Awarding the album five stars at Worship Leader, Jay Akins states, "The collaborative product of the large artist community of songwriters, filmmakers, and musicians at the church, each song on This Glorious Grace has a story of life change through the power of the Gospel. This offering is a rare must-have for your church."[2] Mikayla Shriver, giving the album four stars from New Release Today, writes, "Their latest release, This Glorious Grace, is a live worship album which perfectly reflects the heart of the church's worship ministry...This Glorious Grace is a fantastic live worship album, and this is definitely not the last anyone will hear of Austin Stone Worship."[1] Reviewing the album for Soul-Audio, Andrew Greenhalgh says, "It’s this personal yet universal touch that colors the worship of Austin Stone Worship and which helps take it to the next level."[3]