Jump to content

Talk:Drowned World Tour 2001 (video)/GA1

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

GA Review[edit]

GA toolbox
Reviewing

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: SNUGGUMS (talk · contribs) 14:54, 13 October 2014 (UTC)[reply]


Here is how the article currently compares against the GA criteria:

  • Is it well-written?: Mostly. I've done some tweaking, and have the following comments:
  • For the infobox, use "1:45:00" or "1 hour and 45 minutes" rather than "105 minutes"
    • Sure.
  • Rather than what type of camera was used, I'd include in the lead details on sales.
    • But don't you think that would devoid from WP:LEAD because then there won't be anything about the technicality and just commercial reception. And I don't want to give WP:UNDUE weightage to US release when it was worldwide.
      • I initially didn't see much point in it since her other video albums such as Ciao Italia: Live from Italy mention nothing of the sort in lead, but then again doesn't mention at all within article Snuggums (talk / edits) 07:37, 16 October 2014 (UTC)[reply]
  • In "Background", it would be helpful to mention Rocco by name when mentioning Madonna giving birth.
    • Sorry missed it.
  • A referral link to Drowned World Tour wouldn't hurt
    • Used the {{main}} template
  • I'm not sure it's really necessary to include the detail regarding Canada. Probably better to just say "United States" rather than "North America".
    • Shortened that it skipped Canada.
  • In "Development", the comma after "a video titled Drowned World Tour 2001" is misplaced and should instead go after GHV2
    • Great!
  • In "Synopsis", the section titles shouldn't have italics
    • Actually Carol Clerk's book used it with italics, so I did. But no matter, I removed them.
  • "then husband" should be hyphenated in "dedicated it to her then husband"
    • Tweaked it more, full name was mentioned previously.
  • In "Critical reception, "The reviewer" should be mentioned by name, which is Colin Jacobson
  • "AOL TV Viewer Awards" isn't exactly a prominent award, not sure it's really worth mentioning
    • It was, at that time, I remember when I was in London and and my sister used to vote for it. :D —Indian:BIO [ ChitChat ] 06:10, 16 October 2014 (UTC)[reply]
  • Is it verifiable?: There was one questionable reference I removed myself. Some content has issues, though:
  • FN8 (MTV News) mentions nothing about "The End" appearing towards the show's finale
    • Removed.
  • FN9 (musicOMH) is dead
    • Grrrr. It was working when I did checklinks
  • FN10 (Slant Magazine) links to a general music page, not a review
    • I'm surprised why Checklinks did not throw an error?
  • FN28 (BBC News) mentions nothing about Evita or any interlude
  • FN30 should be listed as Orlando Sentinel, not Orange County Register
  • FN38 (Recording Industry Association of America) mentions certifications, but says nothing about copies sold
    • RIAA link is for the certification only and it is known that platinum for videos implies 100,000 shipped not sales and that's what is mentioned.
  • FN39 (Yahoo! Music) does not mention anything about this album's sales
    • It does, check way down for Paul Grein's extra comments to user queries. Search with "144K"
  • FN42 (IFPI Denmark) lists "Madonna: Live in Detroit" at #5, but not Drowned World Tour
  • FN45 (British Phonographic Industry) also lists certification, but does not explicitly mention copies sold
    • See above. Not needed.
  • FN48 (Syndicat National de l'Édition Phonographique) gives "Error 471"
    • This I can comment out, but I won't delete. SNEP is refurbishing their website as it says and the link might crop up in the future.
  • Is it broad in coverage?: Almost. Aside from focus details mentioned above, my only concern is the AllMusic review as it only gives a star-rating without commentary. Better to replace this with a link giving commentary.
  • AllMusic usually does not give detailed review for videos, it does it only for albums and select songs. For videos and any other releases, like box sets etc, it just gives a star rating.
    • For that exact reason, the link is simply not helpful. I've removed it myself. Snuggums (talk / edits) 07:37, 16 October 2014 (UTC)[reply]
  • Is it neutral?: Yes.
  • Is it stable?: Yes.
  • Is it illustrated, if possible, by images?: Yes.

The article needs work, but I don't think the problems are too extensive. This nomination is on hold for seven days. Get to it!

@SNUGGUMS: I think I addressed all of them. —Indian:BIO [ ChitChat ] 06:10, 16 October 2014 (UTC)[reply]
Now passing :) Snuggums (talk / edits) 07:37, 16 October 2014 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Drowned_World_Tour_2001_(video)/GA1&oldid=1141535418"