User:ChristinaDunigan/Lucy Hagenow
![]() | This is not a Wikipedia article: It is an individual user's work-in-progress page, and may be incomplete and/or unreliable. For guidance on developing this draft, see Wikipedia:So you made a userspace draft. Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL |
Lucy Hagenow
Lucy Hagenow | |
---|---|
![]() Dr. Lucy Hagenow | |
Born | 1852 or November, 1848 Germany |
Died | September 26, 1933 Norwood Park, IL |
Other names | Louise or Louisa Hagenow |
Occupation | Abortion practitioner |
Lucy Hagenow (1852 or November, 1848 – September 26, 1933) was also known as Louise or Louisa Hagenow. She was a notorious criminal abortionist of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, whose exploits in San Francisco and Chicago sparked nationwide headlines. The Bellingham Herald called her a "human monster."[1] The Seattle Times proclaimed, "Lucy Hagenow of Chicago has Criminal Record that Surpasses Anything of a Similar Nature in World's History." [2]
Hagenow first operated as Louisa Hagenow, then as Louise Hagenow, in San Francisco, then switched over to the name Lucy Hagenow after moving to Chicago.
Early life
[edit]Hagenow was born in Germany in either 1852[3] or in November of 1848[4]. She immigrated to the United States in either 1865[3] or 1870[3], likely along with her mother[5] and two sisters.
Hagenow had a diploma dated June 26, 1876 from the Homeopathic Medical College of Missouri[6], which graduated female physicians from 1874 to 1909[7]. She later claimed that she had graduated from Missouri Medical College in 1879[8].
The California Years
[edit]Hagenow's name first surfaces as "Hagenow, Dr. L." in the 1877 San Francisco city directory under "Physicians, Female," practicing at 14 Turk Street.[9].
Her first documented run-ins with the law came in 1879, when she was arrested for abortion, then shortly thereafter for battery at her San Francisco practice for brawling with a patient. The patient told police that she had gone to Hagenow's practice to complain that Hagenow had sent her home injured then delayed coming to treat her for the complications, and that Hagenow had "replied with some coarse epithet." Hagenow argued that the patient had been sent by a rival to try to get her arrested again for abortion.[10]
The Death of L.D.
[edit]Hagenow was indicted on a charge of murder in the death August 27, 1886 death of abortion patient L.D. [11] The L.D. murder case exemplified how complex dealings with Hagenow could be. L.D.'s death certificate was signed with the name of Dr. F. F. Gedecky by Jules Maurin at Hagenow's request.[12] At first Gedecky denied that he had given Hagenow permission to use his name, but under oath he admitted that he had given permission for her to use his name only if the death could be verified as due to peritonitis, and only if she informed him afterward.[12]
Hagenow attempted to get the L.D. murder cased dismissed in January of 1888 on the grounds that the juries in the two previous trials had disagreed.[13] The case went forward, however, and led to an acquittal in April of 1888, largely due to the loss of the state's prime witness when local journalist D. C. Buckley, who had done the original investigation of L.D.'s death, himself died.[14][15]
The Death of A.D.
[edit]On July 26, 1888, nearly three months to the day after the acquittal, 16-year-old patient A.D. died after having been treated at Hagenow's Twelfth Street hospital/maternity home.[16] Hagenow faced three trials for the murder of A.D., the first with one holdout leading to a hung jury, and the second with two holdouts.[17] She was released in November of 1889 on a reduced bail of $10,000 to await a third trial,[18] which ended in a third hung jury in May of 1890.[19]
The Early Chicago Years
[edit]Hagenow relocated to Chicago, and was issued a license to practice medicine on April 12, 1890.[6] Just as she had done in San Francisci, she opened a lying-in hospital.[20]
Through the late 1890s, Hagenow ran thinkly-veiled advertisements for her practice in the Chicago Inter Ocean, usually reading:
- DR. LOUISA HAGENOW, 104 N. WELLS Successful treatment of monthly irregularities by new method approved by Prof. Koch, of Berlin; no operation; 22 years' practice; private home.[21]
1891: The Death of M.D.
[edit]Hagenow was held to a grand jury in January of 1891 in connection with the death of M.D. At the coroner's inquest, witnesses testified that M.D. had gone to Hagenow "for relief from her woe," and suffered "from a criminal operation." In an attempt to treat her, someone administered carbolic acid, which rather than heal the woman killed her. However, Hagenow's attorney requested a writ of habeas corpus, which was granted by Judge Tuthill, who said that only ignorance could have led the coroner's jury to hold Hagenow, who "should not have spent an hour in jail.[22]
1892: The Deaths of S.K and E.A.
[edit]S.K., 30 years of age, died at Cook County Hospital on September 25, 1892. She had been brought there by ambulance from Hagenow's practice. Although the woman's father identified Hagenow as the perpetrator of the fatal abortion, the woman herself insisted that she had undergone an abortion elsewhere and had just taken ill near the home of a midwife who brought her to Hagenow's practice to recover.[23][24]
On December 12, 1892, E.A. died under circumstances that strongly cast suspicion on Hagenow. Several women who had attended the dying woman named a man "responsible for her condition," who took police to Hagenow's practice and identified it as the place to which he had accompanied E.A. on the day she underwent the fatal abortion. Hagenow was held over to a grandy jury by the coroner's jury.[25] On March 13, 1893, her murder trial in E.A.'s death ended in an acquittal by order of Judge McConnell, who told the jury that the state had not presented sufficient evidence to convict.[26]
1896: The Death of H.C.
[edit]On July 2, 1896, Hagenow, along with Dr. Ida von Schultz, was arrested after patient H.C. turned up at Emergency Hospital, dying several hours later from abortion compliations.[27][28]
1906: The Death of Lola Maddison
[edit]1907: National Outrage
[edit]On November 30, 1907, Hagenow -- making her first offical appearance as Lucy rather than as Louise or Louisa -- burst onto the national scene when she was sentenced to 20 years in Joliet Prison for the death of patient A.H.[29]
This particular conviction sparked attention for a number of reasons.
One was the gruesome nature of the testimony, which included graphic accounts of other women who had died under Hagenow's care. Eclipsing even the gore was the tangled web of scandal the press could associate with one of Hagenow's prior deaths. The victim, Lola Maddison, a stenographer from Salt Lake City, was revealed to be the sister of Anne Maddison Bradley, the spurned lover whose trial for the murder of former U.S. Senator Arthur Brown of Utah was opening in Washington. Though the father of L.M.'s unborn baby was never posititvely identified, Chicago police indicated that "he was a prominent lawyer and former federal official of Utah."[30]
Furthermore, during closing arguments, the prosecution made two spectacular assertions: that Hagenow had been a practicing abortionist for 37 years, and that she had been responsible for a thousand deaths. The first assertion is in keeping with Hagenow's own claim that she had graduated from medical school in 1870. The latter claim would mean an average of 27 deaths at her hands annually.[30][29] It is unclear whether the prosecutor was claiming that Hagenow killed that number of unborn children by abortion annually, or that her abortion practice was so busy and deadly that 1,000 of her patients had succumbed over the years. An Associated Press article seems to indicate that the reference was to dead patients:
- "Dr." Hagenow has long been a thorn to the police, and the object of attacks by physicians and medical societies. It was stated in the closing argument for the state that Mrs. Hagenow had practiced for thirty seven years, and had been the cause of a thousand deaths. one of the deaths is that of Lola Madison, sister of Mrs. Bradley, whose trial for the murder of Senator Brown, of Utah, is in progress at Washington.[29]
That the reference might have been to Hagenow's patients is supported by the testimony of undertaker W. J. Freckleton, sent by A.H.'s husband to collect the body of his wife for burial. Freckleton said that he had complained to Hagenow how difficult it was to get the body down the narrow staircase; Hagenow had replied that her usual undertaker never had any trouble getting bodies out.[31]
In an article headlined, "Old Woman Kills Ten Thousand Persons," and that "Lucy Hagenow of Chicago Has Criminal Record That Surpasses Anything of a Similar Nature in World's History."[2], the Seattle Times said that Hagenow had been the cause of 10,000 deaths. This would indicate that the prosecutor had been referring to around 270 abortions perpetrated annually by Hagenow.
The news of Hagenow's conviction went national, with coverage in states as wide-flung as Arizona[32], Idaho[33], Michigan[34], Montana[35], Nebraska[36], Washington[37],
The Tuscon Daily Citizen, which referred to Hagenow as a "terrible old woman," alone of all the papers picking up the Associated Press story, noted that Hagenow had also been accused of "the murder by poison of several children."[32]
Citywide Bribery Investigation
[edit]In May of 1907, the city of Chicago convened a grand jury, under the charge of States' Attorney Healy[38], to investigate charges that at least 133 midwives and physicians in the city were able to operate abortion businesses unmolested by bribing politicians and police officers. Falsified death certificates would be issued in order to obtain burial permits.[20][39]
Hagenow was called before the grand jury as a star witness on May 24 to answer questions regarding an interview she had done earlier in which she had made specific allegations about numerous abortion practitioners, and had admitted to paying bribes herself.[39]
Wire service coverage of the investigation, and Hagenow's involvement, appeared in papers all over the country.
The grand jury, while convened, also indicted Hagenow a second time regarding the death of Lola Maddison of Salt Lake City, since the indictment handed down the previous year had been dropped due to a technicality[39][20].
Lifestyle
[edit]Hagenow evidently thrived financially during her practicing years. She was the victim of a burglary that made the news in New York and Michigan as well as in Chicago, when George Alexander, a former police chief of Muskegon, Michigan, as well as a former Deputy U.S. Marshall, broke into her home, beat her mother severely into unconsciousness, and stole between $1,000 and $3,000 worth of jewlery.[40][41]
Bibliography
[edit]Include a bibliography listed in MLA format. Use EasyBib.com for assisted MLA-formatted bibliography entries, or OttoBib for automatic bibliography creation from a list of ISBN numbers. See Reference management software for additional tools.
Always cite your sources! No original research![42]
Notes/Further reading
[edit]See also
[edit]List related internal (Wikipedia) articles in alphabetical order. Common nouns are listed first. Proper nouns follow.
References
[edit]- ^ "Human Monster is Behind Bars," Bellingham Herald, November 30, 1907
- ^ a b "Old Woman Kills Ten Thousand Persons," The Seattle Daily Times, November 30, 1907
- ^ a b c United States Census 1910
- ^ United States Census 1910
- ^ "Hagenow Diamond Robbery," Duluth News Tribune, August 28, 1898
- ^ a b Annual Report of the State Board of Health of Illinois, December 31, 1893
- ^ Early Medical Education for Women in St. Louis
- ^ "Doctors to Help Convict Doctors," Chicago Tribune, 15 May 1907
- ^ San Francisco, California, City Directory, 1877
- ^ "A Tripartite Row" San Francisco Bulletin, July 26, 1879
- ^ "Mrs. Hagenow. She Appears Before Judge Sullivan in a San Francisco Court," San Jose Evening News, September 24, 1887
- ^ a b "Strange Death Certificate," Portland Oregonian, December 7, 1887
- ^ "Mrs. Hagenow's Case," San Jose Evening News, January 30, 1888
- ^ "Dr. Hagenow. She is Acquitted of the Charge of the Murder of Louise Derchow," San Jose Evening News, April 25, 1888
- ^ "A Bad Couple," Riverside Daily Press, February 7, 1889
- ^ "Mrs. Hagenow's Trial," San Francisco Bulletin, February 7, 1889
- ^ "The Third Trial of Mrs. Hagenow," The Portland Oregonian, October 25, 1889
- ^ "Mrs. Hagenow's and Dr. Dodel's Bail," San Francisco Bulletin, November 18, 1889
- ^ "Louisa Hagenow. She is Released from Custody -- Three Trials for Murder," San Jose Evening News, May 26, 1890
- ^ a b c "Malpractice Involves Many. Men and Women under Investigation at Chicago," Fort Worth Star-Telegram, Sunday, May 26, 1907
- ^ Chicago Inter Ocean, June 16, 1895
- ^ "July's Wild Waste of Ignorance," Chicago Herald, January 29, 1891
- ^ "Points to an Awful Crime. Doctors Believed to Have Caused the Death of Mrs. Sophia Kuhn, Chicago Daily Inter Ocean, September 26, 1892
- ^ "Female Physicians Held. Police Make Two Arrests in the Sophia Kuhns Case," Chicago Daily Inter Ocean, September 27, 1892
- ^ "Dr. Hagenow in Trouble. She is Held to the Grand Jury on an Ugly Charge," Chicago Daily Inter Ocean, December 16, 1892
- ^ "Louise Hagenow Acquitted of the Charge of Murder, Chicago Daily Inter Ocean, March 14, 1893
- ^ "Told in a Paragraph," Chicago Inter-Ocean, July 2, 1896
- ^ "Midwives Charged With Murder. Responsible for Result of a Criminal Operation," Chicago Daily Inter Ocean, July 3, 1896
- ^ a b c "Finds Woman Guilty Said to Have Been Cause of Thousand Deaths," Canton Evening Repository, November 30, 1907
- ^ a b "Sister of Slayer. Mrs. Bradley's Relative Victim of Operation, Court Hears," Bay City Times, Thursday, November 28, 1907
- ^ 236 Ill. 524, 86 N.E. 370, People v. Hagenow
- ^ a b "Mrs.Bradley's Sister Was Victim of Murder," Tuscon Daily Citizen, November 30, 1907
- ^ "Woman Sent to Prison," Idaho Statesman, December 1, 1907
- ^ "Thousand Deaths Caused by Chicago Woman by Malpractice," Bay City Times, November 30, 1907
- ^ "Gets Thirty Years," The Anaconda Standard, December 1, 1907
- ^ "Alleged Author of 1,000 Deaths," Omaha World Herald, December 1, 1907
- ^ "Accused of 1,000 Deaths," The Morning Olympian, December 1, 1907
- ^ "Doctor Gave Hush Money. Chicago Grand Jury Investigating Startling Charges in That City," Portland Oregonian, May 24, 1907
- ^ a b c "Infant Murder is Protected by Graft," Olympia Record, May 24, 1907
- ^ "Told in a Paragraph," Chicago Inter Ocean, July 2, 1896
- ^ "Fall of an Ex-Police Chief," Denver Post, March 5, 1898
- ^ Last, first (date). Name of page. Page xx. Publisher: xxxx
External links
[edit]List official websites, organizations named after the subject, and other interesting yet relevant websites. No spam.
Categories go here.