Wikipedia:List of New York City and New York State move discussion page sections
This is a list of discussion page sections on proposed moves of the New York City and New York State articles. If the page is dedicated to this topic, it should not be listed here, but should be in Category:New York City and New York State move discussion pages. In general, discussions should be in one or the other but not both.
A possible exception is a talk page archive which ends up being devoted to these discussions, although the talk page itself is more general... that archive page and its sections could validly be in both. However Talk:New York (state)/Archive 6 fits this description, and there seems no need to add it to the category.
Current discussions[edit]
- Talk:New York#Aftermath, discussion of subsequent changes necessary across areas of the project impacted by the move of the state article to New York (state) and having New York as dab page.
- Talk:New York/Meta, discussions about the 2017 move request process, and some lateral thinking about dab pages
Recent discussions[edit]
- Closed suggestion that might have led to an RM.
Archived discussions[edit]
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 1#Propose rename of this article to "New York State" Oct–Nov 2004 informal discussion, no action
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 1#Title of article Feb 2005 noting reverting move of NYS article to New York (U.S. state), back to New York
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 1#PROPOSED MOVE Feb–Sep 2005 Some support for move to New York (U.S. state) but slightly more opposition
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 3#Hi there I have a proposition Mar–Aug 2008 moved NYS article to New York State and DAB to New York while protected, and then both moved back again
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 4#Should New York be a disam page Oct–Nov 2010 A very long discussion with two RM polls it seems, closed with no move
- User talk:John/Archive 2010#New York the close is challenged
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 4#Perplexed the close is challenged at length and explained
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 5#Requested_move Aug 2011 RM to move to New York (state) and New York (city), almost no support
- Wikipedia talk:Disambiguation/Archive 36#Proposed clarification: No consensus for primary topic means the page becomes a disambiguation page - December 2011, follow up from August RM
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 5#my peepee says hi Jan 2013 Informal heads-up, no action
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 5#new york --> NYC Jul 2013 Informal discussion at some length, no action
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 5#Requested move 9 June 2016 moved to New York (state)
- Wikipedia:Move review/Log/2016 June#New York (state) MR overturned move to relist
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 5#Requested move 19 July 2016 relisted as talk subpage with panel
- Talk:New York/July 2016 move request closed as no consensus
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 6#RFC: Is New York State the primary topic for the term "New York"? August 2016 RfC reached consensus that New York State is not the primary topic of New York
- Talk:New York (state)/Archive 7#Next RfC, musings on what to do next, after having determined by consensus that the state is not primary
- Wikipedia:Move review/Log/2016 October endorsed no consensus close
- Talk:New York (state)/FAQ#NYRM, an explanation of the controversy's history and a list of previous discussions
2017 events[edit]
- Talk:New York (state)/Proposed move, drafting space for the 2017 move proposal
- User:Andrewa/NYRM July 2017, a proposed draft
- User:JFG/sandbox/New York Proposed move, May 2017, an incomplete proposed draft
- User:Certes/New York, yet another proposed draft
- User:JFG/sandbox/New York Proposed move, July 2017, the adopted draft submitted to the community
- User talk:SmokeyJoe#Questions, discussion on what was named after what historically, with many sources
- Talk:New York#Requested move 7 July 2017, the move request closed on July 19, 2017