Talk:Krishna/Krishna worshipers

Proposal discussion Create a Krishna centered Hinduism project Place to discuss - Krishna worshipers WikiProject - lets create unity in diversity! Proposal for discussion - May 2008 Say what you think about it here: Please leave a few words on how you think the Krishna-centered traditions of Hinduism should be represented? Talk:Krishna/Krishna worshipers. We need to talk it over! Look over the complete list of proposed traditions forming the scope of the project - this list is by far not complete, please add your favorites and discuss! From ancient to modern You can join and make a difference! This is a place to discuss a joint venture. Please comment on the proposal of a new Krishna centered project. There are many traditions where Krishna is worshiped and His names revered. The purpose is to join the forces and create more beautiful and well resourced articles. The traditions are not limited to one or two, there are many and all should be given equal attention. Leave a few words here and we will discuss it more and more. Proposed scope (in alphabetical order) Bisnupriya Manipuri Vaishnavas Bhagavata Gaudiya Vaishnava Nimbarka sampradaya Svaminarayana sampradaya Vallabhā sampradāya Editors Wikidās ॐ Wheredevelsdare (talk)    Juthani1   tcs

Comments

Probably too specialized to be viable. I would keep these discussions within Wikipedia:WikiProject Hinduism. --Eastmain (talk) 21:39, 8 May 2008 (UTC)

Its a wide range of traditions -- but within the scope of the Wikipedia:WikiProject Hinduism with the specialised interest and review scope. Wikidās ॐ 21:55, 8 May 2008 (UTC)

Interesting project idea. May be a bit specialized, but it could work. Enough articles are within its scope. I recommend test-driving it as a task force within WP:VAISHNAVA for a while and see if it has potential to remain an active WikiProject. Also, is this going to cover Krishna-centered topics only, or simply anything related to Krishna and Krishna worship (i.e. Vaishnava topics). If it's the former, then Dvaita really shouldn't be within the scope of the project, since followers of the belief do not hold a Krishna-centered theology, but rather a Vishnu/Narayana-centered theology with emphasis on the belief that all major avatars (including Krishna) are "full" avatars of Vishnu. If it's the latter, the project may be better suited as a part of [WP:VAISHNAVA]]. The project box above is nice, by the way. --Shruti14 ^{t c s} 23:48, 8 May 2008 (UTC)

The topic is now discussed on the board.Wikidās ॐ 23:55, 8 May 2008 (UTC)