Talk:Melian

Requested move

Originally under the title "Melian" an article on Middle-earth character was placed (rated top-importance in M-e context), now relocated at Melian (Middle-earth). Yet there were no sufficient reasons for moving: the Middle-earth character is the only entity called simply "Melian". Currently the only other disambiguated topic is an adjectival formation of Milos, a city in Greece, which also appears in Melian dialogue. Otherwise "Melian" appears only in Luis Melián Lafinur and in names of several other persons mentioned aroud Wikipedia but unlikely to have separate pages:

Michaela Melián, member of FSK (band)
Sara Melian Gabriel, "a well known spiritualist from India" or so Jack Parsons article says
Salvador Melián - mentioned in history section of Liga Paraguaya: Primera División
Melian Stokes, a characater in Pugs and Peacocks by Gilbert Cannan
Juan Carlos Melian, member of Vital Information jazz group
Deborah Melian - mentioned in credits section of Jah Kingdom album
Daniel Sarmiento Melián - in BM Ciudad de Almería handball team
Jackson Melián, member of All-Star Futures Game
Florence Stawell, or in full Florence Melian Stawell
Tyr et Sidon, ou les funestes amours de Belcar et Méliane by Jean de Schelandre

Supposingly the Middle-earth character would be the most probable to be searched by a user and should be given the main namespace, with Milos and Melian dialogue in hatnotes; alternatively Melian (disambiguation) can be created, but only if separate articles on aforetime mentioned topics are written. Súrendil 18:22, 30 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Move discussion in progress

There is a move discussion in progress on Talk:Melian (Middle-earth) which affects this page. Please participate on that page and not in this talk page section. Thank you. —RMCD bot 16:25, 23 February 2021 (UTC)[reply]