Jump to content

Talk:Abu Ishaq Ibrahim al-Kanemi

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Categories

[edit]

@Bearcat: It is typical of Wikipedia's categories that you cannot tell whether they are ethnic, national, linguistic, cultural, legal, etc. The category "12th-century Arabic poets" absolutely does not tell you that its members were Arabs. It tells you they wrote in Arabic. Then there is a category:Arab poets, which tells you to put every one in an "Arabic poets" subcat. Probably it is true that until relatively recent times being an Arab poet meant being an Arabic poet (but not vice versa), but why do we switch adjectives in the middle of the category tree? Why isn't there a category:Arabic poets but instead category:Arabic-language poets, when our article Arabic suggests that it refers only to a language? Note that the subcats of Arab poets are also subcats of Arabic-language poets. In short, it's a mess and that is why I dropped it back in June. But you were wrong: "Category:12th-century Arabic poets" does not imply that is members were Arabs. Srnec (talk) 23:47, 17 January 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Well, then you need to get Category:Arabic poets by century out of Category:Arab poets, because if Arabic poets and Arab poets aren't the same thing, then Arabic poets shouldn't be a subcategory of Arab poets. As long as it is a subcategory of Arab poets, however, duplicate categorization rules apply, which means people do not go into both the parent "Arab poets" and the child "any-century Arabic poets" at the same time as each other. It's one or the other, period, and I'm not debating any grey areas that would violate our rules around double-catting articles in both parent and child categories within the same tree. Bearcat (talk) 01:05, 18 January 2022 (UTC)[reply]