Jump to content

Talk:Pennsylvania Route 363/GA1

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

GA Review

[edit]

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer:Hurricanehink (talk) 17:18, 3 February 2011 (UTC)[reply]

I've never reviewed a road article, so here it goes.

  • First, is there anything special about the route that can be emphasized in the first sentence? Right now, it just says what it is, which doesn't draw the reader in at all.
  • "Throughout its length, PA 363 follows Trooper Road, Ridge Pike, Park Avenue, and Valley Forge Road." - what does that mean? Does it parallel those roads? Or does it intersect them
  • Also, I just noticed it, but would 363 be considered a spur, given that it intersects 63?
    • Yes it is, along with the other x63 numbers in the Philadelphia area. Dough4872
  • "PA 363 was first designated by 1930" - who designated it?
  • "At this intersection, the name of PA 363 becomes Valley Forge Road and it continues" - that's a poor way to start off a paragraph, especially since the previous paragraph doesn't technically mention an intersection. Try finding another way to say that, like "Upon crossing the Germantown Pike, the route..." Also, grammatically speaking, the sentence is confusing, as the latter "it" has the antecedent of "name", and surely the name isn't continuing. Finally, is there a link for the Germantown Pik or what route it is?
  • "developments. The amount of development" - can you find a way to avoid the redundancy?
  • "Past the PA 73 intersection, PA 363 continues past areas" - poor wording there, using "past" twice
  • You use "as" several times in inappropriate settings. "as" implies something is happening continuously, but that doesn't apply in these examples
    • "The amount of development increases as the road comes to the junction" - the road only comes to a junction at a very small location, so surely you mean "until the road comes to a junction"
    • "PA 363 continues past areas of housing developments to the west and farmland to the east as it reaches Morris Road." - so there is housing to the west and farming to the east when it actually reaches Morris Road? Or, again, do you mean "until"?
    • Changed to "before". Dough4872 20:54, 3 February 2011 (UTC)[reply]
  • Any link/route # for "Sumneytown Pike"?
  • Why was the Betzwood Bridge closed?
  • Is there a reason "Interchange." appears in the major intersections section? (I note the fullstop)
  • OK, my biggest issue is that there is only one reference that is not a map. I wouldn't even mind if there were offline sources, but I can't pass a GA that has just one source that has prose. There are major accessibility concerns. You shouldn't have to be able to understand cartography to be able to verify one of the sources. I have no idea how to check that to make sure it's correct. I won't fail it yet, since I'll give you a chance to find some prose sources. However, I don't think it helps Wikipedia to have an article that get its info from editors reading maps to get the information. That sounds awfully close to WP:OR. --♫ Hurricanehink (talk) 17:18, 3 February 2011 (UTC)[reply]

One thing I just noticed.

  • "PA 363 continues as a two-lane undivided road past more homes as it continues to the Ridge Pike intersection." - two uses of continues. Try being more creative ;)

Just a few more minor things to address, and I'll be happy to pass the GAN. ♫ Hurricanehink (talk) 06:38, 8 February 2011 (UTC)[reply]

Alright, I'm passing. My only other comment is splitting up the history section into two paragraphs. ♫ Hurricanehink (talk) 00:39, 9 February 2011 (UTC)[reply]