Talk:Petrine doctrine

Text and/or other creative content from this version of Petrine doctrine was copied or moved into Primacy of Simon Peter with this edit on 13:42, 18 May 2012. The former page's history now serves to provide attribution for that content in the latter page, and it must not be deleted as long as the latter page exists.

This article was nominated for merging with Primacy of Simon Peter on 17:51, 18 May 2012. The result of the discussion was no disagreement.

I have merged this page with Primacy of Simon Peter and have placed a tag for merger on this page. If I see no major disagreement with the merger and subsequent edits, I will edit this page to redirect. MatthewEHarbowy (talk) 17:51, 18 May 2012 (UTC)[reply]

MatthewEHarbowy (talk) 04:01, 2 June 2012 (UTC)[reply]

There was no consensus for a merge, in my opinion.

redirect page Petrine doctrine was created to Primacy of the Roman Pontiff on 2006-09-07
redirect page was changed into article on 2007-11-26
added {{orphan}} on 2007-12-17
replaced {{orphan}} with {{Mergeto}} on 2009-01-13
article was linked from Pastor aeternus on 2009-01-24
removed {{Mergeto}} on 2011-10-29 with edit summary "very old merge proposal won no support"
several months later {{merge}} was added on 2012-05-18T13:35:59 with edit summary "contents seem similar but written from different points of view. 'primacy' has more NPOV"
about 7 minutes later copied into Primacy of Simon Peter on 2012-05-18T13:42:18 with edit summaries like "merged from [Petrine doctrine"]
created Talk:Petrine doctrine on 2012-05-18T13:51:58‎ with edit summary "I have merged this page with Primacy of Simon Peter and have placed a tag for merger on this page. If I see no major disagreement with the merger and subsequen..."
created Talk:Primacy of Simon Peter##merger proposal with Petrine doctrine on 2012-05-18T13:58:39 where the editor agreement after the fact.
blanked this page as {{R from merge}} on 2012-06-02 with edit summary "redirect"

The Catholic Petrine doctrine is only one facet of primacy of Simon Peter. It is a fundamental aspect of the Catholic Church's self identity: "There is no one characteristic, apart from the Petrine doctrine, which sets the Catholic Church apart from all other churches". It is codified in the 1983 Code of Canon Law canon 330 that "as by the Lord's decision Saint Peter and the other Apostles constitute one college" and commentaries explains "that the canon is treating a matter of divine law" about that relationship. I think it should have retained its own short article linked from a summary paragraph.

I left this comment as I read and look how to detangle several related articles that duplicate content.

—BoBoMisiu (talk) 16:42, 12 June 2015 (UTC)[reply]