| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Identity |
5 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Identity
|
| Portuguese theory |
12 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Portuguese theory
|
| Probable ad-spam |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Probable ad-spam
|
| Genoese Theory |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Genoese Theory
|
| More Inaccurate quoting of Sources |
5 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#More Inaccurate quoting of Sources
|
| Incoherent sentence |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Incoherent sentence
|
| "Greek" theory |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#"Greek" theory
|
| Flimflam Article in The Independent |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Flimflam Article in The Independent
|
| Finally the Genoese is proven False |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Finally the Genoese is proven False
|
| Again on Portuguese Theory |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Again on Portuguese Theory
|
| Again or against the portuguese theory? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Again or against the portuguese theory?
|
| The house of Christopher Columbus in Porto Santo |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#The house of Christopher Columbus in Porto Santo
|
| Italy |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Italy
|
| Vandal edits followed by an attempt to assert a fact December 31, 2006. |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Vandal edits followed by an attempt to assert a fact December 31, 2006.
|
| Major mistakes in portuguese theory |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Major mistakes in portuguese theory
|
| Lies, Lies and More Lies |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Lies, Lies and More Lies
|
| Catalan-Genoese |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Catalan-Genoese
|
| More Lies - the True Arms of Colón |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#More Lies - the True Arms of Colón
|
| One more FALSE document |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#One more FALSE document
|
| Language |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Language
|
| This shouldn't be a forum |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#This shouldn't be a forum
|
| Portuguese theory redux |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Portuguese theory redux
|
| Quoting a notorious author namely Manuel Luciano da Silva |
6 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Quoting a notorious author namely Manuel Luciano da Silva
|
| Genoese not a "written language"? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Genoese not a "written language"?
|
| Why No Discussion of CC's brothers? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Why No Discussion of CC's brothers?
|
| PLEASE STOP LYING |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#PLEASE STOP LYING
|
| Catalan Theory |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 1#Catalan Theory
|
| PLEASE TAKE THIS OUT IT IS NOT TRUE |
16 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#PLEASE TAKE THIS OUT IT IS NOT TRUE
|
| Turning into a witch hunt |
7 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#Turning into a witch hunt
|
| The Encyclopedia of wrong assertions |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#The Encyclopedia of wrong assertions
|
| Take Out This |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#Take Out This
|
| The Genoese Hypothesis |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#The Genoese Hypothesis
|
| Catalan Colom |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#Catalan Colom
|
| The majority view among historians is that Columbus was Genoese |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#The majority view among historians is that Columbus was Genoese
|
| Portuguese hypothesis |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#Portuguese hypothesis
|
| Charles Merrill |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Charles Merrill
|
| Portuguese hypothesis |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#Portuguese hypothesis 2
|
| COLUMBUS. The Untold Story |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 2#COLUMBUS. The Untold Story
|
| However, Morison did not show any of this proof. |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#However, Morison did not show any of this proof.
|
| Marriage is no big mystery |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Marriage is no big mystery
|
| For Italus |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#For Italus
|
| high social rank of Columbus’s wife |
10 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#high social rank of Columbus’s wife
|
| the 1498 mayorazgo is Forged |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#the 1498 mayorazgo is Forged
|
| Disturbing the Evidence |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Disturbing the Evidence
|
| Pruning |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Pruning
|
| For " Colon-el-Nuevo " |
11 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#For " Colon-el-Nuevo "
|
| This is False somebody please remove this |
6 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#This is False somebody please remove this
|
| Columbus As Byzantine Nobel |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Columbus As Byzantine Nobel
|
| Davide41 |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Davide41
|
| CuriousColonal - NO |
13 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#CuriousColonal - NO
|
| Reminder on logging in |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Reminder on logging in
|
| Portuguese hypothesis |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Portuguese hypothesis
|
| PORTOGUES |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#PORTOGUES
|
| <STOP - Origin theories of Christopher Columbus> |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#<STOP - Origin theories of Christopher Columbus>
|
| Opening Paragraph |
21 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Opening Paragraph
|
| Rosa explains Columbus’ Polish roots |
7 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#Rosa explains Columbus’ Polish roots
|
| Ginovés does NOT mean from Genoa |
6 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Ginovés does NOT mean from Genoa
|
| End of an Era of Lies |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 3#End of an Era of Lies
|
| Non-Greek Historian Claims Columbus was Greek |
22 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Non-Greek Historian Claims Columbus was Greek
|
| Fernando's Testament is a Copy not Original |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Fernando's Testament is a Copy not Original
|
| Another False Claim of facts |
11 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Another False Claim of facts
|
| Correction Footnote 12 |
12 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Correction Footnote 12
|
| Unethical and Fallacious Editing |
13 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Unethical and Fallacious Editing
|
| The Mayorazgo is Unreliable as Evidence |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#The Mayorazgo is Unreliable as Evidence
|
| Uncertain Facts Passed Off as Certainties |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Uncertain Facts Passed Off as Certainties
|
| The Sources (Colon - El - Nuevo ) |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#The Sources (Colon - El - Nuevo )
|
| References |
5 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#References
|
| Giambattista Strozzi |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Giambattista Strozzi
|
| Alessandro Geraldini |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Alessandro Geraldini
|
| Unreliable vs. Reliable Source. Who decides? |
9 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Unreliable vs. Reliable Source. Who decides?
|
| Leaving aside the comic fantasies ... Genoa or Savona ? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Leaving aside the comic fantasies ... Genoa or Savona ?
|
| Portuguese wife |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 4#Portuguese wife
|
| Edit war (Colon-el-Nuevo) |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#Edit war (Colon-el-Nuevo)
|
| "Oyo Decir" = Heard Say |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#"Oyo Decir" = Heard Say
|
| "Columbus was Portuguese." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa] / Martin Waldseemüller's 1516 Carta Marina |
6 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#"Columbus was Portuguese." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa] / Martin Waldseemüller's 1516 Carta Marina
|
| "Columbus uses the word "homeland" in relation to Portugal." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa] |
5 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#"Columbus uses the word "homeland" in relation to Portugal." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa]
|
| "Admiral Colón, (and NOT Columbus), NEVER declared where he was born." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa] |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#"Admiral Colón, (and NOT Columbus), NEVER declared where he was born." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa]
|
| "You should now try to identify, not what countless writers of "hearsay" wrote ..." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa] |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#"You should now try to identify, not what countless writers of "hearsay" wrote ..." [Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa]
|
| The hallucinations of Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa ( 2 ) |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#The hallucinations of Colon-el-Nuevo/Manuel Rosa ( 2 )
|
| My work |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#My work
|
| Adding Verifiable Sources to the Article |
7 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#Adding Verifiable Sources to the Article
|
| Sources and What They Say |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#Sources and What They Say
|
| Source material to be inserted into the Portuguese Theory |
5 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#Source material to be inserted into the Portuguese Theory
|
| Soundness of the Portuguese Theory |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#Soundness of the Portuguese Theory
|
| No Consensus - End of Discussion |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#No Consensus - End of Discussion
|
| Columbus Theories - no consensus over sources |
19 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 5#Columbus Theories - no consensus over sources
|
| This has to stop |
19 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#This has to stop
|
| Polish Theory Piggybacks on the Portuguese theory |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Polish Theory Piggybacks on the Portuguese theory
|
| Balance to scholarly sources |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Balance to scholarly sources
|
| ALL sections on this page need to be expanded. There's a myriad of facts on the Italian, Spanish and Catalan wikis that is missing from here. |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#ALL sections on this page need to be expanded. There's a myriad of facts on the Italian, Spanish and Catalan wikis that is missing from here.
|
| Correction suggested |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Correction suggested
|
| Galician hypothesis? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Galician hypothesis?
|
| Kolumbus was Polish after all |
10 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Kolumbus was Polish after all
|
| Genovese Marrano? |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Genovese Marrano?
|
| Suggested correction |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Suggested correction
|
| Assereto Document is a forgery |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Assereto Document is a forgery
|
| Criticism: Portuguese hypothesis |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Criticism: Portuguese hypothesis
|
| "Official" Columbus vs. Cristóbal Colon |
8 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#"Official" Columbus vs. Cristóbal Colon
|
| Portuguese hypothesis |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Portuguese hypothesis
|
| ORIGINS |
12 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#ORIGINS
|
| Assereto is a Forgery |
4 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Assereto is a Forgery
|
| Felipa Perestrello e Moniz " a Portuguese noblewoman of the Order of Santiago." |
6 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Felipa Perestrello e Moniz " a Portuguese noblewoman of the Order of Santiago."
|
| Evidence of intent to obscure Columbus's true origin |
7 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 6#Evidence of intent to obscure Columbus's true origin
|
| Contemporary or not? |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Contemporary or not?
|
| The "father" of Christopher Columbus |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#The "father" of Christopher Columbus
|
| Kolumb byl Plakiem? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Kolumb byl Plakiem?
|
| Bien que el coerpo ande aca el coracon esta ali de continuo... |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Bien que el coerpo ande aca el coracon esta ali de continuo...
|
| COLUMBUS AN ARMENIAN ? |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#COLUMBUS AN ARMENIAN ?
|
| Galician origin theory |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Galician origin theory
|
| Include more details about the publication of "The Life of Admiral Christopher Columbus by his son Ferdinand" |
7 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Include more details about the publication of "The Life of Admiral Christopher Columbus by his son Ferdinand"
|
| Chinese Origin Theory |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Chinese Origin Theory
|
| He did not speak Italian |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#He did not speak Italian
|
| Re-write, please |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Re-write, please
|
| Genoese Documents are false |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Genoese Documents are false
|
| The article focuses solely on Patriarchal line |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#The article focuses solely on Patriarchal line
|
| Columbus Was Not Italian? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Columbus Was Not Italian?
|
| Colon was not Columbus and was Not Italian? |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Colon was not Columbus and was Not Italian?
|
| University Professors Now Doubt Columbus Origins |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#University Professors Now Doubt Columbus Origins
|
| Samuel Eliot Morison has cast no doubts |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Samuel Eliot Morison has cast no doubts
|
| edits eliminated |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#edits eliminated
|
| Columbus did not write nor Speak Italian |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Columbus did not write nor Speak Italian
|
| The Columbus from Genoa was not the same guy as the discoverer |
10 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#The Columbus from Genoa was not the same guy as the discoverer
|
| Uncertain Sources |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Uncertain Sources
|
| Rosa |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Rosa
|
| Add the Galician origin please |
2 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Add the Galician origin please
|
| Assereto document |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Assereto document
|
| Agenda? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Agenda?
|
| Problems in the language section |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus/Archive 7#Problems in the language section
|
| NPOV/original research ? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus#NPOV/original research ?
|
| Theories contrary |
3 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus#Theories contrary
|
| What are the words of the supposed Genoese gloss? |
1 |
Talk:Origin theories of Christopher Columbus#What are the words of the supposed Genoese gloss?
|
