User:Bigger digger/Third Opinions

Template

{{User:Bigger digger/doing3O}} is a template I created in my userspace to allow for an introduction to the 3O on an article talk page.

Use {{subst:User:Bigger digger/doing3O}} to include it in a talk page, it is self-signing.

My Third Opinions

A list of my third opinions, generally found from WP:3 but occasionally stumbled upon. Listed with most recent conversation at the top:

Ongoing

Resolved but still watched

Resolved, not watched

Date Collected	Article	Dispute	Last Contribution	Current Situation
2010-09-20	Template:Canadian mobile phone companies - dispute	Is a mobile company regional or national/major?	2010-09-20	await response
2009-06-09	Friends of the Western Buddhist Order - dispute	Weight of criticism section, general neutrality	2009-06-09	Seems to suffer from WP:UNDUE because of insufficient WP:Reliable sources. Also reported it to WP:BLP/N due to concerns over the criticism of the ex-leader. WP:ELs are excessive. It will take a lot of work to right this one!
2009-06-06	Fan Expo Canada - dispute	CoI'd editor disputing removal of future info by IP editors	2009-06-06	Statements need WP:V from WP:RS. Suggest article might need rewrite. Awaiting reponses.
2009-06-05	Raw milk - dispute	Inserting more information on the pro-raw milk position	2009-06-05	One editor seems to have disappeared. Will monitor and try to improve.
2009-06-04	International High IQ Society - dispute	Non-profit or not?	2009-06-04	No source, so can't state either way. Also, barely any sources to establish notability. Awaiting comments.
2009-06-03	Elena Paparizou - dispute	Description of singer as "Greek, born in Sweden" or "Greek/Swedish"	2009-06-05	Suggested maintain as is (there was previous consensus for "Greek, born in Sweden") or remove nationality altogether. There was some progress, now awaiting further comment
2009-06-02	Battle of Isandlwana - dispute	One editor felt the lead contained unnecessary information about British weaponry	2009-06-02	A third editor offered an opinion, I agreed with that and so consensus essentially achieved. Dissenting editor hadn't edited on talk page, but with two other editors clearly in favour of the status quo, no need to watch.
2009-06-02	Judith A. Reisman - dispute	Inclusion of similar research, but without WP:RS link between them.	2009-06-04	Editors agreed with my opinion
2009-05-27	Battle of Panipat (1761) - dispute	NPOV of quote used in article	2009-05-27	Suggested it's not NPOV but in wrong place, that editors need to actually engage in a debate, and that there are more important issues that need addressing in the article.
2009-05-26	Guns, Germs, and Steel - dispute	Use of headings within the article, stumbled upon this dispute	2009-05-27	Discussed with one editor, who changed my mind. Other editor seems to have accepted the edits.
2005-05-25	List of tools for static code analysis - dispute	Inclusion of an external link in main article	2009-05-25	Suggest that external links are not appropriate as per MoS and ELNO
2009-05-19	The Unloved - dispute	Inclusion of a direct link to 4 on Demand, the online video site for the UK's Channel 4	2009-05-19	Advised that link was in contravention of WP:ELNO but not a problem as programme site links to it.
2009-05-18	List of The Suite Life on Deck episodes - dispute	The name of an episode had changed, how should it be listed?	2009-05-20	Offered opinion that listing both in the column was the best way to serve users. Consensus achieved.
2009-05-16	Rangers F.C. - dispute	Addition of sectarianism info by newish editor	2009-05-16	Left message at User_Talk:SeekerAfterTruth which seemed to diffuse the situation
2009-05-13	Matter - dispute	Definition of matter	2009-05-13	Many editors involved, suggested a way forward.
2009-05-13	Philadelphia Union - dispute	NFC-use of a secondary logo	2009-05-13	Logo was removed by the editor
2009-05-13	Daydream (Mariah Carey album) - dispute	Various issues across the article	2009-05-13	Wasn't suitable for a WP:3O as not formatted very well and plenty of editors, but left advice
2009-05-12	Al Farooj Fresh and Mimi Lesseos	Editor not using WP:3O correctly, trying to save from (I think) speedy deletion	2009-05-12	Not watched, gave advice to User:Roaring Siren here
2009-05-06	Intel Corporation - Dispute	IP user wanting to insert info that had WP:V, WP:N & WP:OR issues	2009-05-09	Consensus was there before I arrived, resolved. Welcomed IP editor. Weeks later, issue sent to ArbCom who declined it. I think the IP editor is fairly single purpose but can't work out how to help them.
2009-05-06	The Adventures of Mimi Tour - Dispute	Sales and revenue for a Mariah Carey tour	2009-05-06	Seemed to be old and or resolved before my arrival
2009-05-06	Simon Darby - Dispute	Insertion of info on BNP member's podcast	2009-05-08	Consensus apparently reached not to include, but still watching the page
2009-05-05	Yaakov Shwekey - dispute	Insertion of links to commercial music site for every song	2009-05-08	Resolved. links removed, but watching for {{fact}} issue
2009-04-29	El Sobrante, California - dispute	Insertion of resident - is she sufficiently notable?	2009-05-08	Removed heat from dispute, next edit awaited