Talk:Xbox 360/GA1
Failed GA[edit]
I failed this article because:
- No references in Xbox Live and Interface section.
- A lengthy bulleted list in the Hardware section
- Few pictures in Overview, Xbox Live, and Software section.
Some P. Erson 15:11, 12 August 2006 (UTC)
- Anything that can be referanced in those sections I will be getting sources for after this post
- I'm not realy sure what you want referances in the UI section, it's a section that doesn't realy seem to need referances.
- Adding anything I thought needed referancs. Please tag[citation needed] to anything else you want referances in the Live section r interface
- I'll put a survey here to see on what we should cut out of the bulleted list to make it shorter.
- Any pictures added to the article are removed quickly, I've tried adding some that I feel add to the article, but they are always removed. (Under the basis that they are only fair use in the section main article, not on this page) Can't fix that one by myself.
- Jigahurtz has added the images that greatly add to UI section, that may be referance to what you wanted there.
- Xbox Live UI images added, flow perfectly with the two Jiga added.
- Suggestion for overview, live and software images?
- Anything that can be referanced in those sections I will be getting sources for after this post
70.101.201.248 15:47, 12 August 2006 (UTC)
- According to the criteria, a lack of images does not in itself prevent an article from achieving Good Article status. So no need to turn on "insert-picture" mode, just concentrate on the other stuff. -- ReyBrujo 18:27, 17 August 2006 (UTC)