User:DumbBOT/RfArSummary/Jean-Thierry Boisseau

Summary of Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Jean-Thierry_Boisseau/Proposed_decision (experimental)

• Majority: 5
• Total: 9

Color legend

Passed

Rejected

Cannot pass with current votes

Number	Title	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status
1	Courtesy	6	0	0	Passed
2	Conflict of interest	6	0	0	Passed
3	Experts with conflicts of interest	6	0	0	Passed
4	Wikipedia is not a battleground	6	0	0	Passed
5	Wikipedia is not a soapbox	6	0	0	Passed
6	Neutral point of view	6	0	0	Passed
7	"Consensus" never trumps NPOV	6	0	0	Passed
8	Public issues	1	3	1
9	Wikipedia is dynamic	6	0	0	Passed
10	Creative solutions and original research	6	0	0	Passed
11	Notability	3	2	1
12	Wikipedia is not an advertising venue	6	0	0	Passed
1	Musik Fabrik	6	0	0	Passed
2	User:Musikfabrik	5	0	0	Passed
3	Jean-Thierry Boisseau	6	0	0	Passed
4	Promotion of Musik Fabrik composers	6	0	0	Passed
5	Failure of Jean-Thierry Boisseau to assume good faith	6	0	0	Passed
6	Rudeness by Jean-Thierry_Boisseau	4	0	2
7	Jean-Thierry Boisseau's superior tone	6	0	0	Passed
8	The issue of gender bias	6	0	0	Passed
9	Women opera composers	6	0	0	Passed
10	Outside parties	6	0	0	Passed
11	Testing of limits by the crew from Musik Fabrik	2	2	1
12	Other users	1	2	3	Cannot pass with current votes
1	Users affiliated with Musik Fabrik	6	0	0	Passed
2	Jean-Thierry Boisseau placed on probation	5	1	0	Passed
3	Jean-Thierry Boisseau on civility parole	2	4	0
1	Enforcement by block	6	0	0	Passed