Talk:Wishology/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Pedro J. ^{the rookie} 20:09, 22 June 2011 (UTC)

Okay this artical seems quit ready for a GA except for some details

• In the Kiss picture it is said the the band guest started, but reading the artical is says just two members lended their voices, could you change it in the image so it says which members guest started.
  • Done 89119 (talk)
• This is just a personal thing but could you add some Alt to the images.
  • Done 89119 (talk)
• The George Lucas image dose not have a good example of Alt.
  • Done - Elaborated more on the George Lucas alt. 89119 (talk)
• Has this episode ever been released on DVD?
  • Currently, there are no news of the DVD release on Wishology; a Google search would not return any results of it. 89119 (talk)
• The part were it says the other series Guy Moon has worked in seems irelevent (even if they are all created by Hartman)
  • Done - Removed the mention of two other series. 89119 (talk)
• Could you please add that Kiss is a rockband.
  • Done 89119 (talk)
• guest actor Gary Sturgis. What dose guest actor mean?
  • Done - Changed from "guest actor Gary Sturgis" to "actor Gary Sturgis". 89119 (talk)
• Why are the opinions of the reviewers inbetween each other?
  • It is to show the comparison of any same aspect in the TV film between two reviewers. i.e. Turbo Thunder is praised by Bynum while criticized by Cruz. 89119 (talk)

Well thats all my thoughts. fix those things and it will Pass. --Pedro J. ^{the rookie} 20:09, 22 June 2011 (UTC)

Passed, I must encorage you to review an artical which is on the list when you have time to. Also I belive that this artical is quit closeto FA material. Pedro J. ^{the rookie} 01:08, 23 June 2011 (UTC)