Talk:Geo Tv

Merger of Nadia Khan Show

I disagree with the proposed merger of Nadia Khan Show into this article. The show is independently notable, having several references. Furthermore, bascially any television show which is broadcast on a national network is inherently notable. We would never even consider doing this for a US or UK television production, so there is no justification for the merger here. Qwyrxian (talk) 12:39, 16 October 2012 (UTC)

Hi, I've proposed it to be merged it to Geo TV as it used to be aired on it. I have also proposed for it to be merged to Nadia Khan, since the encyclopedic article Nadia Khan Show does not meet standards as it has been written by a co-worker of Ms. Nadia Khan and show is no more notable now. So, I think it should either be merged to Geo TV or Nadia Khan. --S.M.Samee (talk) 13:51, 16 October 2012 (UTC)

As regards references, these are not adequate. Since Reference 6 & 7 leading to masala.com are blind links. Reference no. 4 that leads to Awamiweb.com is a blog and that is just a false article since Nadia Khan came back to Dunya News on weekends.Ext. Link Reference no. 3 is also non-reliable blog which I speculate to be made by the Farwah Khan herself. The remaining 1 or 2 references are primary sources. If you still stick on the same, why don't you think to merge it to Nadia Khan--S.M.Samee (talk) 14:01, 16 October 2012 (UTC)?

As I've explained on my talk page, your concerns here actually aren't in line with policy. Notabilty is not temporary--since the show was clearly notable at one time (being a highly rated show in Pakistan), it is always "notable" for Wikipedia. That never changes, even 100 or 300 years from now. Would it be okay if I removed the merger tags? Qwyrxian (talk) 22:34, 16 October 2012 (UTC)