User:Ealdgyth/2023 Arb Election votes

Normally I'd do a whole bunch of statistics here, but with just 10 candidates for 8 seats, I'm not going to bother. I'm going to play "tilt at windmills" here but doubt that its going to make much difference - 8 folks will be elected, even though I'm not convinced that they will do well on the committee.

Past votes[edit]

Candidates[edit]

Support[edit]

HJ Mitchell Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/HJ Mitchell/Questions - in general, I've had good interactions with HJ and think they are level-headed and sensible.
Z1720 Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Z1720/Questions Answer to question #10 is clueful and in general I've had no issues with Z when we've interacted and I've found them level-headed and sensible.
Sdrqaz Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Sdrqaz/Questions - very marginally support because I've not seen anything bad and their answers seem clueful
Firefly Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Firefly/Questions - very marginally support because I've not seen anything bad and their answers seem clueful

Oppose[edit]

Robert McClenon - Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Robert McClenon/Questions. I've opposed them in the past and continue to find them entirely too rule-bound and rigid for the position of arbitrator.
Maxim Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Maxim/Questions - I've opposed in the past and retain my concerns from past years.
ToBeFree Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/ToBeFree/Questions well - "I'm fine with how the Arbitration Committee works and am not applying to push for reforms." (as well as the rest of the answers along these lines) is a deal-breaker - there is always room for improvement and I remain concerned about transparency and a habit of hiding from the tough decisions.

Neutral[edit]

Cabayi Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Cabayi/Questions - I've found them to be ... a nonentity on the committee, that they don't really engage in much and I'm not sure what good they've done. On the other hand, they've not actually done anything horrific so I guess there's that?
Wugapodes Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Wugapodes/Questions - I'm conflicted about Wug. In some things, I've been impressed, but at other times, I've been tempted to beat my head on my desk when they do something wildly out of line (some of their conflict with VM at the Holocaust ArbCase comes to mind). In the end, I think that if they really are a grad student, it's in their best interests to not be on the committee.
Aoidh Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2023/Candidates/Aoidh/Questions - I've not seen enough of them in stressful conditions to have a judgement and their recent RfA timing makes me concerned they aren't ready for this role.