User:Soni/sandbox3

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Proposal A (16C as is)[edit]

  1. WP:Admin Reconfirmation will be created, where any subpages can be created for individual admins. Editors may sign on those subpages to vote for a reconfirmation.
  2. The reconfirmation is initiated if 25 editors with Extended Confirmed rights vote for it within the last 1 month. Or if 50 editors with Extended Confirmed rights vote for it within the last 1 year.
  3. Once a reconfirmation is started, the admin in question must run for a "Reconfirmation RFA" (RRFA) within the next 30 days. Otherwise a bureaucrat can remove their admin rights.
  4. A RRFA will be identical to any RFA, but with lower thresholds. Instead of 75% "generally passing", it'll be 66%. And the discretionary range for Bureaucrats will be 55% to 66% instead of 65% to 75%. Any admins who fail a RRFA will have their admin rights revoked.
  5. Any admins may voluntarily stand for RRFAs at any time if they like. This will be otherwise considered identical to a community initiated Reconfirmation.
  6. Admins who have successfully run for an RFA, RFB, RRFA, or Arbcom elections in the last 1 year are not eligible for a community initiated Reconfirmation. Any votes for reconfirmation in the 1 year after an admin succeeds any of these will be struck.

Support (Proposal A)[edit]

Discussion (Proposal A)[edit]

Proposal B (A with higher thresholds)[edit]

Point 2 of Proposal A is amended to

The reconfirmation is initiated if 50 editors with Extended Confirmed rights vote for it within the last 1 month. Or if 75 editors with Extended Confirmed rights vote for it within the last 3 months.

Support (Proposal B)[edit]

Discussion (Proposal B)[edit]

Overall Discussion[edit]