Wikipedia:Featured list candidates/List of films that most frequently use the word "fuck"

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

List of films that most frequently use the word "fuck"[edit]

This list I stumbled upon is cited for every move, sorted, and has good pictures to support it. Therefore, I nominate it and will help improve it if need be. The Placebo Effect 19:11, 27 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]

  • Oppose Lead is inadequate and too self referential. Put guidelines for editors in the talk page. It isn't acceptable to use bare URL hyperlinks for featured material. A full citation is required (Title, Publisher, Author (if one), Date (if given), Access Date, etc). "The Documentary Blog" isn't a reliable source, which gives a problem with the number 1 film, which only opened to a handful of screens (according to IMDB). Screen It are a "husband and wife team", only one of whom is full-time. Don't think that counts as a reliable source even if the site has been around a long time – there isn't the editorial control and fact checking you'd expect from proper publisher. Many of their reviews seem very vague (at least nnn times; hard to hear; difficult accents; etc). The two big negatives are the US bias and failure to specify which edition of the film is being counted (would appear to be mostly US DVD's). Editions for Europe or screened in theatres may well be different. Would different US states have different rules? The term "commercially released film" is inadequate as it would include the sort of films that "Family Media Guide" and "Screen It" wouldn't lower themselves to watch. You seem to include some TV-movies/straight-to-video/dvd? This makes me doubt the list is comprehensive. The "Other movies" section is weak. A lot of the links are redirects or just wrong (Rounders). Colin°Talk 21:31, 27 March 2007 (UTC)[reply]