User:DumbBOT/RfArSummary/Derek Smart

Summary of Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Derek_Smart/Proposed_decision (experimental)

• Majority: 5
• Total: 9

Color legend

Passed

Rejected

Cannot pass with current votes

Number	Title	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status
1	Conflict of interest	8	0	0	Passed
2	Transparency in editing	8	0	0	Passed
3	Article quality and sourcing	6	1	1	Passed
3.1	Neutral point of view and sources (... generic)	6	0	0	Passed
4	Use of primary sources	2	6	0	Rejected
5	Biographies of living persons	6	0	0	Passed
5.1	Biased or malicious content in biographical material	6	0	0	Passed
6	Personal attacks	6	0	0	Passed
1	Article has been edited by disruptive single-purpose accounts	8	0	0	Passed
2	Article raises concerns about quality	5	0	3	Passed
3	No evidence of legal threats	3	5	0	Rejected
4	Supreme Cmdr has engaged in personal attacks	8	0	0	Passed
5	Bill Huffman	6	0	0	Passed
5.1	Personal attacks and harassment by Bill Huffman	1	2	1
6	Outside comments	6	0	0	Passed
7	Derek Smart	6	0	0	Passed
7.1	Surrogates of Derek Smart	6	0	0	Passed
1	Limitation on reverts by single-purpose accounts	8	0	0	Passed
2	Referred for cleanup	4	0	4
3	Supreme Cmdr	4	2	1
3.1	Supreme Cmdr	6	1	0	Passed
4	Bill Huffman banned from editing articles which relate to Derek Smart	3	0	0
5	Bill Huffman banned for personal attacks	1	3	0
6	Bill Huffman placed on attack parole	1	1	0
7	Supreme Cmdr and other surrogates	6	0	0	Passed
8	Derek Smart	5	1	0	Passed
8.1	Use of BLP re. Derek Smart	3	0	0
1	Enforcement by block	6	0	0	Passed