User:104.153.231.105/Evaluate an Article

Evaluate an article

This is where you will complete your article evaluation. Please use the template below to evaluate your selected article.

• Name of article: Nuclear gene
• I chose to evaluate this article because it is on the to-do list of the Molecular Biology project.

Lead

The article only includes a short factual description of what a Nuclear gene is. It does not have sections. Its level of detail is fine but it is confusing.

Content

The article is relevant and up to date. Is the article's content relevant to the topic?

Tone and Balance

The article is neutral and factual.Is the article neutral?

Sources and References

The facts are backed up by just a few sources. They are exclusively books but no primary literature.

Organization

Guiding questions

I find it uneasy to read. No grammar or spelling error though.

Images and Media

It does not include any image or media.

Checking the talk page

Not much is going on in the Talk page. The article is part of the Molecular Biology/Genetics project.

Overall impressions

The article looks like a draft with not much information. One of the comments on the Talk page says there should be no redirect from Nuclear genome to Nuclear gene. I think there should be a redirect from Nuclear Gene to Nuclear genome. It could be improved by, either, adding details regarding the specificities of Nuclear genes, or fusing this with Nuclear genome.