| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Untitled |
67 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 1#Untitled
|
| Assessment comment |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 1#Assessment comment
|
| Newly-added section with issues |
22 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Newly-added section with issues
|
| long confusing irrelevant section |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#long confusing irrelevant section
|
| China, Manchu, Qing, or Ch'ing, take your pick |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#China, Manchu, Qing, or Ch'ing, take your pick
|
| Replace Chinese View? |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Replace Chinese View?
|
| Requesting consensus discussion |
18 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Requesting consensus discussion
|
| Seek consensus to modify error in statement |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Seek consensus to modify error in statement
|
| Basic Rewrite Please! |
9 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Basic Rewrite Please!
|
| Move material from Righteous Harmony Society |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Move material from Righteous Harmony Society
|
| citation needed |
9 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#citation needed
|
| Slaughter, rape, and pillage |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Slaughter, rape, and pillage
|
| Restored? |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Restored?
|
| Image copyright problem with File:55 Days.jpeg |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Image copyright problem with File:55 Days.jpeg
|
| BMS internal link |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#BMS internal link
|
| The article is totally unneutral. Be careful of those spiritual betrayers: Christians. Culture and belief conflict analysis |
15 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#The article is totally unneutral. Be careful of those spiritual betrayers: Christians. Culture and belief conflict analysis
|
| The article needs a comprehensive spell-check. |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#The article needs a comprehensive spell-check.
|
| Let's get back to business |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Let's get back to business
|
| Prescriptivism or compromise? |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Prescriptivism or compromise?
|
| merge proposal |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#merge proposal
|
| Page Protection |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Page Protection
|
| Fiction |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Fiction
|
| Picture: US MArines or Army? |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Picture: US MArines or Army?
|
| Gods and ghosts |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Gods and ghosts
|
| Gods and ghosts |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Gods and ghosts
|
| Section to be moved |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Section to be moved
|
| Section to be moved |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Section to be moved
|
| War reparations |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#War reparations
|
| War reparations |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#War reparations
|
| Dagu (Taku) Forts |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 2#Dagu (Taku) Forts
|
| Dagu (Taku) Forts |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Dagu (Taku) Forts
|
| Warning- this article is not a place to spew anti Manchu propaganda |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Warning- this article is not a place to spew anti Manchu propaganda
|
| The foreign casualty rate was beyond the 200% mark. |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#The foreign casualty rate was beyond the 200% mark.
|
| Original Boxer text |
11 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Original Boxer text
|
| Rewrite of the article |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Rewrite of the article
|
| [3] |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#[3]
|
| File:Beijing Castle Boxer Rebellion 1900 FINAL.jpg to appear as POTD soon |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#File:Beijing Castle Boxer Rebellion 1900 FINAL.jpg to appear as POTD soon
|
| Bias |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Bias
|
| NPOV |
10 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#NPOV
|
| No personal attack |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#No personal attack
|
| Westeners treated chinese christians more savagely than boxers |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Westeners treated chinese christians more savagely than boxers
|
| POV Dispute |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#POV Dispute
|
| "Orgy of looting" |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#"Orgy of looting"
|
| User:Arilang1234 blatantly removing sourced information and falsely stating that a source is about "art" |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#User:Arilang1234 blatantly removing sourced information and falsely stating that a source is about "art"
|
| Jane E Elliott's book |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Jane E Elliott's book
|
| Apparently Arilang has not read wikipedia policy |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Apparently Arilang has not read wikipedia policy
|
| Let's take a look to Arilang1234's earliest "contributions", to this article |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Let's take a look to Arilang1234's earliest "contributions", to this article
|
| Personal Attack |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Personal Attack
|
| Lynn Bodin |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Lynn Bodin
|
| Peter Harrington,Michael Perry |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Peter Harrington,Michael Perry
|
| Albert Feuerwerker,S. Cheng |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Albert Feuerwerker,S. Cheng
|
| Larry Clinton Thompson |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Larry Clinton Thompson
|
| Response to Arilang's copy and paste and speculation |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Response to Arilang's copy and paste and speculation
|
| Xiaorong Han of Butler University |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Xiaorong Han of Butler University
|
| Lead section's controversial text |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Lead section's controversial text
|
| User:Arilang1234 has a serious problem with grasping the concept of "POV" |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#User:Arilang1234 has a serious problem with grasping the concept of "POV"
|
| 侯宜傑 |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#侯宜傑
|
| I would like an explanation from Arilang inserting "undefined", which caused broken links all over the article |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#I would like an explanation from Arilang inserting "undefined", which caused broken links all over the article
|
| User:Arilang1234 falsely accuses me of Communist propaganda, but he himself uses communist sources. |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#User:Arilang1234 falsely accuses me of Communist propaganda, but he himself uses communist sources.
|
| Yuan Weishi |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Yuan Weishi
|
| According to Arilang, Leo Tolstoy and Mark Twain are Communist propaganda activists |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#According to Arilang, Leo Tolstoy and Mark Twain are Communist propaganda activists
|
| The Kuomintang has also called Western Christian missionaries imperialist |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#The Kuomintang has also called Western Christian missionaries imperialist
|
| User:Arilang1234 pushing blatant POV, violating concensus, and refuses to talk out disputes with me before editing the article |
20 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#User:Arilang1234 pushing blatant POV, violating concensus, and refuses to talk out disputes with me before editing the article
|
| Why is Arilang1234 inserting Cantonese terms, when all the Boxers and northerners spoke Mandarin? |
19 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Why is Arilang1234 inserting Cantonese terms, when all the Boxers and northerners spoke Mandarin?
|
| Lead cleanup |
25 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Lead cleanup
|
| The Gelaohui Bandits of Sun Yatsen- Hui muslims supported Manchus against Dr. Sun's Gelaohui bandits |
7 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#The Gelaohui Bandits of Sun Yatsen- Hui muslims supported Manchus against Dr. Sun's Gelaohui bandits
|
| Yuan Weishi unreliable- Yuan lies about Ronglu, claiming he was pro Boxer, in reality, Ronglu was pro foreign and anti Boxer |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 3#Yuan Weishi unreliable- Yuan lies about Ronglu, claiming he was pro Boxer, in reality, Ronglu was pro foreign and anti Boxer
|
| Lead part 2 |
21 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Lead part 2
|
| Source: Prince Qing's Manchu Bannermen fought against Kansu braves, in favor of the foreigners |
19 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Source: Prince Qing's Manchu Bannermen fought against Kansu braves, in favor of the foreigners
|
| This article is pushing a single viewpoint and needs to be revised. |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#This article is pushing a single viewpoint and needs to be revised.
|
| Mass Vandalism by ip 208.64.63.176 |
10 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Mass Vandalism by ip 208.64.63.176
|
| This article contains many errors |
16 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#This article contains many errors
|
| Copyright violation by User:Binesi |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Copyright violation by User:Binesi
|
| The Chinese forces never wanted to attack the legations, it was the foreigners who started the firing |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#The Chinese forces never wanted to attack the legations, it was the foreigners who started the firing
|
| Living in China does not qualify you as an expert in Chinese related articles |
7 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Living in China does not qualify you as an expert in Chinese related articles
|
| Solution |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Solution
|
| Grammar and section work |
12 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Grammar and section work
|
| Gaselee Expedition |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Gaselee Expedition
|
| Article needs to be re-written AND Дунгане should be banned |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Article needs to be re-written AND Дунгане should be banned
|
| Boxer Uprising? |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Boxer Uprising?
|
| Regarding WP:CIVIL |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 4#Regarding WP:CIVIL
|
| Peaceful Chinese Intention? |
7 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Peaceful Chinese Intention?
|
| regarding questions some had about the origins section |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#regarding questions some had about the origins section
|
| Non Neutral Standpoint and poorly written |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Non Neutral Standpoint and poorly written
|
| Edits to the lede |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Edits to the lede
|
| i have found reliable sources for chinese use of electric mines and works refering to torpedoes |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#i have found reliable sources for chinese use of electric mines and works refering to torpedoes
|
| Atrocities section |
9 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Atrocities section
|
| "Western" |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#"Western"
|
| Conflicting attitudes within the Imperial Court section |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Conflicting attitudes within the Imperial Court section
|
| Another source which said alliance forces raped but chinese did not |
7 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Another source which said alliance forces raped but chinese did not
|
| "Abundance of Rain" is NOT a WP:Reliable source |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#"Abundance of Rain" is NOT a WP:Reliable source
|
| Tolstoy |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Tolstoy
|
| Lead section |
27 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Lead section
|
| Broken/wrong citations |
13 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Broken/wrong citations
|
| Ronglu deliberately gave conflicting orders to General Nie to make the imperial army fight the boxers and sabotage his performace against western forces |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Ronglu deliberately gave conflicting orders to General Nie to make the imperial army fight the boxers and sabotage his performace against western forces
|
| Muslim Kansu Braves or Wuwei Troop |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Muslim Kansu Braves or Wuwei Troop
|
| Han Troops or Wuwei Front Troop |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Han Troops or Wuwei Front Troop
|
| Dubious picture caption |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Dubious picture caption
|
| Historical books |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Historical books
|
| Arilang1234's edits |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Arilang1234's edits
|
| When did the Boxer Rebellion begin? |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#When did the Boxer Rebellion begin?
|
| We need a clearer narrative |
7 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#We need a clearer narrative
|
| Change the structure? |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Change the structure?
|
| Change Article Name to "Boxer Uprising"? |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Change Article Name to "Boxer Uprising"?
|
| Chester Biggs as an unreliable source for the events leading to the uprising |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Chester Biggs as an unreliable source for the events leading to the uprising
|
| Holocaust and Boxer Deniers - welcome to Wiki |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Holocaust and Boxer Deniers - welcome to Wiki
|
| Notes on Sources and Proposed Edits in Notes |
9 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Notes on Sources and Proposed Edits in Notes
|
| Re-removing Images of Heavenly Pig and Zeng Guoquan |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Re-removing Images of Heavenly Pig and Zeng Guoquan
|
| The "bias" in the article: various interpretations of the Boxers |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#The "bias" in the article: various interpretations of the Boxers
|
| Remove Neutrality Templates? |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Remove Neutrality Templates?
|
| Russian Invasion of Manchuria and Other Planned Revisions |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Russian Invasion of Manchuria and Other Planned Revisions
|
| Rework Chinese Forces Section? |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Rework Chinese Forces Section?
|
| Siege of the Legations section |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Siege of the Legations section
|
| Translation of "Yihequan" and "Yihetuan": modify throughout? |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Translation of "Yihequan" and "Yihetuan": modify throughout?
|
| Who first used "Boxers" for Yihetuan? |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Who first used "Boxers" for Yihetuan?
|
| Requested move to Boxer Uprising |
36 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 5#Requested move to Boxer Uprising
|
| Bibliography and Further Reading: A New Approach |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Bibliography and Further Reading: A New Approach
|
| Two new wikis concerning the Boxers |
6 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Two new wikis concerning the Boxers
|
| Removed Koekkoek Drawing |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Removed Koekkoek Drawing
|
| Add the southern viceroys in the infobox along with the eight nation alliance |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Add the southern viceroys in the infobox along with the eight nation alliance
|
| Reluctantly cut section "False Propaganda" |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Reluctantly cut section "False Propaganda"
|
| Merge discussion |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Merge discussion
|
| Neutrality Review |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Neutrality Review
|
| Removal of request for citations |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Removal of request for citations
|
| Removal of quote and source |
19 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Removal of quote and source
|
| Further Reading Section |
7 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Further Reading Section
|
| Citing Sources |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Citing Sources
|
| Revised lede |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Revised lede
|
| Dragon chair or Dragon Throne |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Dragon chair or Dragon Throne
|
| Ketteler attacking a Chinese |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Ketteler attacking a Chinese
|
| Chinese names and characters for events and peoples during the rebellion |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Chinese names and characters for events and peoples during the rebellion
|
| Many Allied soldiers dropped dead, foaming from the mouth due to the extreme heat. |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Many Allied soldiers dropped dead, foaming from the mouth due to the extreme heat.
|
| This article could use some revision to reflect a more neutral pov |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#This article could use some revision to reflect a more neutral pov
|
| Red Lanterns |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Red Lanterns
|
| Gaselee Expedition: Gruesome Details and Atrocities at Times |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Gaselee Expedition: Gruesome Details and Atrocities at Times
|
| Debate at the imperial court |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Debate at the imperial court
|
| Question about involvement of other nations |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Question about involvement of other nations
|
| Military of the Qing dynasty, Muslim Gansu Braves |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Military of the Qing dynasty, Muslim Gansu Braves
|
| The Kansu Braves, World War 2 and the Muslim Ma Clan |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#The Kansu Braves, World War 2 and the Muslim Ma Clan
|
| Infobox image neutrality |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Infobox image neutrality
|
| Million Award, anyone? |
9 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Million Award, anyone?
|
| Sources for data |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Sources for data
|
| Western views of China |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Western views of China
|
| actual number of Russian troops in Manchuria was 200,000 |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#actual number of Russian troops in Manchuria was 200,000
|
| A note on Edgerton as a source for Russian occupation of Manchuria |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#A note on Edgerton as a source for Russian occupation of Manchuria
|
| Russian newspaper editorial criticizing Russian atrocities |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Russian newspaper editorial criticizing Russian atrocities
|
| Casualty figures |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Casualty figures
|
| No USMC at embassy in Beijing? |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#No USMC at embassy in Beijing?
|
| Third Party requested in advance of formal RFC arbitration; Seymour's Expeditions "Luckily" found the Boxer's rifle cache |
5 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Third Party requested in advance of formal RFC arbitration; Seymour's Expeditions "Luckily" found the Boxer's rifle cache
|
| Great Wall |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Great Wall
|
| Separate article for the actual 'Boxer' organisation |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Separate article for the actual 'Boxer' organisation
|
| British India |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#British India
|
| Order to kill foreigners |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Order to kill foreigners
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#External links modified
|
| Beheading photos |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Beheading photos
|
| References to Li Hongzhang are not linked |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#References to Li Hongzhang are not linked
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#External links modified 2
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#External links modified 3
|
| Jerzy mess |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Jerzy mess
|
| Opium mentioned. Europeans trying to get opium? |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Opium mentioned. Europeans trying to get opium?
|
| Casualty Figures are Wrong; Evidence of Trolling |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Casualty Figures are Wrong; Evidence of Trolling
|
| Reverting confused and badly sourced "origins" material from Guenon |
4 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Reverting confused and badly sourced "origins" material from Guenon
|
| This article is broken |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#This article is broken
|
| Provenance of the photo captioned "A Boxer is publicly executed" |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Provenance of the photo captioned "A Boxer is publicly executed"
|
| Korea's involvement |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion#Korea's involvement
|
| A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion
|
| Canada's involvement |
2 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Canada's involvement
|
| Wiki Education assignment: Research Seminar in Digital and Public History |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion/Archive 6#Wiki Education assignment: Research Seminar in Digital and Public History
|
| Do not plagiarize sources |
1 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion#Do not plagiarize sources
|
| Picture |
3 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion#Picture
|
| Leadership |
8 |
Talk:Boxer Rebellion#Leadership
|
