User:Dalton spearman/sandbox

Copy and paste the Wikipedia markup code below the line into your Wikipedia sandbox. This gives you 5 sections for the items you should have in your sandbox, and it makes it easy for me to grade your sandbox to give you an A: Proposed edits to your article Your reading list A revised paragraph from your article Your original contributions to your article drawn from your readings A list of references for all your citations I will look for these sections when I grade your sandbox, so they are important.

COPY THE CODE BELOW THE LINE

Dalton Spearman's Homeridae article for ENGL9876.99

Analysis of Article

Article needs reevaluation based on the instance of various grammatical errors, paragraph structuring not applying to Wikipedia standards and regulations. The article itself flows choppily and has no discernale structure other than a basic line of events. Dividers are needed and fact checking is required for some aspects.

1. Narrator & Point of View
2. Mentioned Characters:

1. Asclepius
2. Pindar
3. Isocrates
4. Eros
5. Cynaethus
6. Harpocration
7. Acusilaus
8. Hellanicus of Lesbos
9. Strabo
10. Thucydides

Reading List

"Homer and the Homeridae The spread of a 'network of stories'". http://mediterraneannetworks.weebly.com/. 5 May 2015. Retrieved 21 October 2015. {{cite web}}: External link in |website= (help)

Barbara Graziosi. Inventing Homer: The Early Reception of Epic. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-80966. {{cite book}}: |access-date= requires |url= (help); Check |isbn= value: length (help)

Original Paragraph

The Homeridae were a family, clan or professional lineage on the island of Chios claiming descent from the Greek epic poet Homer.

The origin of the name seems obvious: in classical Greek the word should mean "children of Homer". An analogous name, Asclepiadae, identified a clan or guild of medical practitioners as "children of Asclepius". However, since the existence of the Homeridae is authenticated while that of Homer is not, and since Greek homeros is a common noun meaning "hostage", it was suggested even in ancient times that the Homeridae were in reality "children (or descendants) of hostages". The natural further step is to argue that Homer, the supposed founder, is a mythical figure, a mere back-formation, deriving his name from that of the later guild.

Their influence on the dark early history of transmission of the Homeric texts, though incalculable, is sure to have been conservative.

Evidence on the Homeridae relates to the late sixth, fifth and fourth centuries BC, after which nothing more is heard of them.

The first contemporary mention of this group is in a poem of about 485 BC by Pindar:

In the same way as the Homeridae,

Singers of stitched words, usually
Begin with an address to Zeus ...

A "singer of stitched words" is a literal definition of a rhapsode.

Later contemporary references come in fourth-century texts, in the works of Plato and Isocrates. In one of his essays, written around 350 BC, Isocrates says:

Some of the Homeridae tell the story that Helen appeared to Homer in a dream and told him to make a poem about the Trojan expedition.

At a slightly earlier date Plato makes a similar comment:

I believe that some of the Homeridae recite two hymns to Eros from among the esoteric poems. One of them is quite disrespectful to the god, and, what's more, the metre is incorrect! This is what they sing:

Now this winged god is called by mortals Eros,

But immortals say "Pteros" because love must grow wings.

There are two further mentions, in Plato's Republic and in the Ion. In the latter the rhapsode Ion claims that he should be "crowned by the Homeridae" for his work in promoting the poems of Homer.

Supplementary information, of uncertain validity, is found in later Greek antiquarian writings. A scholarly commentary on Pindar's poem gives the following details:

The name Homeridae originally meant descendants of Homer, who maintained the tradition of singing his poems, but afterwards was applied to rhapsodes who did not claim literal descent from him. One famous member, Cynaethus of Chios, was at the centre of a group who were specially active in composing new poems and attaching them to Homer's works. Cynaethus himself was the author of the Homeric Hymn to Apollo and was the first to perform Homeric poems at Syracuse.

A second source is Harpocration, who names three early writers of Greek local history whose works are now lost: Acusilaus and Hellanicus of Lesbos apparently stated that the Homeridae were named after Homer, while Seleucus said that they were not. Finally, the geographer Strabo says that the people of Chios adduced the Homeridae as evidence that Homer came from Chios; which implies, though Strabo does not say it, that the Homeridae, too, came from Chios.

It seems from this evidence that the Homeridae were a guild of oral performers (rhapsodes, as implied by Pindar's phrase "singers of stitched words") who claimed to inherit Homer's tradition and performed poems ascribed to Homer, no doubt including the Iliad and Odyssey. They also developed stories about how the poems had originated, such as Homer's dream of Helen. Like other rhapsodes, they travelled widely, but they were perhaps based on Chios. Certain Homeridae were active in adding new poems to the tradition.

Incidentally, some people believed these attributions: Thucydides, though not easily fooled, quotes from a version of the Homeric Hymn to Apollo similar to the text now known and confidently ascribes it to Homer.

Bibliography

• Walter Burkert, 'Kynaithos, Polycrates and the Homeric Hymn to Apollo' in Arktouros: Hellenic studies presented to B. M. W. Knox ed. G. W. Bowersock, W. Burkert, M. C. J. Putnam (Berlin: De Gruyter, 1979) pp. 53–62.
• Dalby, Andrew (2006), Rediscovering Homer, New York, London: Norton, ISBN 0-393-05788-7, pp. 167–175
• Graziosi, Barbara (2002), Inventing Homer: the early reception of epic, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, ISBN 0-521-80966-5

Category:Oral epic poets Category:Homer Category:Ancient Chios

Revised Article

The Homeridae appear in antiquity as a proposed guild and descendants of the poet Homer, namely based on the island of Chios who are first mentioned to have existed in the year 523BC, and claim to be descendants of the Greek epic poet Homer.

Origin of Namesake

The origin of the name is in line with classical Greek the word/name Asclepiadae. An analogous name which identified a clan or guild of medical practitioners as "children of Asclepius". The proven existence of this proposed guild has yet to be substantiated, and with the Greek word homeros is a common noun meaning "hostage", it was suggested they people claiming the name Homeridae are actually the "children (or descendants) of hostages". The natural further step is to argue that Homer, the supposed founder, is a mythical figure, a mere back-formation, deriving his name from that of the later guild.

Their influence on the dark early history of transmission of the Homeric texts, though incalculable, is sure to have been conservative.

Historical Evidence

Evidence on the Homeridae relates to the late sixth, fifth and fourth centuries BC, after which nothing more is heard of them.

The first contemporary mention of this group is in a poem of about 485 BC by Pindar:

In the same way as the Homeridae,

Singers of stitched words, usually
Begin with an address to Zeus ...

A "singer of stitched words" is a literal definition of a rhapsode. Which was later made analogous with the name "Homeridae"

Later contemporary references come in fourth-century texts, in the works of Plato and Isocrates. In one of his essays, written around 350 BC, Isocrates says:

Some of the Homeridae tell the story that Helen appeared to Homer in a dream and told him to make a poem about the Trojan expedition.

At a slightly earlier date Plato makes a similar comment:

I believe that some of the Homeridae recite two hymns to Eros from among the esoteric poems. One of them is quite disrespectful to the god, and, what's more, the metre is incorrect! This is what they sing:

Now this winged god is called by mortals Eros,

But immortals say "Pteros" because love must grow wings.

There are two further mentions, in Plato's Republic and in the Ion. In the latter the rhapsode Ion claims that he should be "crowned by the Homeridae" for his work in promoting the poems of Homer.

Supporting Information

Supplementary information, that cannot be genuinely documented or validated, is found in later Greek antiquarian writings. A scholarly commentary on Pindar's poem gives the following details:

The name Homeridae originally meant descendants of Homer, who maintained the tradition of singing his poems, but afterwards was applied to rhapsodes who did not claim literal descent from him. One famous member, Cynaethus of Chios, was at the centre of a group who were specially active in composing new poems and attaching them to Homer's works. Cynaethus himself was the author of the Homeric Hymn to Apollo and was the first to perform Homeric poems at Syracuse.

A second source is Harpocration, who names three early writers of Greek local history whose works are now lost: Acusilaus and Hellanicus of Lesbos apparently stated that the Homeridae were named after Homer, while Seleucus said that they were not. Finally, the geographer Strabo says that the people of Chios adduced the Homeridae as evidence that Homer came from Chios; which implies, though Strabo does not say it, that the Homeridae, too, came from Chios.

Bibliography

• Walter Burkert, 'Kynaithos, Polycrates and the Homeric Hymn to Apollo' in Arktouros: Hellenic studies presented to B. M. W. Knox ed. G. W. Bowersock, W. Burkert, M. C. J. Putnam (Berlin: De Gruyter, 1979) pp. 53–62.
• Dalby, Andrew (2006), Rediscovering Homer, New York, London: Norton, ISBN 0-393-05788-7, pp. 167–175
• Graziosi, Barbara (2002), Inventing Homer: the early reception of epic, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, ISBN 0-521-80966-5

Category:Oral epic poets Category:Homer Category:Ancient Chios