Draft:Walter McClure

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Walter J. McClure is Distinguished Senior Fellow and Chairman at Center for Policy Design. Dr. McClure received a BA in ‎philosophy and physics from Yale University ‎in 1959 and a PhD in theoretical physics ‎from Florida State University in 1967. His ‎dissertation research, on nuclear cluster ‎theory, was performed at the University of ‎Tübingen in Germany; he co-authored a ‎book on the subject with his professor, Karl ‎Wildermuth.‎

In 1969, Dr. McClure switched from physics ‎to health care reform policy for reasons ‎having to do with relevance. He worked at ‎InterStudy under Dr. Paul M. Ellwood Jr.’s leadership ‎from 1969 to 1981. At InterStudy, Dr. ‎McClure worked with colleagues on the ‎HMO strategy for health care reform, among ‎other tasks drafting much of the Federal ‎legislation. ‎

Subsequently, Dr. McClure left to start the ‎Center for Policy Studies (now the Center ‎for Policy Design). He directed the Center ‎until his retirement for medical reasons in ‎‎1990. At the Center, Dr. McClure developed ‎Large System Architecture, which is a ‎general theory of why organizations do what ‎they do, and a set of methods to strategically ‎redirect their behavior toward the goals ‎society desires of them. With these methods, ‎Dr. McClure and his colleagues at the Center ‎developed a health care system reform ‎strategy to get better care for less, and ‎developed a National Health Insurance ‎proposal consonant with this strategy. He ‎assisted Medicare, Pennsylvania and ‎Cleveland to implement the first step of the ‎strategy, severity-adjusted outcomes ‎assessment of providers, before his reluctant ‎retirement.‎

Dr. McClure remains chair of the board of ‎the Center but for many years was no longer ‎active in its professional work or ‎management. Recently he resumed some of ‎his professional work. ‎

Professional Biography[edit]

Dr. McClure founded the Center ‎for Policy Design where he developed his Large System Architecture theory. If the organizations in a macrosystem are ‎chronically malperforming—not performing ‎as society wants—it is almost always ‎because the fundamental system structure is ‎flawed and rewards the undesired ‎performance and punishes the desired ‎performance. Difficult as it is, there is no ‎enduring remedy except to restructure the ‎larger system (“macrosystem redesign”) so ‎that it rewards the desired performance and ‎punishes the undesired performance. The ‎policy discipline to accomplish this is what ‎Dr. McClure calls Large System Architecture ‎‎(LSA)—the idea being that if one wishes a ‎system to perform well for society, one must ‎intentionally architect it to do so rather than ‎let the system develop by topsy and ‎historical happenstance.‎

Dr. McClure’s scholarship garnered the ‎support of numerous leaders and professors ‎in higher education and beyond. ‎

Dr. Julio Frenk, President of University of ‎Miami, wrote: “To effectively address the ‎complex policy challenges facing society—‎in health, the economy, education, social ‎justice and more—we need to think both in ‎terms of large, interconnected systems, and ‎in terms of leadership to change them. When ‎I was early in my career, I was influenced by ‎Walter McClure’s approach to analyzing ‎health systems. His theory Large System ‎Architecture and concept of macrosystem ‎design laid out in these essays are important ‎contributions and provide valuable guides ‎for this work.”‎

Dr. David T. Ellwood, Isabelle and Scott ‎Black Professor of Political Economy and ‎Former Dean at Harvard Kennedy School, ‎wrote: “It is time to think big! Sick of ‎never-ending incremental “solutions” that ‎lead nowhere while things keep getting ‎worse? Read Walter McClure. He thinks ‎systems: when everything and everyone ‎seems to be behaving badly, stop blaming ‎them, and start looking for the larger, self-‎reinforcing, system-wide incentives that ‎reward this behavior. And rather radically, he ‎argues that even massive systems and their ‎incentives can be changed. When the effect ‎of most efforts “come a cropper,” it is time to ‎change the rules. Decide what outcomes ‎society wants. Then ensure that those ‎behaving well win rather than lose. Think ‎health care is frighteningly expensive, ‎variable in quality, and unevenly distributed ‎‎—pay people for the outcomes they achieve ‎rather than for simply creating more ‎services. Unhappy with education ‎outcomes—reward good ones. Worry about ‎inequality —reshape market incentives. He ‎has the genius to show how real ‎transformation can be achieved with the ‎right tools for thinking comprehensively, and ‎then plotting the steps that lead to the land ‎we keep promising our children.”‎

Dr. Alain Enthoven, Marriner S. Eccles ‎Professor of Public and Private Management ‎at Stanford University Graduate School of ‎Business, wrote: “In the 1970’s a group of ‎health system reformers met regularly in ‎Jackson Hole, Wyoming. It became known ‎as “The Jackson Hole Group,” and was a ‎place where a diverse group of researchers, ‎policy makers, and medical leaders came to ‎discuss issues and new approaches to reform ‎of the American healthcare system. As part ‎of that group, and in the wider health reform ‎movement Walt kept us focused on the ‎essential role of competition, properly ‎structured, as a tool of incentives. This book ‎is a major contribution to thinking about ‎system reform—health systems and ‎beyond.”‎

Personal History[edit]

Dr. McClure has learned a great deal from ‎his mentor, Dr. Paul Ellwood. As such, Dr. ‎McClure became a generous mentor, and his ‎‎prodigies achieved remarkable success under ‎‎his tutelage. ‎

His first prodigy, Mr. Tim McDonald, is a Senior ‎Fellow at the Center for Policy Design, ‎where he was mentored by Dr. McClure. Mr. ‎McDonald has a B.A. in political science ‎from Hamline University, an M.P.P. in ‎business and government from the Harvard ‎Kennedy School, and a Ph.D. in policy ‎analysis from the Pardee RAND Graduate ‎School. Mr. McDonald is an assistant policy ‎researcher at the RAND Corporation and a ‎visiting researcher at the Program on ‎Negotiation at Harvard Law School. His ‎research focuses on approaches to designing ‎and implementing policy strategy for ‎reforming large systems and applying the ‎methods to socially important systems such ‎as those impacting health and education, the ‎economy, and the national defense. His ‎current projects include analysis of ‎consumer-oriented approaches to changing ‎incentives in the U.S. healthcare system and ‎approaches to U.S. strategic competition. ‎

His second prodigy, Mr. Abdulrahman ‎Bindamnan, is a contributing author at ‎Psychology Today, and some of his editorials ‎appeared in Star Tribune. Mr. Bindamnan ‎earned a B.A. in psychology and religious ‎studies from University of Miami, M.S.Ed. ‎in international educational development ‎from University of Pennsylvania Graduate ‎School of Education, and is pursuing his ‎Ph.D. studies at the University of Minnesota Twin ‎Cities. Mr. Bindamnan met Dr. McClure ‎through mutual publications at the Star ‎Tribune. Mr. Bindamnan is a prolific writer, ‎despite the fact that he is nonnative English ‎speaker and writer. Mr. Bindamnan thus far ‎published 90 articles and essays, 48 of which ‎appeared in Psychology Today. ‎

Public Professional Publications[edit]

Dr. McClure published a number of ‎publications on newspapers in Minnesota, ‎where he resides in Edina, namely in ‎Minnesota Reformer and Star Tribune. His ‎influential publication appeared in Star ‎Tribune, titled, “A friendly letter to pro-life ‎believers” which garnered robust comments ‎and reviews on the newspaper. Dr. McClure ‎has also published two essays on Free ‎Inquiry. ‎

Selected Academic Publications[edit]

• Karl Wildermuth and Walter McClure: Cluster Representations of Nuclei. Springer Tracts in Modern ‎Physics, Volume 41 pp 1-172; DOI:10.1007/BFb0045473‎

• Walter J. McClure: National Health Policy for the 1980s. Competition in the Marketplace: Health ‎Care in the 1980s, 01/1982: pages 73-76; , ISBN: 978-94-011-7395-7, DOI:10.1007/978-94-011-7393-‎‎3_7‎

• Walter McClure, Alain Enthoven, Tim McDonald: How Universal Health Coverage Can Be ‎Done Right. Health Affairs Blog, ‎https://healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20171109.973715/full/‎ • Walter McClure, Alain Enthoven, Tim McDonald: Universal Health Coverage? Why? Health ‎Affairs Blog, http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2017/07/25/universal-health-insurance-why/‎

• Jon B. Christianson, Walter McClure: Incentives For Quality In A Restructured Medical Care ‎System. Policy Studies Journal 09/2005; 9(2):271 - 278., DOI:10.1111/j.1541-0072.1980.tb02203.x‎

• W McClure: Good And Bad Models Of Market Reform For Managed Care. Health Care ‎Management (Philadelphia, Pa.) 11/1995; 2(1):237-60.‎

• W McClure: Health Care Reform Under The 'Buy Right' Strategy. Medical Group Management ‎Journal / MGMA 03/1992; 39(2):16-23, 76, 78-80 passim.‎

• W McClure: Health Care Delivery Systems. Transactions of the Association of Life ‎Insurance Medical Directors of America 02/1988; 71:144-50., ‎DOI:10.1525/maq.1973.4.3.02a00050‎

• W McClure: Competition And The Pursuit Of Quality: a conversation with Walter McClure. Interview ‎by John K. Iglehart. Health Affairs 02/1988; 7(1):79-90.‎

• W McClure: Buying right: Will Good Medicine Drive Out Bad?. The Psychiatric Hospital 02/1988; ‎‎19(2):57-62.‎

• W McClure: Unleashing The Potential: Current Trends And Future Policy Directions. Bulletin of the ‎New York Academy of Medicine 01/1988; 64(1):84-100.‎

• W McClure: The view from the eye of Minnesota's health care hurricane: an interview with Walter ‎McClure, Ph.D., by Richard L. Reece. Minnesota Medicine 01/1988; 70(12):679, 681.‎

• W McClure: The Consequences Of Glut. Michigan Hospitals 02/1987; 23(1):11-5.‎

• W McClure: Buying Right: How To Do It. Business And Health 11/1985; 2(10):41-4.‎

• W McClure: Buying right: The consequences of glut. Physician Executive 09/1985; 13(5):7-10.‎

• W McClure: Incentive Reform: Finding An Alternative To All-Payer Rate Controls. Healthcare ‎Financial Management Journal 04/1985; 39(3):19-23, 26-32.‎

• W McClure: On the Research Status of Risk-Adjusted Capitation Rates. Inquiry 02/1984; 21(3):205-13.‎

• W McClure: On "Health Care In Canada: Patterns Of Funding And Regulation". Journal of ‎Health Politics Policy and Law 02/1984; 8(4):822-3.‎

• W McClure, D Shaller: Variations in Medicare expenditures per elder. Health Affairs 02/1984; ‎‎3(2):120-9., DOI:10.1377/hlthaff.3.2.120‎

• W McClure: Redesigning Benefits Stimulates Cost Consciousness. Business and Health 12/1983; 1(1):23-6.‎

• W McClure: When You Offer People A Free Lunch, They Don't Eat At McDonald’s. They Go To The ‎Ritz. Across the Board 10/1983; 20(8):46-9.‎

• Walter McClure: The Competition Strategy for Medical Care. The Annals of the American Academy ‎of Political and Social Science 08/1983; 468(468):30-47., DOI:10.1177/000271628346800103‎

• W McClure: Competition: Necessary Market Reform. Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons ‎‎05/1983; 68(4):2-4.‎

• W McClure: Directing The Future Of Health Care Costs: Developing A Competitive Market. OH. ‎Osteopathic hospitals 07/1982; 26(6):18-20, 22 concl.‎

• W McClure: Directing The Future Of Health Care Costs: High Vs Low Style Procedures. OH. ‎Osteopathic hospitals 06/1982; 26(5):8-11 contd.‎

• Walter McClure: Implementing a Competitive Medical Care System through Public Policy. Journal ‎of Health Politics Policy and Law 02/1982; 7(1):2-44., DOI:10.1215/03616878-7-1-2‎

• Walter McClure: Structure and Incentive Problems in Economic Regulation of Medical Care. The ‎Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly Health and Society 02/1981; 59(2):107-44., ‎DOI:10.2307/3349753‎

• W McClure: The Role Of Competition. Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 01/1981; 57(1):45-‎‎50.‎

• W McClure, L K Ellwein, D Aquilina: Competition: theory and practice in Minneapolis-St. Paul. The ‎Internist 12/1980; 21(10):8-11.‎

• W McClure, L Kligman: Reducing excess capacity: closing down or converting hospital facilities may be ‎easier said than done. Cost containment 06/1980; 2(10):3-6.‎

• Walter McClure: An Incentive Tax for Medicare, Medicaid, and National Health Insurance. Journal ‎of Health Politics Policy and Law 02/1980; 5(1):10-24., DOI:10.1215/03616878-5-1-10‎

• W J McClure: Indications, Process And Implications Of Hospital Closure. Proceedings of the ‎Health Policy Forum. Health Policy Forum 02/1980.‎

• W McClure: Reorganize The System To Set Up A Competitive Structure, Review - Federation of ‎American Hospitals 10/1979; 12(5):25.‎

• W McClure: Cost containment: choices for medical care. Pennsylvania Medicine 07/1979; 82(6):14-23.‎

• W McClure: "You don't have a choice between change and no change". Interview by Merian Kirchner, ‎Medical Economics 04/1979; 56(5):143, 147, 149 passim.‎

• W McClure: Choices For Medical Care. Minnesota Medicine 05/1978; 61(4):261-71.‎

• Walter McClure: On Broadening the Definition of and Removing Regulatory Barriers to a ‎Competitive Health Care System. Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law 02/1978; 3(3):303-‎‎27., DOI:10.1215/03616878-3-3-303‎

• W McClure: Regulation Only Choice If Private Sector Cannot Control Health Costs. Hospital Progress ‎‎01/1978; 58(12):6, 10.‎

• W McClure: Benefits Of Reducing Excess Hospital Capacity. Hospital Progress 08/1977; 58(7):7, 10-1.‎

• W McClure: Too Many Beds, Not Enough Market Pressures Fuel Hospital Cost Rocket. Hospital ‎Financial Management 02/1977; 31(1):10-2, 14, 16 passim.‎

• Walter McClure: The Medical Care System Under National Health Insurance: Four Models And Their ‎Prospects. Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law 02/1976; 1(1):22-68., DOI:10.1215/03616878-‎‎1-1-22‎

• W McClure: National health insurance and HMOs. Nursing Outlook 02/1973; 21(1):44-8.‎

• Walter Jackson McClure: The Ground State of Lithium7 and Beryllium7. Dissertation 1967, ‎Florida State University

References[edit]