Murder of Ching Bee Ing
Ching Bee Ing | |
|---|---|
 Ching Bee Ing, the 26-year-old murder victim | |
| Born | Ching Bee Ing 1969 |
| Died | 8 August 1995 (aged 26) |
| Cause of death | Murdered |
| Nationality | Malaysian |
| Other names | To-to |
| Occupation | Prostitute (former) |
| Employer | A brothel at Teck Lim Road |
| Known for | Murder victim |
| Spouse | Unnamed husband |
| Children | 2 |
On 8 August 1995, a 26-year-old prostitute named Ching Bee Ing (曾美婷; Zēng Meǐtíng) was stabbed seven times by her 35-year-old co-worker Teo Kim Hong (张金凤; Zhāng Jīnféng) at a brothel along Teck Lim Road. Ching, a Malaysian, died as a result of four fatal knife wounds to her liver and heart. Teo, a Singaporean, was charged with murder after she was arrested for the brutal stabbing. Teo was found guilty and sentenced to death in January 1996,[1] and after the loss of her appeal, Teo was hanged on 30 August 1996.[2]
Murder[edit]
On 8 August 1995, at a brothel along Teck Lim Road, a prostitute was stabbed seven times by one of her co-workers, who was restrained by a 70-year-old male customer before the police were contacted and arrived to apprehend the attacker. A diving knife was also seized from the assailant.[3]
The 26-year-old Malaysian-born victim of the stabbing incident, identified as Ching Bee Ing (alias To-to), was mortally wounded and died by the time an ambulance arrived. She was a popular prostitute who often received customers requesting for her services due to her personality and beauty, and she was a well-mannered colleague to her co-workers.[4] According to Dr Wee Keng Poh, a senior forensic pathologist, he examined the body and stated that out of the seven knife wounds on the corpse of Ching, four of these wounds were fatal and they penetrated the liver and heart; he pointed out that based on the severity of the injuries, either one of these stab wounds alone was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature.[5] Ching, who was born and raised in the Malaysian state of Sarawak, was married with a pair of twin daughters and had one older brother and a few more siblings in her family. Ching reportedly lied to her family that she was working as a waitress in a restaurant in Singapore and hid the fact that she was a prostitute, a truth which brought sadness and shock to her kin upon her death. Her husband travelled from Kuala Lumpur to Singapore to reclaim her body.[6]
Meanwhile, Ching's alleged killer, a 35-year-old Singaporean named Teo Kim Hong, was officially arrested and charged with murder. Background information revealed that Teo and Ching were friends but they fell out shortly before the murder. Teo herself left school at age eleven and she gave birth to one son at age sixteen; the son (aged 20 in 1996) was serving his National Service as of the time his mother was charged with killing Ching.[7] Furthermore, it was revealed that Teo herself was a distant cousin of Lim Ban Lim,[8] who was one of Singapore's most notorious gunmen and the perpetrator behind the murder of police corporal Koh Chong Thye in 1968. Lim was later killed by police during a gunfight in 1972.[9][10]
Trial and sentencing[edit]
On 17 January 1996, Teo Kim Hong claimed trial for one count of murdering Ching Bee Ing, and her case was heard at the High Court. Teo was represented by both Winston Mok and Tan Teow Yeow while both David Khoo and Beverly Wee were appointed as the trial prosecutors. The murder trial was presided by Judicial Commissioner Choo Han Teck.
The court was told that the defendant Teo and Ching Bee Ing often come together to provide their services to the customers.[11] However, during the prior week before Ching's death, Teo and Ching fell out after they clashed over serving a client. Several witnesses, mainly those who frequent the brothel or worked at the brothel, testified that six days before her death, Ching was assaulted by Teo after she finished servicing a male customer, and Ching never fought back during the assault, choosing to apologise to Teo.[12][13][14]
Teo testified in court that she fell out with Ching because of Ching allegedly insulting her boyfriend, and she also believed that Ching was responsible for infecting her boyfriend with a sexually-transmitted infection.[15] She even claimed that she received a phone call from Ching's boyfriend who threatened her for what she did to Ching,[16][17] and Teo also blamed Ching for an argument she had with her boyfriend, after Teo's boyfriend got wind of Teo providing oral sex to her clients at the brothel.[18] Out of anger over their personal issues, Teo decided to confront Ching, starting with going to a shopping mall to purchase a diving knife from the Mall's diving equipment store.[19] Teo claimed her intention of bringing the knife was merely for self-defense instead of causing any hurt to Ching. However, the prosecution argued that based on the evidence before the court, it was evident that Ching never provoked Teo or even acted negatively towards the defendant, and it was clear that Teo herself had the premeditated intent to commit murder and voluntarily inflicted seven knife wounds on the defenceless victim while she was resting in her room, with a view to cause severe bodily harm that was sufficient to lead to Ching's death. Therefore, they submitted that Teo should be convicted of murder in their final submissions before sentencing.[20][21][22]
On 24 January 1996, after a five-day trial, Judicial Commissioner Choo delivered his judgement. He rejected Teo's claims that she was under grave and sudden provocation at the time of the murder, and also did not accept her other claims of having no intent to cause bodily harm to Ching, effectively rejecting the allegations Teo made against Ching for supposedly insulting her boyfriend. Judicial Commissioner Choo stated that it was clear that Ching was unarmed and defenceless and that she was resting alone when Teo barged in to slap her and confront her, which made her more of an aggressor in this case. Teo's decision of bringing a knife with her was also a telling sign that she intended to use it to harm Ching, and it demonstrated her premeditation to cause injury to Ching as well. Since Teo had intentionally stabbed Ching seven times, such that four of the knife wounds were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, and Teo herself had the premeditation to commit the offence of murder, Teo was considered guilty under the law.[23][24]
As such, Judicial Commissioner Choo found 36-year-old Teo Kim Hong guilty of murder, and sentenced her to death.[25] Under the laws of Singapore, the death penalty was mandated as the sole punishment for murder upon conviction, and there was no discretion to sentence such offenders to any other punishment aside from death. According to news reports, Teo was expressionless at the time of sentencing, and her elderly mother was very hysterical at the verdict of death, so much so that she collapsed in court after Teo was led away.[26] Teo's older brother Teo Cheow Kim even openly shouted an expletive at the trial judge for sentencing his younger sister to death.[27]
As a result of the murder, according to the brothel owner, his business fell sharply due to the public attention focused on the murder that took place there.[28]
Fate of Teo Kim Hong[edit]
After she was sentenced to death, Teo filed an appeal against her conviction and sentence, but on 26 March 1996, the Court of Appeal unanimously rejected Teo's appeal, dismissing her claims of a sudden fight and lack of premeditation in committing the murder, and they did not call for the prosecution to reply prior to turning down her appeal.[29][30][31]
On 30 August 1996, 36-year-old Teo Kim Hong was hanged in Changi Prison at dawn.[32] On the same date of Teo's execution, three more convicts on death row were put to death at the same prison; one of them was Zainal Abidin Abdul Malik, who brutally murdered a police officer Boo Tiang Huat in November 1994,[33][34] before receiving a death sentence for the crime in July 1995.[35]
Aftermath[edit]
Eleven years after Teo was executed, in May 2007, her older brother Teo Cheow Kim was found guilty of trafficking 30.37g of diamorphine and sentenced to death; the trial judge of her brother's case was Choo Han Teck, who was coincidentally the same judge that sent Teo to the gallows for murdering Ching Bee Ing.[36] One of Teo's cousins Lim Ah Tee (younger brother of notorious gunman Lim Ban Lim)[37] was also charged in the same drug case as Teo's brother before he received a discharge not amounting to an acquittal.[38][39][40] Teo's brother was since executed after losing his appeal in November 2007.[41]
As a result of her brother's conviction for drug trafficking, Teo Kim Hong's case was recalled and it was regarded as one of the high-profile cases of women receiving the death penalty in Singapore during the last decade.[42]
See also[edit]
References[edit]
- ^ "杀恭锡街之花 妓女死刑". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 24 January 1996.
- ^ "They paid for their crimes with their lives". New Paper. 31 August 1996.
- ^ "Prostitute arrested for murder after brothel death". The Straits Times. 9 August 1995.
- ^ "恭锡街艳妓 睡梦中遇剌". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 10 August 1995.
- ^ "'恭锡街之花'胸挨7刀死". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 17 January 1996.
- ^ "恭锡街之花给家人的美丽谎言： '我在酒楼当待应长'". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 11 August 1995.
- ^ "被告受教育不多福建话也讲不好". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 24 January 1996.
- ^ "Caught with 30g of heroin". The New Paper. 14 May 2007.
- ^ "Guilty As Charged: Lim Ban Lim was most wanted gunman in Singapore and Malaysia in 1960s". The Straits Times. 14 May 2016.
- ^ "涉贩毒被控·判无事省释 林万霖弟弟逃死刑". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 31 March 2007.
- ^ "女被告和死者 同一娼寮接客". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 18 January 1996.
- ^ "Prostitute on trial for knifing colleague to death". The Straits Times. 18 January 1996.
- ^ "妓女在娼寮内遭'姐妹'刺七刀毙命". Lianhe Zaobao (in Chinese). 18 January 1996.
- ^ "妓院女老板供证揭露 案发前6天被告痛打死者". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 18 January 1996.
- ^ "案发前两个月 被告患性病疑遭死者连累". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 23 January 1996.
- ^ "查案警曹长供证： 被告称质问死者为何叫人恐吓她". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 19 January 1996.
- ^ "恭锡街之花被杀 被告今午判死刑". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 24 January 1996.
- ^ "被控谋杀恭锡街之花 被告供称 死者叫男友恐吓她". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 23 January 1996.
- ^ "女被告案发前夕 买了一把锋利潜水刀 涉嫌猛刺死者前胸7次". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 17 January 1996.
- ^ "Prostitute admits she was angry with murder victim". The Straits Times. 24 January 1996.
- ^ "死者遭痛打·还跪地道歉". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 24 January 1996.
- ^ "恭锡街之花被杀 被告今午判死刑". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 24 January 1996.
- ^ "Prostitute gets death for killing colleague". The Straits Times. 25 January 1996.
- ^ "潜水刀穿心 杀'恭锡街之花'妓女被判死刑". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 24 January 1996.
- ^ "Prostitute gets death for killing colleague". The Straits Times (Overseas). 27 January 1996.
- ^ "IN COURT". New Paper. 26 January 1996.
- ^ "妹当年判死刑时 兄向法官爆粗口". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 14 May 2007.
- ^ "Business down after murder". New Paper. 26 January 1996.
- ^ "Prostitute loses appeal against death sentence for stabbing colleague". The Straits Times. 27 March 1996.
- ^ "谋杀「恭锡街之花」 被判死刑 被告上诉驳回". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 26 March 1996.
- ^ "杀死'恭锡街之花'判死刑 妓女上诉遭驳回 逃不过鬼门关". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 26 March 1996.
- ^ "恭锡街之花被杀 女被告今早上绞台". Shin Min Daily (in Chinese). 30 August 1996.
- ^ "Trafficker, murderers hanged". The Straits Times. 2 September 1996.
- ^ "四名死囚正法". Lianhe Zaobao (in Chinese). 31 August 1996.
- ^ "Man who killed policeman with axe to be hanged". The Straits Times. 16 July 1995.
- ^ "兄妹11年内遭同法官判死刑". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 14 May 2007.
- ^ "涉嫌对公务员动粗案 贩毒判死刑男子 与林万霖弟同被捉". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 13 May 2007.
- ^ "涉贩毒被控·判无事省释 林万霖弟弟逃死刑". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 31 March 2007.
- ^ "双枪大盗 林万霖弟弟 逃过 死刑". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 31 March 2007.
- ^ "Gunman's brother escapes death penalty". The New Paper. 14 May 2007.
- ^ "林万霖表弟 死刑上诉被驳回". Lianhe Wanbao (in Chinese). 12 November 2007.
- ^ "Some other women who got the death sentence". The New Paper. 14 May 2007.