Bras Basah coffeeshop murder
Tan Eng Kim | |
|---|---|
 Tan Eng Kim, the vegetable seller murdered in 1973 | |
| Born | Tan Eng Kim c. 1949 |
| Died | 15 September 1973 (aged 24) |
| Cause of death | Fatal stab wound to the heart |
| Nationality | Singaporean |
| Occupation | Vegetable seller |
| Known for | Murder victim |
On 15 September 1973, 24-year-old vegetable seller Tan Eng Kim (Chinese: 陈荣林; pinyin: Chén Rónglín) was attacked and stabbed to death by another man at a coffee shop in Bras Basah, Singapore. The killer was Pehn Kwan Jin (Chinese: 彭广仁; pinyin: Péng Guǎngrén), a 25-year-old seaman who sought revenge against Tan due to a previous dispute, although Pehn denied that he killed Tan out of vengeance and claimed that it was Tan who tried to attack him and he only acted in self-defence. However, the defence was rejected and Pehn was hence found guilty of murdering Tan and sentenced to death in May 1974. Pehn's appeals were dismissed, and he was hanged on 16 April 1976.
Murder[edit]
On 15 September 1973, at about 2am, a stabbing incident happened inside a coffeeshop at Bras Basah, and one man was killed during the stabbing.[1]
The sole victim of the stabbing was identified as 24-year-old vegetable seller Tan Eng Kim, who resided at Woo Mon Chew Road, off East Coast Road. Tan sustained a total of four stab wounds on his stomach and he collapsed outside the boys' toilet after staggering for a distance in the shop. Tan was rushed to Outram Hospital for emergency treatment, but Tan died shortly after his admission to the hospital. It was eventually uncovered through investigations that Tan was likely killed in a possible gang clash and was involved in talks between two rival gangs, and one of the gangs had attacked Tan and therefore killed. Several witnesses, including the employees of the shop and patrons, were interviewed and the police searched for any traces of murder weapons in the scene, but none were recovered.[2] Tan's death was one of the two murder cases to happen within 24 hours during that week itself; a 30-year-old salesman named Kok Chee Onn was murdered outside a bar on the night of the date of Tan's murder.[3]
Professor Chao Tzee Cheng, a senior forensic pathologist, conducted an autopsy on the victim, and he found that out of the four stab wounds on Tan's corpse, one of them penetrated the heart and was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. According to Professor Chao, the severity of the wound was such that it would have caused the death of Tan within ten minutes, due to the massive bleeding from the wound. He also stated that one of the other wounds had cut through the liver (but there was no major loss of blood) and some cuts were also found on the victim's left hand and arm.[4]
On 22 September 1973, it was announced that the police had arrested four gang members in separate locations across Singapore, and two of them were found to be in connection with the murder of Tan Eng Kim,[5][6] and one of these suspects would be charged with murder.[7][8] On that same day, the same suspect, identified as 25-year-old seaman Pehn Kwan Jin, was charged with murder, an offence that mandated the death penalty under Section 302 of the Penal Code. If found guilty of murder, Pehn would be sentenced to hang.[9]
Trial of Pehn Kwan Jin[edit]
Pehn Kwan Jin | |
|---|---|
 Pehn Kwan Jin, the Bras Basah coffeeshop killer | |
| Born | Pehn Kwan Jin c. 1948 |
| Died | 16 April 1976 (aged 27) |
| Cause of death | Execution by hanging |
| Nationality | Singaporean |
| Occupation | Seaman (former) |
| Criminal status | Executed |
| Motive | Revenge |
| Conviction(s) | Murder (one count) |
| Criminal charge | Murder (one count) |
| Penalty | Death |
On 13 May 1974, the murder trial of Pehn Kwan Jin began at the High Court. Pehn was represented by Goh Heng Leong while the prosecution was led by Lawrence Ang, and the trial was presided over by two trial judges – Justice Tan Ah Tah and Justice T Kulasekaram.
The trial court was told that on the date of the murder, the deceased victim Tan Eng Kim was drinking together with his friend Chong Hwang Kee at the coffeeshop in Bras Basah. At the material time, Pehn was also patronizing the shop with his friend Koh Teck Eng., and during a drinks session, Pehn told Koh that he wanted to hit someone, and although Koh advised Pehn to refrain from doing so, Pehn nonetheless stood up and paid the bill, before he approached Tan and in front of witnesses, he brandished a knife and plunged it into Tan's stomach. Tan tried to defend himself by taking a chair and hurled it at Pehn, but Pehn retaliated by throwing a chair at Tan, who managed to run to the back of the coffeeshop and locked the door behind him. However, Tan collapsed shortly after from his wounds and he would be taken to Outram Hospital, where he died upon his arrival. Pehn later fled from the coffeeshop but he was caught at Serangoon Road five days later for the murder.[10][11] Koh, who appeared as a witness, testified that prior to the incident, he learnt that Pehn had been assaulted by Tan and his friends sometime after both Tan and Pehn, who were originally friends, fell out with each other, and the prosecution therefore alleged that Pehn had a motive of wanting to seek revenge against Tan by stabbing him to death on 15 September 1974.[12][13][14] Not only that, Pehn had confessed to the police during interrogation that he indeed stabbed Tan.[15]
Pehn opted to enter his defence in court. He testified that before the murder, he and Tan Eng Kim were friends for more than a year, before a misunderstanding between himself and another friend had caused them to drift apart, and a month after they fell out, Pehn was reportedly assaulted by Tan and his two friends at a bar; Pehn was said to have been treated with unfriendly gazes from Tan, who would bump into him on purpose whenever he passed by him, and this led to Pehn asking Tan inside the toilet why he ignored him and did it to him. Tan responded by assaulting Pehn, who later reported the matter to Joo Chiat Police Station, but the news of the report reached Tan, who allegedly threatened a neighbour on knifepoint and probed him where did Pehn live.[16]
Turning to Tan's death, Pehn said that he only acted in self-defence when he killed Tan,[17] and he recounted that after he and Koh arrived at the coffeeshop at 1am, he saw Tan's gang outside the shop and he feared Tan was looking for him. Later, Tan and a friend (Chong Kwang Kee) sat at a table next to Pehn's and Pehn noticed Tan keeping a knife at his left thigh, and he believed Tan wanted to use it to harm him. Pehn said he tried to have a talk with Tan peacefully but Tan did not reply to him, and after Tan looked away he took a chance to snatch the knife from Tan, and this drove Tan into pushing Pehn down. Pehn testified that after seeing Tan about to grab something from the table, he went at him and got into a scuffle, during which Pehn had stabbed Tan. Pehn said that he was unable to remember the full sequence of events as everything happened so suddenly, but the next thing he remembered was Tan arming himself with two knives and an iron rod inside the kitchen, and he had to hold onto the kitchen doorknob to prevent Tan coming out, before he made his escape.[18][19][20] Overall, Pehn claimed he only acted in self-defence, and he denied murdering Tan out of revenge over their unsettled differences. He also denied telling Koh that he wanted to hit Tan prior to the stabbing.[21][22][23]
On 28 May 1974, Justice T Kulasekaram and Justice Tan Ah Tah delivered their verdict. Justice Kulasekaram, who pronounced the judgement in court, stated that there were three main contentions which both the judges arrived at when reaching the verdict. The first contention was they did not believe Pehn's claim that he wanted to settle his differences peacefully with Tan; the second was that they disbelieved Pehn's claim that he grabbed the knife from Tan; and the third point was the judges rejected the claim of Pehn that he only wielded the knife in self-defence after seeing Tan about to grab something from the counter. Due to these contentations, Justice Kulasekaram pronounced on behalf of the judges that Pehn's claim of self-defence should be dismissed, and given that Pehn had intentionally inflicted the knife wounds on Tan, such that one of the injuries were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, there were sufficient grounds for the trial court to return with a verdict of murder.[24][25]
Therefore, 25-year-old Pehn Kwan Jin was found guilty of murder, and sentenced to death by hanging. Reportedly, Pehn, who was silent and expressionless at the time of sentencing, had tried to escape from the courtroom before the police officers could handcuff him. Pehn was quickly subdued by three of the officers present before he could successfully escape, and was led out of the courtroom thereafter.[26][27]
By October 1974, Pehn was one of the 15 people held on Singapore's death row awaiting their executions, and all of them were convicted of murder. Among the 14 others incarcerated on death row with Pehn, seven of them were responsible for the 1971 Gold Bars triple murders (where a businessman and his two associates were killed for 120 gold bars), two of them were guilty of the 1972 Amoy Street wine shop murder and another one of them was Chelliah Silvanathan, who killed a fellow gang member.[28]
Appeal and execution[edit]
On 17 March 1975, the Court of Appeal rejected Pehn Kwan Jin's appeal, after finding that he had intentionally inflicted the fatal wound onto Tan and caused his death, and they therefore upheld Pehn's death sentence and murder conviction. On the same date itself, the Court of Appeal also rejected the appeal of another murder convict on death row, and upheld the death sentence of the convict Liew Ah Chiew, a former National Serviceman who was found guilty of murdering his superior Hor Koon Seng via a fatal shooting in 1974.[29][30] Liew had since been hanged on 29 November 1975.[31]
On 18 December 1975, Pehn filed a motion for special leave to appeal to the Privy Council in London.[32] However, the motion was rejected by the Privy Council. Likewise, on the same day, the Privy Council also rejected the appeals of both K. Vijayan Krishnan and Jorge Belardo Belleza against their death sentences.[33][34] Vijayan, a labourer from Malaysia, was found guilty of murdering a crane driver Ahora Murthi Krishnasamy in 1973 while Belleza, a Filipino-born mechanic, was convicted of killing his lover Alice Ong in 1974.[35] Belleza and Vijayan were both hanged since then.[36]
In February 1976, it was reported that Pehn and two other prisoners on death row appealed for clemency from the President of Singapore as a final recourse to escape the gallows. However, Pehn's clemency plea was rejected and his death sentence was consequently finalized.[37]
According to a Singaporean Chinese newspaper Sin Chew Jit Poh, it was reported that 27-year-old Pehn Kwan Jin was hanged in Changi Prison on the Friday morning of 16 April 1976.[38]
See also[edit]
References[edit]
- ^ "Youth is stabbed to death". New Nation. 15 September 1973.
- ^ "Farmer knifed to death outside coffee house at 2 am". The Straits Times. 16 September 1973.
- ^ "Salesman killed after row in bar". New Nation. 17 September 1973.
- ^ "咖啡座喝茶闹出命案 菜販被刺殺喪生 嫌兇昨被控公堂". 星洲日报 (Sin Chew Jit Poh) (in Chinese). 14 May 1974.
- ^ "Coffee house murder: Two suspects arrested". The Straits Times. 22 September 1973.
- ^ "涉及與謀殺有關 兩嫌犯前晚落網". 星洲日报 (Sin Chew Jit Poh) (in Chinese). 22 September 1973.
- ^ "警方採取行動逮捕四名歹徒其中兩人相信與謀殺案有關". 南洋商报 (Nanyang Siang Pau) (in Chinese). 22 September 1973.
- ^ "生菓小販遭殺害案 警方已捕兩名嫌兇". 新明日报 (Xin Ming Ri Bao) (in Chinese). 22 September 1973.
- ^ "Berita2 dari mahkamah". Berita Harian (in Malay). 23 September 1973.
- ^ "DEATH IN A COFFEE HOUSE". The Straits Times. 14 May 1974.
- ^ "勿拉士巴沙路去年血案高庭聆訊咖啡座發生爭執被告拔刀刺死者承審法官至現塲巡視". 南洋商报 (Nanyang Siang Pau) (in Chinese). 14 May 1974.
- ^ "勿拉士峇沙路命案續審被吿之友出庭供証目擊死者胸前遭刺被吿透露死者曾與兩人打他". 南洋商报 (Nanyang Siang Pau) (in Chinese). 18 May 1974.
- ^ "高院续审咖啡座命案 一証人供證揭露 被吿爲報仇殺人". 星洲日报 (Sin Chew Jit Poh) (in Chinese). 18 May 1974.
- ^ "咖啡座內命案被告友人昨日供証 指被告事後承認 曾揮利刃刺死者". 新明日报 (Xin Ming Ri Bao) (in Chinese). 18 May 1974.
- ^ "新加坡咖啡座血案高庭開審 被吿所作口供書 承認拔刀刺死者". 新明日报 (Xin Ming Ri Bao) (in Chinese). 14 May 1974.
- ^ "Fatal bar stabbing started with 'unfriendly looks'". The Straits Times. 23 May 1974.
- ^ "Lapuran dari Mahkamah". Berita Harian (in Malay). 23 May 1974.
- ^ "Accused: I snatched knife to use it in self-defence..." The Straits Times. 24 May 1974.
- ^ "新加坡咖啡座命案續審 被吿昨答辯否認 蓄意謀殺陳榮林". 新明日报 (Xin Ming Ri Bao) (in Chinese). 24 May 1974.
- ^ "咖啡座命案被告供述 与死者衝突情形". 星洲日报 (Sin Chew Jit Poh) (in Chinese). 24 May 1974.
- ^ "咖啡座命案被告答辯見死者座旁有刀即搶奪在手揮動否認向其友説要打人". 南洋商报 (Nanyang Siang Pau) (in Chinese). 24 May 1974.
- ^ "Ex-seaman denies killing veg seller". The Straits Times. 25 May 1974.
- ^ "Kwan Jin nafi berniat untuk menikam Eng Kim". Berita Harian (in Malay). 25 May 1974.
- ^ "菜攤助手遇刺喪生被告昨遭判處死刑". 南洋商报 (Nanyang Siang Pau) (in Chinese). 29 May 1974.
- ^ "咖啡座命案审結 被吿殺人償命 高院判處絞刑". 星洲日报 (Sin Chew Jit Poh) (in Chinese). 29 May 1974.
- ^ "Escape bid by sailor who got death". The Straits Times. 29 May 1974.
- ^ "咖啡座内命案審畢 被吿遭判處死刑 聞判圖逃被制服". 新明日报 (Xin Ming Ri Bao) (in Chinese). 29 May 1974.
- ^ "15 WAIT TO BE HANGED". New Nation. 5 October 1974.
- ^ "Soldier loses appeal against death". The Straits Times. 18 March 1975.
- ^ "Rayuan Pribet Ah Chew ditolak oleh 3 hakim". Berita Harian (in Malay). 18 March 1975.
- ^ "Akhirnya dia digantung". Berita Harian (in Malay). 29 November 1975.
- ^ "'No' to doomed trio". New Nation. 18 December 1975.
- ^ "Condemned 3 refused leave to appeal to Privy Council". The Straits Times. 19 December 1975.
- ^ "兩名死囚向樞密院上訴全部都遭駁囘最後希望爲待總統特赦". 南洋商报 (Nanyang Siang Pau) (in Chinese). 19 December 1975.
- ^ "Hukuman mati: Majlis Privy di London tolak". Berita Harian (in Malay). 19 December 1975.
- ^ "Killer hanged at dawn". New Nation. 30 April 1976.
- ^ "Condemned men plead for mercy". New Nation. 12 February 1976.
- ^ "為復仇而殺人 死囚昨晨正法". 星洲日报 (Sin Chew Jit Poh) (in Chinese). 16 April 1976.