| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| At the moment the article isn't neutral |
21 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#At the moment the article isn't neutral
|
| Important update on numbers by Grabowski |
46 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Important update on numbers by Grabowski
|
| additions to "Works" |
6 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#additions to "Works"
|
| Judenjagd |
12 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Judenjagd
|
| Little details |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Little details
|
| Misusage of Snyder's words |
10 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Misusage of Snyder's words
|
| Official position? |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Official position?
|
| Strange summary of Musiał-Grabowski discussion |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Strange summary of Musiał-Grabowski discussion
|
| Response of BLP subject to serious accusations |
33 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Response of BLP subject to serious accusations
|
| Negative/positive review |
7 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Negative/positive review
|
| RfC - Neutrality and how to fix it |
35 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#RfC - Neutrality and how to fix it
|
| Hunt for the Jews - summary |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Hunt for the Jews - summary
|
| The book, vividly describing Judenjagd (German for "Jew hunts") in Poland |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#The book, vividly describing Judenjagd (German for "Jew hunts") in Poland
|
| Samsonowska's critics of the Polish edition of Judenjagd |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Samsonowska's critics of the Polish edition of Judenjagd
|
| Michael Fleming |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 1#Michael Fleming
|
| You can't be serious |
17 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#You can't be serious
|
| Wojtyla |
22 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#Wojtyla
|
| "None of the 134 signatories is a Holocaust historian" |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#"None of the 134 signatories is a Holocaust historian"
|
| Death threats issue, reprise |
7 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#Death threats issue, reprise
|
| "Vividly describing" |
17 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#"Vividly describing"
|
| Krystyna Samsonowska |
5 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#Krystyna Samsonowska
|
| Grabowski retracts the 200 000 number |
24 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#Grabowski retracts the 200 000 number
|
| Blanket revert |
48 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#Blanket revert
|
| "Himka notes that the Polish men of the Baudienst" |
7 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#"Himka notes that the Polish men of the Baudienst"
|
| Canadian? |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 2#Canadian?
|
| Nationalists |
16 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Nationalists
|
| County name |
10 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#County name
|
| Puffery - "Historian" - for grad student writing a review on a website |
8 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Puffery - "Historian" - for grad student writing a review on a website
|
| Radio interview |
11 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Radio interview
|
| Misrepresentation of sources |
10 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Misrepresentation of sources
|
| Another false edit summary |
22 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Another false edit summary
|
| BLP Vio? |
13 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#BLP Vio?
|
| Response to Berendt |
12 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Response to Berendt
|
| Reviews - inclusion criteria and ordering |
18 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Reviews - inclusion criteria and ordering
|
| BLP subject views |
19 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#BLP subject views
|
| On restructuring content |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#On restructuring content
|
| Dariusz Stola's review |
31 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Dariusz Stola's review
|
| Grabowski's views |
8 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Grabowski's views
|
| As the BBC noted, this was a "blunt instrument" in efforts to control the study of Poland's past. |
9 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#As the BBC noted, this was a "blunt instrument" in efforts to control the study of Poland's past.
|
| Sharfman |
7 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Sharfman
|
| Musiał |
6 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Musiał
|
| Grabowski's new claim |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 3#Grabowski's new claim
|
| Nobility |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Nobility
|
| There are no Polish bystenders in the Holocaust |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#There are no Polish bystenders in the Holocaust
|
| Methodology |
12 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Methodology
|
| Ethnic marking of sources and implied doubt |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Ethnic marking of sources and implied doubt
|
| Were the Blue Police Polish? |
5 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Were the Blue Police Polish?
|
| The 200,000 story |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#The 200,000 story
|
| Parents - names |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Parents - names
|
| “Came from a family of Polish nobility” |
11 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#“Came from a family of Polish nobility”
|
| References |
6 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#References
|
| Prof. Grabowski's father |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Prof. Grabowski's father
|
| It's a BLP |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#It's a BLP
|
| The 200 000 story |
22 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#The 200 000 story
|
| POV tag? |
17 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#POV tag?
|
| Recent edits |
13 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Recent edits
|
| present themselves as Holocaust experts |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#present themselves as Holocaust experts
|
| Dąbrowa, a rural county |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 4#Dąbrowa, a rural county
|
| 200,000 anti-Polish propaganda |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#200,000 anti-Polish propaganda
|
| Hunt for the Jews |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Hunt for the Jews
|
| Removed per BLPREMOVE |
10 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Removed per BLPREMOVE
|
| The page should be edited |
17 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#The page should be edited
|
| Reception of the book |
16 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Reception of the book
|
| Revised 200,000? |
11 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Revised 200,000?
|
| fringe far right organization |
8 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#fringe far right organization
|
| Dąbrowa Tarnowska County |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Dąbrowa Tarnowska County
|
| Are Grabowski's opinions notable? |
12 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Are Grabowski's opinions notable?
|
| Not The Dark Ages but dark years |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Not The Dark Ages but dark years
|
| Recent additions |
27 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Recent additions
|
| Troubling sourcing.... |
25 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Troubling sourcing....
|
| UNDUE, FRINGE, NOENG |
16 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#UNDUE, FRINGE, NOENG
|
| Problem with source... |
16 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Problem with source...
|
| Glaukopis |
9 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Glaukopis
|
| ZH |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#ZH
|
| Tags |
11 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Tags
|
| Dispute with Daniel Blatman, Israeli historian and professor of Modern Jewish history and Holocaust Studies at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Dispute with Daniel Blatman, Israeli historian and professor of Modern Jewish history and Holocaust Studies at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem
|
| Sourcing policy |
30 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Sourcing policy
|
| Behind a paywall... |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 5#Behind a paywall...
|
| Wildstein translations |
40 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Wildstein translations
|
| The answer to POV concerns is NOT to make the article even more slanted |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#The answer to POV concerns is NOT to make the article even more slanted
|
| Holocaust Studies journal vs. BLPPRIMARY use of Dobrego Imienia and biznesistyl.pl |
5 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Holocaust Studies journal vs. BLPPRIMARY use of Dobrego Imienia and biznesistyl.pl
|
| Proposal to streamline the article |
6 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Proposal to streamline the article
|
| IPN's statement about exhibition |
12 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#IPN's statement about exhibition
|
| "for deconstructing political myths and propaganda that partly still persist in Polish history, journalism, church, and politics" |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#"for deconstructing political myths and propaganda that partly still persist in Polish history, journalism, church, and politics"
|
| Jewish-Polish journalist Bronisław Wildstein |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Jewish-Polish journalist Bronisław Wildstein
|
| with three other Holocaust historians |
7 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#with three other Holocaust historians
|
| Academic lies |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Academic lies
|
| 40,000 |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#40,000
|
| Grabowski and his co-authors requested |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Grabowski and his co-authors requested
|
| "The Polish Police" |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#"The Polish Police"
|
| Where was he baptized? |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Where was he baptized?
|
| "Dispute with Daniel Blatman" |
11 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#"Dispute with Daniel Blatman"
|
| The Judenjagd was the German search for Jews who had escaped from the liquidated ghettos in Poland |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#The Judenjagd was the German search for Jews who had escaped from the liquidated ghettos in Poland
|
| he believes 200,000 |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#he believes 200,000
|
| The Polish Police - sources |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#The Polish Police - sources
|
| Frydel is due |
5 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Frydel is due
|
| Please don't vandalize |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Please don't vandalize
|
| Were Judenjagd and Dalej jest noc given expert review pre-publication? |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Were Judenjagd and Dalej jest noc given expert review pre-publication?
|
| Lawsuit |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Lawsuit
|
| Polish League Against Defamation |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Polish League Against Defamation
|
| Grabowski's opinon about his own article |
5 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Grabowski's opinon about his own article
|
| Further reading vs external links |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Further reading vs external links
|
| Verdict in Poland |
2 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#Verdict in Poland
|
| August 2021 edit |
5 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 6#August 2021 edit
|
| Enemies of Grabowski with conflict of interest editing this page |
3 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski/Archive 7#Enemies of Grabowski with conflict of interest editing this page
|
| New opinion piece |
1 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski#New opinion piece
|
| The WP-thing |
6 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski#The WP-thing
|
| Number of supporters |
9 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski#Number of supporters
|
| Wikipedia criticism |
4 |
Talk:Jan Grabowski#Wikipedia criticism
|
