Stevie Brock received mainly negative reviews from critics. Johnny Loftus from AllMusic gave it one-and-a-half stars out of five, criticizing Brianna Lauren Fuentes's rap on "Shut Me Down" and saying Brock sounds like a little kid singing along to Justin Timberlake lyrics. However, he praised the songs "If U Be My Baby" and "All for Love," naming them the album's Track Picks.