User:Calton/Userfied pages

Executive summary

A statistical breakdown of pages moved to their creators' user pages by RHaworth (talk · contribs · blocks · protections · deletions · page moves · rights · RfA).

Purpose: To see how appropriate these actions were, to assess the admin's judgment, and by tracking the states of the userfied pages and the creators's contributions to Wikipedia.

Survey Range:

From December 2005/February 2006 to August 2006 (6-8 months previous). Period was selected to allow sufficient time for the users to build up their edits and see if they were, in fact, going to do so. Duplicate pages and user subpages were excluded.

User Pages:

Number moved since December 2005:

About 420

Number of user pages surveyed:

102

Vanity pages?

Among the 102 pages surveyed:

• Yes: 80 (79.2%)
• Maybe: 14 (13.9%)
• No: 5 (5.0%)
• Deleted/Unknown: 3 (3.0%)

Edit counts

For the 102 users surveyed (not including deleted edits):

• Average: 15.86
• STD: 67.41
• Median: 4.00

Edit counts excluding Beckjord (talk · contribs) (not including deleted edits):

• Average: 9.48
• STD: 19.65
• Median: 4.00

Edit count distribution

Edit Counts - Editors with totals

Since December 2005 - February 2006:

Number of edits made	Number of editors	Percentage of total
no edits	2	2.0%
1 edit	16	15.7%
2 edits	18	17.6%
3 edits	10	9.8%
4-6 edits	28	27.5%
7-15 edits	15	14.7%
16-25 edits	3	2.9%
25-50 edits	5	4.9%
51-100 edits	3	2.9%
101-200 edits	1	1.0%
more than 200 edits	1	1.0%
TOTAL	102	100.0%

Data

No.	user	Original page	date moved	Vanity article?	Total edits	user space edits*	Article edits	Other edits	Notes
1	User:Benacious	Benacious	12/1/05 5:27	Yes	6	6	0	0	Currently blocked: expires April 10 2007
2	User:Everlyor seo	William Everly	12/1/05 19:38	Yes	5	3	2	0	Added own work to Portrait
3	User:Jmishka	Compuelitist	12/1/05 20:20	Yes	5	4	1	0
4	User:Kalish	Kalish Domestique	12/2/05 6:27	Yes	6	6	0	0
5	User:Orinmoon	Orinmoon	12/2/05 6:57	No	8	1	4	3
6	User:Ikognito	Craig Ramano	12/2/05 19:17	Yes	13	7	6	0	All but 1 article edits to Pharrell Williams, inserting bits about himself (calling himself the boyfriend of Williams)
7	User:H Cornellier	Hugo Cornellier	12/6/05 7:38	No	60	18	35	7
8	User:Anthonyahmed	Sheraz inc	12/7/05 17:59	Yes	6	5	1	0
9	User:Larryroeder	Larry Winter Roeder, Jr.	12/10/05 7:59	Yes	2	2	0	0
10	User:Sonicfan93	Demented Dimention	12/11/05 8:31	Yes	3	1	2	0	Redirect of Apple dave
11	User:Erickson.lind	Erickson Lind	12/11/05 9:59	Yes	1	1	0	0	Not merely vanity, ridiculous vanity
12	User:Gregcoghill	Greg j coghill	12/11/05 21:54	Yes	1	1	0	0
13	User:Bigdaddymiller	Miller, jackie dean	12/12/05 18:02	Yes	7	7	0	0
14	User:Robin81700	"Robin Slick"	12/12/05 18:23	Yes	2	2	0	0
15	User:GunBlade132	Treijim	12/12/05 18:38	Yes	2	2	0	0
16	User:Oxx italian babi	Kaylene	12/12/05 19:08	Yes	1	1	0	0
17	User:Autodescom	Michael Van Steenburg]]	12/13/05 11:02	Yes	2	1	1	0	Added self to List of mechanical engineers. Removed by RHaworth
18	User:Osumailguy	Tis gar plen	12/13/05 18:32	Yes	4	4	0	0
19	User:Itasat	Itasat	12/14/05 22:09	Yes	6	6	0	0
20	User:Abrahamlincoln	Polly Pockets-Helberg	12/15/05 5:51	Yes	8	8	0	0	Page is about the user's DOG, with an enormous photo
21	User:Aking	Adam King	12/16/05 8:10	Yes	164	84	56	24
22	User:Dradoowdarb	Brad Woodard	12/16/05 9:00	Yes	4	4	0	0
23	User:Anshumangaur	Anshuman Gaur	12/18/05 8:00	No	18	3	15	0
24	User:Alexandr Busa	Alexandr Busa	12/18/05 18:30	No	41	3	36	1
25	User:EVB	Jacob Price	12/18/05 21:10	Yes	1	1	0	0
26	User:Pcallioni	Patrick Callioni	12/19/05 7:42	Yes	5	3	1	1	Created Australian Government Information Management Office, his workplace. No mention of self.
27	User:PeterGay	Peter Trevino	12/19/05 8:39	Yes	23	16	0	7	A REALLY LONG vanity article. Also, A DRV posting asking his speediliy deleted vanity-press stories be undeleted.
28	User:Cyeh	C. J. Yeh	12/19/05 18:54	Yes	2	2	0	0
29	User:Spiderwebmaster	Werner Keller	12/20/05 6:40	Yes	14	6	6	2	All article edits are to his own article, now redirected to Liberal Party candidates, 2006 Canadian federal election
30	User:Awxdotcom	Ramek	12/30/05 7:04	Yes	39	13	25	1	Long original essay
31	User:Masplantiz	Masplantiz	1/4/06 12:45	Maybe	1	1	0	0
32	User:Catastrophia	Thomas skabar	1/4/06 18:20	Yes	1	1	0	0
33	User:Colle1	Ronald colle	1/5/06 18:54	Yes	1	1	0	0
34	User:Albert644	Mostyless entertainment	1/6/06 9:39	Yes	2	2	0	0
35	User:Tresbigdog	Tresbigdog	1/7/06 18:10	Yes	3	1	2	0	Both article edits (to Lake Naivasha) are vandlism
36	User:Belakor	Belakor	1/7/06 18:42	Yes	6	6	0	0
37	User:Desmond.Kidney	Dr. daniel davidson	1/9/06 10:45	Yes	2	2	0	0
38	User:Scottiedog	Kirsty Crawford	1/9/06 18:34	deleted
39	User:Revolucion07	The kez	1/9/06 18:40	deleted
40	User:Afan1	Christopher james roberts	1/9/06 19:36	Yes	3	1	0	2	The two edits are to a photo of himself, orphaned and unlinked to his user page
41	User:DeMann6654	(TNA)DarkSide	1/10/06 11:55	Yes	1	1	0	0
42	User:HAAkuromo	Kuromo	1/10/06 12:18	No	8	4	4	0
43	User:Bryce Beverlin II	Deathproj	1/11/06 11:29	Yes	1	1	0	0
44	User:Varanashi	Varanashi	1/11/06 15:15	Yes	2	2	0	0	"I am very sorry, but I feel that all your contributions are just blatant advertising and unsuitable for Wikipedia."
45	User:Daviddeer	Richard Chorley Golf Artist	1/11/06 15:24	deleted	0	0	0	0	Deleted by Xezbeth, 24 May 2006
46	User:O.d.	O.d.	1/11/06 19:26	Yes	1	1	0	0
47	User:Joeingraham	Joe ingraham	1/11/06 19:55	Yes	2	1	1	0
48	User:8r13n	8r13n	1/13/06 19:03	Maybe	66	21	30	15
49	User:Language-cspndnt	Judy Mullins	1/13/06 19:27	Yes	29	2	26	1	vanity article deleted - see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Judy Mullins
50	User:Beckjord	Beckjord	12/8/05 10:33	No	661	341	155	165	Currently blocked: expires April 10, 2007
51	User:DennisMichael	Dennis Michael	2006/1/14 6:51	Yes	4	2	2	0	Created KIDabra International, own org
52	User:Mihalakis	Mikhail karikis	2006/1/14 12:00	No	3	3	0	0	Blanked user page
53	User:Alexmiller	Alexmiller	2006/1/15 7:53	Yes	2	2	0	0
54	User:Alcino	Alcino FERREIRA	2006/1/15 18:54	Yes	5	5	0	0
55	User:Milliondollarpage	Milliondollarpage	2006/1/15 19:16	Yes	3	2	1	0	Added link to self (now redirected elsewhere) to The Million Dollar Homepage
56	User:Hemm74	Hemm74	2006/1/16 11:02	Yes	1	1	0	0	Story pitch
57	User:Connor Anderson	Ian Harbord	2006/1/16 18:31	No	56	25	21	11	Indef blocked as sockpuppet of User:Barbara Osgood
58	User:Blomkvist	Brian Blomkvist	2006/1/17 18:38	Yes	6	2	4	0	Nonsense vanity page. Added said nonsense to Malice
59	User:Trifon	Trifon	2006/1/17 19:47	Yes	7	4	3	0
60	User:Djnotepad	Djnotepad	2006/1/18 14:15	Yes	4	4	0	0
61	User:Pariguayo	Sandy reyes	2006/1/19 5:18	Yes	1	1	0	0
62	User:Homie1091	Homie1091	2006/1/19 5:40	Maybe	3	2	1	0
63	User:Redigieren	Lee Fricke	2006/1/19 6:20	Yes	3	2	0	1	Edit Wikipedia:Requested articles/Social Sciences and Philosophy, asking for an article on himself
64	User:Beauby grech	Beau Grech	2006/1/19 10:25	Maybe	3	3	0	0
65	User:Phils1982	Philip Schonewille	2006/1/20 2:42	Yes	15	4	10	1
66	User:Cpulfer	Adrian Pulfer	2006/1/20 4:08	Yes	2	1	1	0	Added "crude copyvio" to John Tait (football)
67	User:Bioeddie	Bioeddie	2006/1/20 19:14	Yes	5	5	0	0
68	User:Vuchihai	Vu Chi Hai	2006/1/20 20:03	No	2	2	0	0
69	User:Vanibahl	Vani bahl	2006/1/20 20:15	Yes	14	12	2	0	Nine external links. Added self to 1973
70	User:Georgeandlewis	U6GovD1	2006/1/21 11:58	Yes	28	17	9	2
71	User:Walsh415bostoncollege	Adam Bied	2006/1/23 9:11	Yes	2	2	0	0
72	User:Michiganesian	Vinayak aggarwal	2006/1/23 20:25	Yes	5	5	0	0
73	User:Catherine4567586	Judy Mullins	2006/1/24 20:14	Yes	1	1	0	0
74	User:Jamesahn	James Ahn	2006/1/24 21:22	No	5	2	3	0	Added self to Ahn
75	User:Pablo1950	Pablo M. Falcón	2006/1/25 17:01	Yes	4	3	1	0	Only article edit vandalism in June
76	User:Mystelious	Teo floor	2006/1/25 22:44	Yes	4	2	2	0	Nonsense vanity page.
77	User:Alexsopp	Johan Olav Sopp	2006/1/26 12:16	Yes	4	4	0	0
78	User:Seifabdoun	Christina Campo-Abdoun	2006/1/27 9:43	Yes	29	2	27	0
79	User:Major Chavez	ZEGREENBASTARD	2006/1/28 8:00	Yes	6	4	2	0	User claims bio is of someone else
80	User:Thepeople	Sam grist	2006/1/28 10:30	Yes	4	3	1	0
81	User:Layet	Layet	2006/1/28 18:46	No	1	1	0	0	Nonsense page - still has "verify" tag
82	User:Legodude522	Legodude522	2006/1/29 10:11	Yes	2	1	1	0	Created E tellurian -- speedy attack article on 8/16
83	User:Andrech	André Christensen	2006/1/29 10:30	Yes	2	2	0	0
84	User:Matiasjansen	Matias Jansen	2006/1/29 19:10	Maybe	18	18	0	0
85	User:Gadgetoid	Gadgetoid	2006/1/31 1:19	Yes	2	2	0	0
86	User:Digitalcoup	John Young (Cryptome)	2006/1/31 5:56	Yes	5	5	0	0
87	User:Altmannaj	Anthony Altmann	2006/1/31 15:49	Yes	2	2	0	0
88	User:Travelinghamagency	Traveling Ham Agency	2006/1/31 16:33	No	5	0	1	4	Moved user page back to article space with comment "Because it should be a real entry."
89	User:Ygood	Yaakov Goodman	2006/1/31 17:10	Yes	3	3	0	0
90	User:InsideNothing	PM Networking	2006/2/1 3:10	Yes	4	4	0	0
91	User:Legacystar3233	Jesse "Jeskid" Cowell	2006/2/1 3:15	Yes	5	4	1	0
92	User:Nathansands	Nathansands	2006/2/1 3:22	Yes	10	5	5	0	Article edits are to Compassionate Coalition & The Foundation, orgs founded/run by author
93	User:Steev Mike	Steev Mike	2006/2/1 8:06	Yes	4	2	2	0
94	User:Continentalparty	Continental party	2006/2/2 3:27	Yes	15	10	5	0	Six user space edits are to User talk:CambridgeBayWeather and related
95	User:Theblackrider	Cisada	2006/2/2 11:48	Yes	3	3	0	0
96	User:Vijith	Skynettech	2006/2/2 11:56	Yes	10	8	2	0
97	User:Dclobbyist	The C. L. A. Group, LLC	2006/2/2 19:46	No	1	0	1	0	Indef blocked for spamming - not on user page
98	User:Jashfield	Premier bathrooms	2006/2/2 21:36	Yes	11	2	9	0	Article edits are mostly to Walk in bathtub to add company. Also, RHaworth moved another vanity article to User:Jashfield/Gainsborough
99	User:Skifdank	Skif dank	2006/2/3 16:41	No	2	2	0	0
100	User:Asbennett	Anthony Stuart David Bennett	2006/2/3 18:54	Yes	5	4	1	0
101	User:Abidian	Abidian	2006/2/4 19:19	Yes	1	1	0	0
102	User:Yourika	Alexander paul morris	2006/2/5 11:08	Yes	14	8	6	0	Article edits are attempts to add self to financial articles. Log indicates RHaworth also moved Tymorapro and Yourika to the user page.