Jump to content

Talk:Keltner list

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit]

Well, this article reproduces the entire Keltner list. That is completely not allowed for works under copyright (as the 1985 Baseball Abstract, the source of the list, is). On the other hand, the Keltner list is a very small excerpt of the 1985 Baseball Abstract, and thus in an article on that book it would possibly be OK as fair use.

But this article is about the Keltner list, and reproduces it entirely, and so my take is that its not allowed IMO, and we have to err on the side of being conservative on copyright issues, and so I've deleted it. (I also deleted the above talk page thread which contains the entire list, and which is off-topic anyway although its interesting and informative).