User talk:Sgkimbrell/Estuary

Hey, I posted the peer review for your article. I found it very interesting and well informative. Overall, you guys did a really good job.HeathGHioto (talk) 20:40, 11 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Dr. White's critique of your first draft[edit]

Estuarine plants (Nadya): Good information and image added, please add wikilinks. Great references, but check formatting.

Estuarine animals (Sally?): Good information and image added, please add wikilinks and remove the quote. Paraphrase instead. Your references are not peer-reviewed, you should only use peer-reviewed references and check formatting.

Biogeochemical cycles (Savannah?): Good information and table added, please add wikilinks. Nice references, except #9 is not peer-reviewed, you should only use peer-reviewed references and check formatting.

Humans (Ally): Good information and image added, please add wikilinks. Nice references, except #13 is not peer-reviewed, you should only use peer-reviewed references and check formatting.

Whiteamphipod (talk) 18:16, 12 April 2022 (UTC)[reply]