User:Cryptic C62/Graphs

This page documents my attempt to study VisualEditor load times across multiple browsers.

Graphs[edit]

All browsers

Chrome

Firefox

Opera

Safari

Findings[edit]

Of the browsers used, load times were consistently lower in Google Chrome. The dataset is incomplete for Safari; larger articles crashed the loader. From the models section below, it is not clear that any one growth model adequately describes all browsers. However, it seems clear that the growth is not linear or logarithmic, which would have been nice. Load times were also compared to file sizes and total image sizes (both found using User:Dr pda/prosesize), but no significant correlations were found in any browser.

Sampling[edit]

Special:LongPages was used to find articles. I started at the top of the list and worked my way down to History of Australia (262 kB), skipping some articles along the way. Then I worked down through the list to find one article near each multiple of 10 kB — 250 kB, 240 kB, 230 kB, etc.

Times[edit]

Times (sec)
Article	Page Size (kB)	Firefox	Opear	Chrome	Safari
1994 Australian Open – Men's Doubles	30	4	4	3	4
Sydvaranger	40	7	4	3	5
Raven paradox	50	9	4	3	6
Opinion polling for the Spanish general election, 2004	60	10	6	6	7
Tsukasa Fujimoto	70	17	7	6	10
Iraqi Kurdistan	80	9	7	6	12
List of Ohio railroads	90	18	11	11	18
Aleppo	100	11	9	7	17
Go (game)	110	12	9	8	21
List of birds of Bolivia	120	21	17	15	54
Tyrannosaurus	130	11	20	8	16
2008 Sichuan earthquake	140	11	10	8	17
United States House of Representatives elections, 1922	150	24	36	14	32
Soil	160	13	8	8	20
Bibliography of the Tonga people (Africa)	170	12	11	8	26
Brazil	181	19	39	14	63
South African contract law	190	16	17	12	31
History of painting	200	18	20	10	25
Historical inheritance systems	210	30	21	13	26
West Virginia Mountaineers football	221	18	29	12	45
Arkansas Militia in the Civil War	230	19	31	13	42
List of licensed and localized editions of Monopoly: USA	241	8	18	6	8
List of moths of Turkey	250	38	43	25	37
History of Australia	262	32	18	17	71
List of Olympic medalists in athletics (men)	274	29	24	20	70
2012–13 UEFA Europa League qualifying phase and play-off round	290	37	56	22	144
Historical list of the Catholic bishops of the United States	310	38	27	22	31
List of The Simpsons guest stars	321	49	38	35	N/A
Religions by country	345	35	38	21	33
2013 in paleontology	360	54	43	37	125
List of monastic houses in Ireland	377	48	36	33	72
List of Other Backward Classes	403	105	106	102	N/A
2012 in American television	408	39	30	28	68
Timeline of Orthodoxy in Greece	422	40	26	23	119
List of counties in the People's Republic of China	434	71	62	57	121
List of people of the Three Kingdoms	475	105	101	70	N/A
List of jōyō kanji	557	118	123	73	N/A
List of United States counties and county-equivalents	616	323	199	142	N/A

Models[edit]

Best fit highlighted in bold.

Correlation Coefficients
Browser	Exponential	Polynomial Deg. 2	Polynomial Deg. 3	Power	Linear	Logarithmic
Safari	0.6648	0.6014	0.6024	0.7327	0.5926	0.4894
Firefox	0.8440	0.8234	0.8933	0.7336	0.5761	0.3317
Opera	0.7988	0.8239	0.8693	0.8087	0.6745	0.4427
Chrome	0.8547	0.8111	0.8184	0.7935	0.6761	0.4321

Procedure[edit]

Open browser. Log in. Navigate to chosen article. Wait for it to completely load. Activate VisualEditor and start timer simultaneously. If any error messages appear, quickly click "continue", but do not stop timer. Find a cluster of wikilinks or transclusions in the article, and rapidly hover mouse across several of them. When VisualEditor recognizes hovering (blue underline for links, blue overlay for transclusions, green stripes for uneditables), stop timer. Note that this occurs after the VisualEditor toolbar appears. The idea is to see how long it takes before you can actually start editing, not how long it takes before loading appears to be finished.

Specs[edit]

Skin: Vector
Operating system: Windows Vista Home Premium
Processor: Intel Premium Dual CPU E2180 @ 2.00 GHz
RAM: 3.00 GB