| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Simple Solution to Hardest Problem |
6 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Simple Solution to Hardest Problem
|
| What's the problem? |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#What's the problem?
|
| The problem of measuring gain/loss |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#The problem of measuring gain/loss
|
| Another proposed solution |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Another proposed solution
|
| History of the problem |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#History of the problem
|
| Three envelopes |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Three envelopes
|
| Commentary 1 |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Commentary 1
|
| I think it starts off wrong |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#I think it starts off wrong
|
| solution |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#solution
|
| Solution |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Solution 2
|
| Simple Solution |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Simple Solution
|
| Very simple solution to the 'Two envelopes paradox' |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Very simple solution to the 'Two envelopes paradox'
|
| Problematic problem formulation |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Problematic problem formulation
|
| Comments on Comments |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Comments on Comments
|
| Problem Supposedly Solved |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Problem Supposedly Solved
|
| Possible solution |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Possible solution
|
| Comments about the Paradox and the Flaw |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Comments about the Paradox and the Flaw
|
| Please see if i have a point here: |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Please see if i have a point here:
|
| Tell me if I'm wrong, but... |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Tell me if I'm wrong, but...
|
| step 6 |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#step 6
|
| Solving the real problem |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Solving the real problem
|
| Frequentist vs Bayesian distinction |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Frequentist vs Bayesian distinction
|
| The original two-envelope problem is not a paradox |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#The original two-envelope problem is not a paradox
|
| Why is there so much debate over this? |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Why is there so much debate over this?
|
| Here is the correction to the switch argument |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Here is the correction to the switch argument
|
| My Solution |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#My Solution
|
| Mathematical Fallacy |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Mathematical Fallacy
|
| Solution to original paradox is much simpler |
4 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Solution to original paradox is much simpler
|
| Not up to Wiki standards |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 1#Not up to Wiki standards
|
| Two envelopes without probability: summary of solutions |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Two envelopes without probability: summary of solutions
|
| Schwitzgebel and Dever |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Schwitzgebel and Dever
|
| Open letter to Schwitzgebel and Dever |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Open letter to Schwitzgebel and Dever
|
| Schwitzgebel and Dever's simple solution |
19 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Schwitzgebel and Dever's simple solution
|
| Dubious importance |
8 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Dubious importance
|
| Puzzled |
30 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Puzzled
|
| The theorem |
14 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#The theorem
|
| Richard's change to the problem in the lead |
61 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 5#Richard's change to the problem in the lead
|
| TEP Synthesis |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#TEP Synthesis
|
| My simple resolution - has this been covered in the literature? |
12 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#My simple resolution - has this been covered in the literature?
|
| Two neckties as two envelopes: the math |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Two neckties as two envelopes: the math
|
| What goes wrong |
4 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#What goes wrong
|
| Great expectations (Broome example) |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Great expectations (Broome example)
|
| Locate the error in steps 1 to 12 |
6 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Locate the error in steps 1 to 12
|
| The heart of the matter |
5 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#The heart of the matter
|
| Why steps 9 to 12 of the TEP "switching argument" is complete nonsense, while step 7 can only be correct if unknown presuppositions were given. |
31 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 2#Why steps 9 to 12 of the TEP "switching argument" is complete nonsense, while step 7 can only be correct if unknown presuppositions were given.
|
| iNic's arguments: |
18 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 3#iNic's arguments:
|
| Ancestral TEP |
50 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 3#Ancestral TEP
|
| Ultra Simple Solution |
172 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 3#Ultra Simple Solution
|
| What is the paradox? |
28 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#What is the paradox?
|
| Why the first resolution is false |
4 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 3#Why the first resolution is false
|
| The 'simple solutions' explained |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#The 'simple solutions' explained
|
| The philosopher's stone |
35 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#The philosopher's stone
|
| This is not a paradox. |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#This is not a paradox.
|
| Random Question |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Random Question
|
| A possible fault |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#A possible fault
|
| The stated problem ignores the value of the chosen envelope, which is lost on swapping. |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#The stated problem ignores the value of the chosen envelope, which is lost on swapping.
|
| Critique 1 |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Critique 1
|
| Critique 2 |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Critique 2
|
| The not switching argument |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#The not switching argument
|
| The symbol A stands for different things??? |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#The symbol A stands for different things???
|
| My solution @zazaalaza |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#My solution @zazaalaza
|
| Flawed Logic |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Flawed Logic
|
| What am I missing? |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#What am I missing?
|
| Ali Baba Variant |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Ali Baba Variant
|
| Odd Solution? |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Odd Solution?
|
| Rationalization to the non-probabilistic approach |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Rationalization to the non-probabilistic approach
|
| Randomized solutions |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Randomized solutions
|
| Where is the problem? |
3 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Where is the problem?
|
| Solution idea by Tsikogiannopoulos |
41 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Solution idea by Tsikogiannopoulos
|
| Solution idea by Tsikogiannopoulos |
17 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Solution idea by Tsikogiannopoulos 2
|
| Flawed Analysis |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Flawed Analysis
|
| Common resolution |
7 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Common resolution
|
| Core resolution |
63 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 5#Core resolution
|
| Simplest, verbal, resolution |
6 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#Simplest, verbal, resolution
|
| YADD (Yet another difficult description) |
2 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 4#YADD (Yet another difficult description)
|
| The philosopher's solution |
17 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 5#The philosopher's solution
|
| The paper by Ishikawa |
17 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 5#The paper by Ishikawa
|
| More thoughts on classifying resolutions (and therefore problems) |
30 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments#More thoughts on classifying resolutions (and therefore problems)
|
| YADD: an argument resumed |
12 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments/Archive 5#YADD: an argument resumed
|
| Question |
1 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments#Question
|
| Error in formulation? |
29 |
Talk:Two envelopes problem/Arguments#Error in formulation?
|
