Jump to content

Talk:Ed Seykota

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

NPOV Dispute

[edit]

The article uses subjective language and makes unqualified assertions about Seykota's success and personal qualities. Phrases like "Much of Seykota's success was attributed to his development and utilization of computerized trading systems" and "Another aspect of his success was his genuine love for trading and his optimistic demeanour" are subjective and promotional.

The article highlights Seykota's achievements and innovations without providing a critical analysis or contrasting viewpoints from other experts in the field.

There are references to specific works and events, such as his book "The Trading Tribe" and Jack D. Schwager's "Market Wizards," but there is a lack of diverse sources to corroborate the claims made in the article. This reliance on limited sources biases the article. The article references his influence and contributions but does not cite external evaluations or independent sources for a neutral assessment.

The article also includes personal anecdotes, such as Seykota's emotional support group for traders. These details seem irrelevant. The focus on Seykota's methods and personal philosophy degrades the neutrality of the article.

Claims about Seykota's influence and status, such as being "one of the best traders of our time," are not sufficiently backed by independent evidence or comparative analysis. The article lacks detailed references to verify some of the statements, reducing the credibility and neutrality of the content. Meleager91 (talk) 12:44, 17 May 2024 (UTC)[reply]