Talk:Uncle Arthur

This article was nominated for deletion on 2006 June 14. The result of the discussion was rewrite as a disambiguation page.

Untitled

Talk:Uncle Arthur

The reason this page has been listed should be fairly obvious - he was a joke character, mentioned once. Considering other far more notable characters are combined into one article, and that the infromation is already at Simpson family#Extended_family, making this article redundent. If this article is kept, then that would mean every single one off gag in the Simpsons is notable for a wiki entry. As for the other "unseen and mentioned once" characters - they shouldn't have articles either. Aplogises for not adding this notice to this discussion page earlier, I thought I had. ACE Spark 08:28, 11 June 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Proposed new disambiguation page

Uncle Arthur may refer to:

Uncle Arthur, pen name of prolific Seventh-day Adventist Church author Arthur S. Maxwell
Uncle Arthur, a minor character from television show The Simpsons
Uncle Arthur, a regular character on television show Bewitched
Uncle Arthur, a character played by Australian comedian Glenn Robbins
Uncle Arthur, a song published in 1967 by musician David Bowie
Uncle Arthur, the name used by Private Frank Pike for Sergeant Arthur Wilson in British sitcom Dad's Army

Uncle Arthur's is a registered trademark in the United States, used by the Arthur S. Maxwell Estate. [1] {{disambiguation}}

I'd hardly call this character minor, because other more notable characters in the Simpsons are still considered minor. This character doesn't even get an appearence. A gag character seems to be a better discription, how-ever the disambiguation seems like a good idea. --ACE Spark 18:38, 14 June 2006 (UTC)[reply]