User:CaroleHenson/sandbox1

Notability and/or merge issues, clean-up needed

6. Robert Hunt (died 1964) 2017-07-16 — notability tag, detail tag, merge tag - probably true, but haven't done searches yet

20. Anne Murray Dike 2017-07-16 — added clean-up and ref improve tags

21. Anne Harriman Vanderbilt 2017-07-15 — significant recent work by someone, request to hide prev versions -- now a close paraphrasing tag and notability tag

24. Lawrence Waldemar Tonner 2017-07-15 —  Done redirect

• This was subsequently returned to a stand-alone article by Elisa and worked extensively by Adavidb... still seems to be an ongoing discussion about the article. It has a notability tag

29. Harriet E. Giles 2017-07-15 — added clean-up and ref improve tags

35. Nicolo Martines 2017-07-15 — added clean-up and ref improve tags

36. María Luisa Manrique de Lara y Gonzaga 2017-07-15 — added clean-up and ref improve tags

45. Gerald Caldwell Siordet 2017-04-30 — notability tag

• Elisa has been working on this

46. Frank Coombs (artist) 2017-04-30 — refimprove and notability tag

• Elisa has been working on this

47. Emile Mond 2017-04-30 — lots of tags and notability tag

48. Robert Bruce (Scottish composer) 2017-04-30 — added more footnotes tag

50. Ferruccio Vitale 2017-04-12 — added clean-up and notability tags

51. Charles B. Cluskey 2017-04-09 — refimprove and notability tag

53. Torcuato Benjumeda 2017-04-05 — added no footnotes tag

56. Coral Gables Villages 2017-04-04 — notability and other tags

• See George_E._Merrick#Coral_Gables

Hold due to discussions about how to resolve the articles

30. Kate Scott Turner 2017-07-15 - tags up the wazoo, including notability, merge and copy vio

• Worked on the article, not finding more content to prove notability. Added suggestion at Talk:Emily Dickinson discussion about the merge proposal
• Addressed copyvio issues. Posted copyvio-revdel template.–CaroleHenson (talk) 06:16, 25 July 2017 (UTC)

34. Barbara Montagu 2017-07-15 — notability tag, cleanup tag, merge tag

• Worked on article and removed all tags except merge tag. I am torn. ODNB has their bios jointly. But, Montagu seems to have been the one that inspired Scott to do charitable works and her legacy enabled Scott to continue to do them after her death. Montagu, far more than Scott, seems to have been notable for creating an alternative support system for women who were off the patriarchal social grid. SusunW (talk) 00:12, 24 July 2017 (UTC)

I should also point out that the discussion link goes to Scott's page, but the discussion is on Montagu's talk page? SusunW (talk) 00:33, 24 July 2017 (UTC)

I added the discuss parameter to the templates and they now point to the Montagu talk page.–CaroleHenson (talk) 00:58, 24 July 2017 (UTC)

52. Buildings in Savannah Historic District (Savannah, Georgia) 2017-04-07 -- too much detail

• This looks like too much detail to me. Posted a question at the NRHP talk page

• I am stuck on this one. If anyone has an idea about how to approach this, that would be great!–CaroleHenson (talk) 01:29, 25 July 2017 (UTC)

No action

28. Anna Cogswell Wood 2017-07-15 - could use some cleanup to remove excess detail and add more notable content about her, but not a big deal

Done

1. Ben Zuckerman 2017-07-17 —  Done Looks ok, not seeing copyright issues, made some edits, could likely benefit from expansion

3. Elizabeth Warham Forster 2017-07-17  Done SusunW (talk) 18:22, 22 July 2017 (UTC)

4. Phyllis Reid Fenner 2017-07-17 —  Done

5. Edith J. Goode 2017-07-17 — merged / redirect. Discussion at Talk:Alice Morgan Wright

7. Marion Morgan (choreographer) 2017-07-16 —  Done by SusunW

8. Grace Hutchins 2017-07-16 —  Done, mostly by Fortuna Imperatrix Mundi

• Addressed copyvio issues. Posted copyvio-revdel template.–CaroleHenson (talk) 06:16, 25 July 2017 (UTC)
• Nominated for DYK by Alex Shih
• Further edits by Gerda Arendt and Alex Shih

9. Edward Daniel Stone 2017-07-16 —  Done–CaroleHenson (talk) 03:17, 27 July 2017 (UTC)

• Being worked on by Elisa, with good progress in several areas
• Added close paraphrasing tag for the one source I checked so far

10. Elizabeth Reynard 2017-07-16 —  Done, although this could be expanded quite a bit - more about her role at WAVE, input for UN Conference, role at Barnard, whatever else comes up

12. Agnes E. Wells 2017-07-16 —  Done

13. Anna Lukens 2017-07-16 —  Done

14. Geraldine Morgan Thompson 2017-07-16 — copyvio issues addressed by CactusWriter, cn tagged

• Salvidrim! reviewed the article and marked it patrolled without tagging it, consider it  Done

15. Jeannette Augustus Marks 2017-07-16 —  Done

16. Herbert Charles Pollitt 2017-07-16 —  Done by Mabalu

17. Doris Fielding Reid 2017-07-16 —  Done

• Not notable on her own, I made edits and cleaned-up citations
• Elisa copied over content from the article and based upon her posting on my talk page, I redirected it to Edith Hamilton.–CaroleHenson (talk) 15:51, 27 July 2017 (UTC)

22. Clementina Anstruther-Thomson 2017-07-15 — was redirected, Alex Shih brought back and improved

23. Bertha van der Vyver 2017-07-15 —  Done by CaroleHenson and more particularly by SusunW

• Addressed copyvio issues
• On hold for now until there is feedback on the merge proposal, not really much more to do

• I have no opinion on the merge, but I have expanded what I could and honestly think her story is possibly strong enough to stand on its own. SusunW (talk) 00:26, 22 July 2017 (UTC)

• I removed the merge tag based upon the improvements.

25. Katherine Peabody Loring 2017-07-15 —  Done was deleted for copyvio, restored and improved by Alex Shih

• He addressed copyvio issues and hid versions

26. Evangeline Marrs Whipple 2017-07-15 —  Done with Alex Shih and Elisa

• Addressed copyvio issues. Posted copyvio-revdel template.–CaroleHenson (talk) 06:16, 25 July 2017 (UTC)

27. Irene Leache 2017-07-15 —  Done SusunW (talk) 17:05, 26 July 2017 (UTC)

31. Elizabeth Cushier 2017-07-15 —  Done, I am sure that the article could be expanded though

• Edits by Victuallers
• Addressed copyvio issues through most of the article. Posted copyvio-revdel template.–CaroleHenson (talk) 06:16, 25 July 2017 (UTC)

33. Charity Bryant 2017-07-15 —  Done by SusunW and Rosiestep

40. Louisa Caroline Stewart-Mackenzie 2017-07-14 -  Done tags up the wazoo, including notability and merge - work in progress and opposition to the merge

• I have added refs, copy edited, removed tags, and made what I think are compelling arguments to defeat the merge. SusunW (talk) 19:27, 20 July 2017 (UTC)

• I suggested proposal to close, based upon votes and improvements here

41. Alice DeLamar 2017-07-14 —  Done, but there are opportunities for expansion

42. Dorothy Warren 2017-05-02 -  Done, with contributions by Elisa

49. Benajah Osmun 2017-04-13 —  Done primarily due to Elisa

54. Clarence Winthrop Bowen 2017-04-04 —  Done in May

55. Eliza Larken Monson 2017-04-04 — done, redirect

• Neither Eliza or her husband are sufficiently notable for their own articles. Created a summary blurb for Baron Monson and redirected the article there. Much discussion at Talk:Eliza Larken Monson–CaroleHenson (talk) 01:02, 26 July 2017 (UTC)

58. Bernheimer Building 2017-04-02 — removed notability tag, there does not seem to be a clear issue that it is not notable and was considered 95% likely to be notable by one person. I added a message on the article talk page.–CaroleHenson (talk) 22:13, 25 July 2017 (UTC)

• When asking about the Smith... House, I also asked if the NRHP project knew if state historic properties were notable.–CaroleHenson (talk) 00:59, 23 July 2017 (UTC)

• Someone weighed-in at Wikipedia_talk:WikiProject_National_Register_of_Historic_Places#Notability_tag_on_NRHP_properties that they felt 95% sure that it was notable as a state historic building. I posted a message on Wikipedia:WikiProject Historic sites... so far no clear issue that it's not notable.–CaroleHenson (talk) 01:13, 25 July 2017 (UTC)

59. Smith-Bontura-Evans House 2017-04-02 -  Done in May, there was a notability tag

• I thought that NRHP properties were considered notable and asked at the NRHP project talk page about this article.–CaroleHenson (talk) 00:59, 23 July 2017 (UTC)

• I removed the tag, saying NRHP properties are inherently notable here

60. Vermilionville Historic Village -  Done, in terms of resolving primary sources tag

• Added secondary sources and further reading, did not expand the article

61. Article that had been redirected without a merge: Marjory Lacey-Barker -  Done

62. Consuelo Reyes-Calderon -  Done

Deleted / deletion tags

Note: Megalibrarygirl will look to see whether several of the identify women might meet notability requirements to be redlinked at Wikipedia:WikiProject Women in Red.

2. Ruth Turner Mallory · (Deleted) 2017-07-17

11. Mabel Reed 2017-07-16 — was nominated for CSD due to copyvio issues

18. Jeannette Augustus Marks · (Deleted) 2017-07-16

19. Leila Griswold Webb 2017-07-16 — CSD tag was applied for copyvio issues, deleted now

32. Ann Walker (died 1854) 2017-07-15 — Article for deletion discussion tag

• The decision was to merge.

37. John Hoyle (died 1692) 2017-07-15 — Article for deletion discussion tag

• Relisted for further discussion

38. Raoul II, Archbishop of Tours 2017-07-15 — Deleted due to copyvio

39. Jean, bishop of Orleans 2017-07-15 — Deleted due to copyvio

43. Kingscote Family 2017-05-01 — CSD tag for not a genealogy site

44. Jasper Fitzhardinge Kingscote · (Deleted) 2017-04-30

57. List of landmarks in the New Orleans French Quarter · (Deleted) 2017-04-03