Talk:Mina Khel
 | This article was nominated for deletion on 11 Sept. 2006. The result of the discussion was redirect to Marwat. |
This small piece on Mina Khel was earlier redirected by me and was merged with the main article on Marwat. But the unidentified editor has once again created this article with a dubious assertion which is far from being true. It contradicts the entire main article on Marwat. -- Marwatt 15:29, 10 September 2006 (UTC)
Comment[edit]
No need to delete this article. Mina Khel tribe is the ruling clan of Marwat Tribe, for past 300 years. Beside this, there are many of ten thousands Mina Khels, those must be govena seprate identity. There are many famous personalities in Mina Khels, one i.e. Khan Habibullah Khan reached the position of President, Chief Justice, Chairman Senate, Minister and other vbarious positions. We must have seprate page for this big clan.
KEEP or DELETE[edit]
There is no need of redirection now, as there is too much posted on the Mina Khels on the same page.
Beside this, when an article is tagged for Deletion, it must have one of the following results.
Delete
Speedy Dlete
Keep
or
Speedy Keep
Redirection was a suggestion not a result nor an order.
The article is kept, this means that the article is having it's own position and name.
I in immense endeavour, will promote this article by valueable information, that will soon be added here.
A M. Khan 21:25, 1 November 2006 (UTC)
Article should remain to itself.[edit]
This is unfair, totally unfair that an article of a Nation, of a very big clan and tribe of a nation Marwat is redirected and not given a separate space.
I would like the administration to review its decission and the article be given its own value i.e. to be a page for Mina Khels, that is very famous tribe of Pakhtuns.
Please, review.
There is no need to create a seperate article[edit]
Mina Khel is a small family of the bigger tribe of Marwat. Are they bigger then Begukhel, Issak Khel, Maidad Khel, Ghazni Khel, Shashan Khel, Abbad Khel, Dallo Khel etc. All of these big villages are much bigger in size. --Marwatt 14:33, 7 November 2006 (UTC)
There is a massive need for a separate article[edit]
Yes, there is a massive need of a separate article. The tribe is too big.
If any one has any doubt about this family, (S)he can check Mina Khels or Meena Khels on search engines. They themselves will come to know the fact. Mina Khels are no doubt very well known clan.
Regards,
A M. Khan 18:25, 7 November 2006 (UTC)