Jump to content

Template talk:Musical repertoire

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Removing "By composer"

[edit]

I've been expanding the "By composer" section, until I've realized just how massive this would have to be. Right now, there are around 80 entries. PetScan shows another 280 missing:

Title Page ID Namespace Size (bytes) Last change
List of compositions by Juan María Solare 221181 0 1455 20200610225343
List of compositions by Luciano Berio 736721 0 16138 20210105160934
List of compositions by Alban Berg 1021030 0 5790 20200913185013
List of compositions by Rebecca Clarke 1860606 0 16270 20200303212749
List of compositions by Ernest Chausson 1894493 0 7310 20200903084845
List of compositions by Vincent d'Indy 1913714 0 10509 20200303212849
List of compositions by Moritz Moszkowski 1923469 0 97850 20201110014638
List of compositions by Pierre Boulez 2164046 0 6078 20201210015452
List of compositions by Antonio Salieri 2978349 0 24440 20200809034733
List of compositions by César Cui 3193080 0 26475 20210110153256
List of compositions by Mieczyslaw Weinberg 3896810 0 12169 20201011070517
List of compositions by Johann Pachelbel 4310250 0 50238 20200308114158
List of compositions by Harrison Birtwistle 4328329 0 13914 20201127124704
List of compositions by Sergei Taneyev 4413896 0 4417 20200303212813
List of compositions by Arnold Bax 4478687 0 10828 20210114091622
List of compositions by Georg Böhm 4490638 0 3922 20201220070935
List of compositions by François Couperin 4492324 0 10326 20201130102018
List of compositions by Leo Sowerby 4539870 0 2183 20200303212601
List of compositions by Fanny Mendelssohn 4796928 0 47612 20201128101039
List of compositions by Jean-Baptiste Lully 4876541 0 12125 20200817124545
List of compositions by Johann Jakob Froberger 5060185 0 21283 20201223150616
List of compositions by Joseph Martin Kraus 5211099 0 8716 20200303212539
List of compositions by Karol Szymanowski 5880500 0 27059 20201228202020
List of compositions by Modest Mussorgsky 5900698 0 57217 20200502033449
List of compositions by Witold Lutosławski 5985873 0 12653 20200807094927
List of compositions by Mauro Giuliani 6009356 0 8913 20200605075547
List of compositions by Emilio Pujol 6063093 0 2971 20200615023822
List of compositions by Giacinto Scelsi 6936659 0 7479 20200622092115
List of compositions by Anton Rubinstein 7362534 0 15113 20210105050608
List of compositions by Friedrich Kuhlau 8017707 0 27781 20200721154810
List of compositions by Giovanni Bottesini 8187845 0 6365 20200303212344
List of compositions by Gustav Holst 8460756 0 61210 20201213145259
List of compositions by William Byrd 8644597 0 16402 20201211163553
List of compositions by George Enescu 8767522 0 12433 20200629160432
List of compositions by Django Reinhardt 8930372 0 6007 20201020132139
List of compositions by Akil Mark Koci 9024922 0 3611 20200303211858
List of compositions by Michael Haydn 9453086 0 43780 20200303212649
List of compositions by Guillaume de Machaut 9649446 0 9703 20200511192529
List of compositions by Karlheinz Stockhausen 10116532 0 34391 20200805232346
List of compositions by Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina 10331194 0 29510 20201203225122
List of compositions by Heinrich Schütz 10774186 0 39565 20200315094358
List of compositions by Alexander Glazunov 11075165 0 18131 20200721173803
List of compositions by Toru Takemitsu 11575584 0 81430 20200816221221
List of compositions by Arthur Honegger 11914674 0 38759 20201006203658
List of compositions by Paul Moravec 12065249 0 5138 20200305205648
List of compositions by Johann Nepomuk Hummel 12338589 0 24660 20210118193317
List of compositions by Sigismond Thalberg 12738233 0 16113 20201013123010
List of compositions by Anton Reicha 14022921 0 27191 20200308111956
List of compositions by Josef Suk 14136966 0 21382 20201102000423
List of compositions by Arthur Bliss 14289148 0 12334 20201024062002
List of compositions by Johann Adolph Hasse 14313735 0 4761 20201219122451
List of compositions by Carl Maria von Weber 14985252 0 23929 20201114145628
List of compositions by Charles-Valentin Alkan 15003671 0 23675 20201210191853
List of compositions by Nikolai Kapustin 15077628 0 10215 20200715153604
List of compositions by Reynaldo Hahn 15302834 0 45182 20210117181622
List of compositions by Otto Albert Tichý 15307465 0 11791 20200620131130
List of compositions by Howard Skempton 15557112 0 12536 20200827140209
List of compositions by Charles Ives 15694530 0 15109 20200318235319
List of compositions by Gregory Short 15868756 0 12815 20200303212354
List of compositions by Thomas Adès 15901176 0 11307 20201204005254
List of compositions by Henryk Górecki 15916550 0 11231 20210103040448
List of compositions by Robert Simpson 16095345 0 7506 20210118231513
List of compositions by Erik Chisholm 16546936 0 6815 20201208004137
List of compositions by Alexander Borodin 16820824 0 12967 20200327231717
List of compositions by Max Bruch 16899697 0 6199 20201111170437
List of compositions by Kurt Atterberg 17120178 0 6875 20201123160609
List of compositions by Muzio Clementi 17744138 0 12831 20200907043125
List of compositions by Francisco Tárrega 17751587 0 3782 20210117185441
List of compositions by Jennifer Higdon 17810951 0 4594 20200303212457
List of compositions by Daron Hagen 17823848 0 8878 20200303212045
List of compositions by Bedřich Smetana 17934848 0 45411 20201108095925
List of compositions by George Onslow 17976558 0 5792 20200303212334
List of compositions by Paul Juon 17983594 0 28456 20200316221720
List of compositions by Anton Diabelli 18012643 0 4942 20200701194510
List of compositions by Matteo Carcassi 18015418 0 13187 20200303212635
List of compositions by Fernando Sor 18017243 0 11666 20200913213205
List of compositions by Ferdinando Carulli 18323183 0 17040 20200303212136
List of compositions by Charles Wuorinen 18530355 0 28553 20200924210921
List of compositions by Zdeněk Fibich 18711171 0 40044 20201031045548
List of compositions by Fabio Vacchi 19160006 0 9793 20200525180937
List of compositions by James Scott 19616176 0 3935 20200303212439
List of compositions by Eugène Bozza 19769282 0 16763 20200303212126
List of compositions by Eric Ewazen 20320958 0 6137 20210108165325
List of compositions by Thomas Arne 20542642 0 33669 20201015164130
List of compositions by Simon Mayr 20755531 0 5963 20200303212818
List of compositions by Gioachino Rossini 20802174 0 5244 20200303212343
List of compositions by Léo Delibes 20843719 0 2948 20200303212624
List of compositions by Tomaso Albinoni 21000135 0 21978 20200418194626
List of compositions by Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach 21251361 0 50583 20201203154002
List of compositions by Lukas Foss 21464582 0 13729 20200303212622
List of compositions by Franz Lachner 21479307 0 33549 20210116092048
List of compositions by Victor Herbert 21512784 0 15397 20200303212845
List of compositions by Girolamo Frescobaldi 21654284 0 4497 20201024231052
List of compositions by David Maslanka 21850241 0 23009 20201024232630
List of compositions by Jan Ladislav Dussek 22056423 0 22584 20200303212443
List of compositions by Darius Milhaud 22200521 0 47022 20200303212043
List of compositions by Bill McGlaughlin 22325883 0 15302 20200308112312
List of compositions by Ferruccio Busoni 22397005 0 141752 20201013062154
List of compositions by Malcolm Williamson 22552251 0 19526 20200614190420
List of compositions by Einojuhani Rautavaara 22577971 0 8021 20210117084238
List of compositions by Germaine Tailleferre 22598042 0 11623 20200714234133
List of compositions by Thomas Tallis 23026174 0 5185 20210104181518
List of compositions by Wilhelm Kienzl 23139836 0 7546 20200303212850
List of compositions by Johann Christian Bach 23654721 0 21462 20200901172555
List of compositions by Georges Bizet 23691895 0 8634 20210103051140
List of compositions by Louis Couperin 23811552 0 21198 20200718022418
List of compositions by Takashi Yoshimatsu 23899017 0 20818 20200627234336
List of compositions by Lorenzo Perosi 24701780 0 11947 20200303212607
List of compositions by Johann Joachim Quantz 24732400 0 38953 20210107120807
List of compositions by Constant Lambert 25006590 0 6485 20200510143244
List of compositions by Lord Berners 25036977 0 3466 20210118123138
List of compositions by Niccolò Paganini 25077833 0 27400 20200303212708
List of compositions by Morton Feldman 25166668 0 24436 20210103035405
List of compositions by Josef Tal 25224768 0 17379 20200801225135
List of compositions by Giovanni Sgambati 25456318 0 5609 20200806133454
List of compositions by Manuel de Falla 25521396 0 5225 20200303212628
List of compositions by Johanna Senfter 25708820 0 5176 20200303212521
List of compositions by Édouard Lalo 25709215 0 6108 20200417213434
List of compositions by Luise Adolpha Le Beau 25717201 0 4182 20200303212621
List of compositions by José Vianna da Motta 25717486 0 2808 20200303212542
List of compositions by Friedrich Kalkbrenner 25722435 0 3702 20200509233204
List of compositions by Othmar Schoeck 25733779 0 22118 20200303212726
List of compositions by Ignaz Brüll 25734189 0 8302 20201023160721
List of compositions by Henry Litolff 25734368 0 5669 20200303212415
List of compositions by Carl Loewe 25734576 0 23025 20200610225233
List of compositions by Zygmunt Stojowski 25742572 0 3994 20200303212905
List of compositions by Emilie Mayer 25742844 0 3495 20201101122752
List of compositions by Nikolai Myaskovsky 25788225 0 9938 20200413213242
List of compositions by Henri Herz 25817376 0 13123 20200303212411
List of compositions by Christian Sinding 25817768 0 7534 20200820012927
List of compositions by Clémence de Grandval 25843728 0 4798 20201229182659
List of compositions by Donald Tovey 25856081 0 2244 20200612201636
List of compositions by Alexander Dreyschock 25857839 0 4863 20200303211905
List of compositions by Sergei Bortkiewicz 25948321 0 7845 20200518014513
List of compositions by Joseph Holbrooke 25966751 0 59081 20200909095651
List of compositions by Friedrich Kiel 25969210 0 3447 20200303212314
List of compositions by Felix Blumenfeld 25971702 0 3115 20200723203821
List of compositions by William Sterndale Bennett 26004766 0 2397 20200303212854
List of compositions by Robert Volkmann 26008940 0 4308 20200929124114
List of compositions by Albert Dietrich 26016686 0 4136 20201005134045
List of compositions by Jenő Hubay 26045206 0 51396 20200303212459
List of compositions by Theodor Kirchner 26100056 0 5443 20200303212827
List of compositions by Felix Weingartner 26124224 0 4293 20200303212135
List of compositions by York Bowen 26654069 0 9408 20200406180223
List of compositions by F. Melius Christiansen 27035768 0 1236 20200507014938
List of compositions by Alexander Mosolov 27249973 0 7876 20200304142003
List of compositions by Mikhail Ippolitov-Ivanov 27390004 0 17404 20200303212657
List of compositions by Frederic Austin 27707206 0 15806 20200307185748
List of compositions by Louis Vierne 27887541 0 17740 20210107194724
List of compositions by Frank Bridge 28009498 0 40677 20210102011747
List of compositions by James MacMillan 28821553 0 53022 20210118204236
List of compositions by Glenn Gould 28953001 0 3929 20200308113916
List of compositions by Michael Tippett 29250458 0 28129 20201018135136
List of compositions by Johann David Heinichen 29998700 0 16426 20200523175250
List of compositions by Dmitry Kabalevsky 30319788 0 8306 20201019085558
List of compositions by Frederick Delius 30472973 0 26844 20201127190625
List of compositions by Jean Françaix 30490237 0 52569 20200706073658
List of compositions by Ernst Krenek 30631357 0 6155 20200303212122
List of compositions by Libby Larsen 31111829 0 23803 20200303212605
List of compositions by Charles Villiers Stanford 31155109 0 12395 20201217223142
List of compositions by Nino Rota 31209604 0 7710 20200303212721
List of compositions by Louis Spohr 31257657 0 7079 20210103045445
List of compositions by Emmanuel Chabrier 31328742 0 6332 20200303212107
List of compositions by Charles Gounod 31511729 0 33050 20200910093727
List of compositions by Jan Dismas Zelenka 31522196 0 11896 20201012050139
List of compositions by Ethel Smyth 31535438 0 9539 20201124192955
List of compositions by Marcel Dupré 32324474 0 20263 20200303212630
List of compositions by Jacques Offenbach 32521240 0 5505 20200303212433
List of compositions by Josef Bohuslav Foerster 32551625 0 43778 20200715131631
List of compositions by Carlos Salzedo 32907131 0 14544 20200602224534
List of compositions by Eric Coates 33047815 0 31303 20200921084909
List of compositions by Jan Kalivoda 33183111 0 14689 20200308114120
List of compositions by Božidar Kantušer 33502720 0 20599 20200303211958
List of compositions by Malcolm Arnold 33644765 0 10848 20210106102918
List of compositions by Henri Vieuxtemps 33824620 0 31126 20200303212412
List of compositions by Kaikhosru Shapurji Sorabji 33921889 0 18780 20201209090052
List of compositions by Marc Wilkinson 34035835 0 4294 20200401144632
List of compositions by Salvatore Sciarrino 34197944 0 10201 20200519131720
List of compositions by Jean Langlais 34216877 0 7845 20200303212449
List of compositions by Vagn Holmboe 34322819 0 38561 20201011064115
List of compositions by Christoph Willibald Gluck 34963965 0 7878 20201025170035
List of compositions by Tobias Picker 35446476 0 7152 20200922162230
List of compositions by Alan Hovhaness 35475952 0 60923 20210114203525
List of compositions by Nikolai Medtner 35691089 0 10670 20201217150930
List of compositions by Alexander Mackenzie 35763699 0 8160 20200711094046
List of compositions by Leo Brouwer 36169408 0 9883 20201231114921
List of compositions by William Bolcom 36467263 0 3732 20200515003645
List of compositions by Bill Evans 36540642 0 6719 20200303211953
List of compositions by Peter Warlock 36596320 0 13678 20201104094426
List of compositions by Michael Finnissy 36645173 0 56584 20200913145309
List of compositions by Tomáš Svoboda 36653471 0 7480 20200303212837
List of compositions by Niels Viggo Bentzon 36799693 0 32169 20200328113457
List of compositions by Kalevi Aho 36814592 0 11190 20201027073229
List of compositions by Franco Donatoni 37106998 0 10073 20200303212145
List of compositions by François-Adrien Boieldieu 37309736 0 2432 20200303212306
List of compositions by Jacques Champion de Chambonnières 37600874 0 31374 20210110182129
List of compositions by Franz Krommer 37641524 0 42351 20200505201732
List of compositions by Nikos Skalkottas 37999912 0 5121 20200319171232
List of compositions by Gerald Finzi 38063743 0 14941 20210107222537
List of compositions by John Corigliano 38137791 0 18829 20200303212524
List of compositions by Alexandre Goria 38671953 0 56207 20210105215745
List of compositions by Hubert Parry 38899006 0 10855 20200303212421
List of compositions by George Whitefield Chadwick 39168356 0 4279 20201030141010
List of compositions by Jane Joseph 39368116 0 10291 20200303212444
List of compositions by John Woolrich 39447114 0 6980 20200303212529
List of compositions by Amy Beach 39586363 0 18004 20200310193412
List of compositions by Johann Baptist Wanhal 39701293 0 7096 20201123230039
List of compositions by Ignaz Moscheles 39926294 0 16227 20200330172444
List of compositions by Matthew de Lacey Davidson 40153064 0 4767 20200730205233
List of compositions by Erich Wolfgang Korngold 40472821 0 9977 20201001011755
List of compositions by Frederik Magle 41821386 0 4823 20200308113810
List of compositions by Imogen Holst 41830273 0 24047 20200303212429
List of compositions by André Previn 42047542 0 17502 20200912010856
List of compositions by Frederic Rzewski 42330756 0 6540 20201217170953
List of compositions by Joachim Raff 42380199 0 20137 20200710085630
List of compositions by Carlo Gesualdo 43045815 0 5890 20200715035109
List of compositions by Tielman Susato 43137132 0 7162 20200303212833
List of compositions by Pierre Rode 43210592 0 3523 20200303212745
List of compositions by Cécile Chaminade 43383629 0 19396 20200303212038
List of compositions by Stanisław Moniuszko 43509312 0 13404 20200402125300
List of compositions by Sylvius Leopold Weiss 43515147 0 104131 20200303212823
List of compositions by Enrique Granados 43793510 0 6665 20210115134207
List of compositions by Giuseppe Corsi da Celano 43820472 0 6600 20200303212350
List of compositions by Mario Castelnuovo-Tedesco 43903177 0 41678 20200831134230
List of compositions by Miklós Rózsa 43925653 0 10545 20200923183038
List of compositions by Eduard Strauss 43995874 0 4994 20200308112523
List of compositions by Juan Crisóstomo Arriaga 44238445 0 3306 20200308114327
List of compositions by Geirr Tveitt 44583988 0 6029 20200725110934
List of compositions by Ottorino Respighi 44884598 0 27122 20200727081021
List of compositions by Michael Torke 45381766 0 6502 20200303212652
List of compositions by James Hotchkiss Rogers 45638666 0 13498 20200303212436
List of compositions by Alois Hába 45659592 0 8690 20200303211917
List of compositions by Percy Pitt 45702517 0 18527 20210104123140
List of compositions by Swan Hennessy 46269787 0 35413 20200330064836
List of compositions by Jake Heggie 47398176 0 25310 20200303212435
List of compositions by Otar Taktakishvili 47744615 0 17976 20200303212725
List of compositions by Michael Daugherty 47996191 0 8682 20201212042823
List of compositions by György Kurtág 48001525 0 16366 20200907154619
List of compositions by Aivars Kalējs 48033791 0 10776 20200303211857
List of compositions by Viktor Kosenko 48856932 0 62756 20200308115223
List of compositions by Johann Ludwig Krebs 49088826 0 24960 20210110111258
List of compositions by Jean-Claude Éloy 49130376 0 13968 20200303212456
List of compositions by Seán Doherty 50097055 0 1436 20200303212815
List of compositions by Maria Szymanowska 50516943 0 5635 20201201215534
List of compositions by Alan Bush 50915196 0 43179 20200303211859
List of compositions by Yehuda Yannay 51074602 0 10169 20201017143917
List of compositions by Leevi Madetoja 51116014 0 66697 20201201210811
List of compositions by Elliott Carter 51253452 0 8001 20200828024748
List of compositions by Julius Harrison 52480129 0 12960 20201001071644
List of compositions by Teresa Carreño 52611827 0 6486 20201222153748
List of compositions by Franz Benda 52776295 0 17233 20200303212148
List of compositions by Isaac Albéniz 52852807 0 8281 20200303212430
List of compositions by Erkki Melartin 53033614 0 134698 20201025185857
List of compositions by Leopold Koželuch 53450467 0 19999 20200303212602
List of compositions by Henrique Oswald 54411805 0 16546 20201203154012
List of compositions by Claudio Monteverdi 54590872 0 36332 20200719140106
List of compositions by Agostino Steffani 55015662 0 5814 20200907043118
List of compositions by Johann Peter Pixis 56731104 0 11218 20201103084152
List of compositions by Domenico Cimarosa 56800586 0 11363 20210110074221
List of compositions by André Messager 57116045 0 5530 20200303211919
List of compositions by Luigi Nono 57381329 0 5624 20200303212620
List of compositions by Ernest Bloch 57683356 0 5487 20201001071636
List of compositions by Alfred Schnittke 58229913 0 12118 20201227180531
List of compositions by Betsy Jolas 58483814 0 10661 20201203153952
List of compositions by Aulis Sallinen 59097616 0 75977 20201201223941
List of compositions by Eugene Aynsley Goossens 59116968 0 25435 20200303212124
List of compositions by Niels Gade 59715804 0 17520 20200508191550
List of compositions by Jean Guillou 59801457 0 12960 20200303212448
List of compositions by Silvestre Revueltas 60243768 0 4767 20190605102803
List of compositions by Geoffrey Bush 60862828 0 15050 20200303212324
List of compositions by Guillaume Lekeu 61247459 0 13846 20200610225323
List of compositions by Joaquín Turina 61264972 0 17657 20200303212502
List of compositions by Alexander von Zemlinsky 61608475 0 10509 20200704191555
List of compositions by Herbert Howells 61867126 0 8674 20201115040700
List of compositions by Carlos Chávez 62979580 0 13580 20200303212016
List of compositions by Arlene Sierra 63477931 0 3838 20200523191842
List of compositions by Orlando Gibbons 63607746 0 32064 20210106080144
List of compositions by William Boyce 64494429 0 24977 20201024060011
List of compositions by Kaija Saariaho 64980327 0 27784 20210106075853
List of compositions by Martin Lohse 65734966 0 29938 20210110085424

This would be unfeasible for this navbox. Thus, I'm proposing to delete the entire group. As far I can see, almost none of the composition pages linked right now actually transclude the navbox. intforce (talk) 02:04, 19 January 2021 (UTC)[reply]

I have no objection to this and it seems that Francis has gone ahead and removed them. I wonder if we could do something similar to Template:Lists of paintings and sort by period? Seems like an appropriate alternative in my mind. Aza24 (talk) 06:23, 19 January 2021 (UTC)[reply]
The template is useless at the moment. The edits deleting the template have not been explained. Before those deletions, Ravel and Debussy could not really be described as Romantic composers, cf Chansons madécasses or Études (Debussy)? Mathsci (talk) 07:25, 19 January 2021 (UTC)[reply]
I never met this template, and find it useless, with or without composers. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 08:51, 19 January 2021 (UTC)[reply]
I don't find adding every composer to be feasible or frankly useful. That being said, I think that the instruments/ensemble pages (e.g Viola A-B or Concert Band, etc.) should be kept as is or even expanded. (edit) Actually, this may be a good time to talk about Viola A-B and all the other following pages. Why are we listing 10,500 works that just happen to have the viola; even by composers without their own pages? Why? I Ask (talk) 00:18, 21 January 2021 (UTC)[reply]
@Why? I Ask: cleaning up in accordance to your suggestions. --Francis Schonken (talk) 06:16, 21 January 2021 (UTC)[reply]
@Francis Schonken: I believe that we need to delete some pages themselves. Pages such as List of compositions for arpeggione or Jew's harp music can either be combined with their parent pages or just outright deleted considering none of the works listed on those pages are notable enough for their own articles
... which is not something to be discussed or decided on this template talk page: should be raised in an appropriate place (unless if WP:BOLD action suffices). --Francis Schonken (talk) 04:52, 22 January 2021 (UTC)[reply]