User:DumbBOT/RfArSummary/Giano

Summary of Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Giano/Proposed_decision (experimental)

• Majority: 4
• Total: 7

Color legend

Passed

Rejected

Cannot pass with current votes

Number	Title	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status
1	Requests for adminship	6	0	0	Passed
2	Bureaucrats	6	0	0	Passed
3	Consensus	5	0	0	Passed
4	Advantages of consensus	6	0	0	Passed
5	Problems with consensus	6	0	0	Passed
6	The effect of failure of consensus	5	0	0	Passed
7	Administrator conduct	6	0	0	Passed
8	Second chances	5	0	0	Passed
9	Decisions are final	5	0	0	Passed
10	Appeal of a decision by Bureaucrats	1	3	0
11	Criticism welcome	4	0	1	Passed
12	Being upset	4	0	0	Passed
13	Wikipedia is not a battleground	4	0	0	Passed
14	Disruption	5	0	0	Passed
15	Disruption by administrators	6	0	0	Passed
16	Return to administrative status of desysopped administrators	1	1	1
17	Courtesy	6	0	0	Passed
18	Assume good faith	2	1	0
19	Discussion of controversial decisions	5	0	0	Passed
20	Productive policy discussion differentiated from trolling	3	2	1
21	Baiting	6	0	0	Passed
22	Taking the bait	2	1	1
23	A mixed system	1	4	0	Rejected
23.5	Contributors are valued	1	0	0
24	Respect	1	4	0	Rejected
25	Blocking of administrators and other wheels for disruption	1	2	1
26	Jurisdiction of the Arbitration Committee	5	0	0	Passed
27	Return of access levels	6	0	0	Passed
1	Carnildo	1	3	1	Cannot pass with current votes
2	Resysopping	5	0	0	Passed
3	Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Carnildo 3	5	0	0	Passed
4	Failure to achieve consensus	5	0	0	Passed
5	Closing of Carnildo's request for adminship	5	0	0	Passed
6	Opposition to closing of RfA	5	0	0	Passed
7	Giano's role in opposing the decision	5	0	0	Passed
8	John Reid's role in opposing the decision	5	0	0	Passed
9	Kelly Martin	4	0	0	Passed
10	Tony Sidaway	5	0	0	Passed
11	Giano	4	0	0	Passed
12	Giano II	6	0	0	Passed
13	JoshuaZ	5	0	0	Passed
14	Geogre	1	2	2	Cannot pass with current votes
15	Irpen	6	0	0	Passed
16	Jdforrester	6	0	0	Passed
17	Inksplotch is not a sockpuppet	1	3	0
17.1	Checkuser on Inksplotch does not find sockpuppeting	5	0	0	Passed
1	Carnildo restored to Administrative status	1	1	3	Cannot pass with current votes
2	John Reid is banned for one week	3	3	0
2.1	John Reid is strongly censured	2	2	0
3	Kelly Martin thanked	4	0	0	Passed
4	Tony Sidaway suspended	1	4	0	Rejected
4A	Tony Sidaway's sysop access	6	0	0	Passed
5	Giano II	6	0	0	Passed
6	Geogre desysopped	1	4	0	Rejected
7	Jdforrester reminded	4	0	0	Passed
8	Kelly Martin's sysop/checkuser/oversight access	6	0	0	Passed