Jump to content

User:Jwang19/sandbox

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Human rights in Nigeria are protected under the most current constitution of 1999. Nigeria has made serious improvements in human rights under this constitution though the Human Rights Report of 2012 notes areas where significant improvement is needed. [1] This report discusses abuses by Boko Haram, killings by governmental forces, lack of social equality, and issues with freedom of speech.

History since independence[edit]

In the period between its independence in 1960 to 1998, Nigeria had, in terms of heads of State, two elected, one appointed, one military successor and 7 coups d'etat powers. In 1979, they moved to a presidential system in order to properly instate the right of choosing who rules them with a new constitution. This constitution guarantees fundamental human rights that are constantly in violation.

There was a crusade for human rights in 1985 when General Ibrahim Babangida took power.[2] Though short-lived, there were changes under the Babangida administration both for the positive as well as for the negative.

Although Nigeria has been active in signing and ratifying international human rights treaties, it has seen challenges when trying to implement these treaties domestically. Nigeria operates under a dualist system and cannot apply international treaties unless they are ratified by the legislative houses of Nigeria. Furthermore, the Nigerian constitution protects civil and political rights, but international treaties like the African Charter also expand protection to cultural, socioeconomic, and group rights. Because the Nigerian constitution is supreme law, the Supreme Court of Nigeria often resolves conflicts in favor of the Constitution, therefore restricting the expansion of potential human rights.[3]

Freedom of Expression[edit]

When General Babangida took power in 1985 and repealed Decree N0. 4 of 1984, a law that made it criminal behavior to publish any material that was considered embarrassing or against the interests of the government,[4] there was renewed hope for freedom of expression both by the people and the media. Within the Babangida regime, political tolerance occurred for some time. However, this brief foray into human rights broke down when the regime began jailing its critics and firing employees who did not promote their views and ideals. This regime closed down more newspapers and banned more popular organizations than any other in Nigeria's post-colonial history.[4]

The press in Nigeria was often subject to scare tactics and intimidation. Journalists were subjected to "chats" with the State Security Service that involved threatening and possible imprisonment.[4] There were continually newspaper shutdowns. In 1990, The Republic, Newbreed, Lagos Daily News, The Punch, and various other newspapers were shutdown at some point by the federal government.[5]

Critics maintain that though measures of freedom of the press have improved, there is still room for improvement. Nigeria was described as "partly free" in the Freedom of the Press 2011 report published by the Freedom House (see yearly rankings in Freedom House ratings in Nigeria section).[6]

Government violations[edit]

Police force[edit]

In Nigeria, the Nigeria Police Force has been typically viewed as inefficient and corrupt. The Joint Task Force (JTF) has provided inadequate and violent response to the Boko Haram attacks. The JTF has been involved in killing suspects without fair trial as well as killing random members of communities expected in involvement with the Boko Haram.[7] This "heavy-handed" approach violates human rights with its lack of access to a fair trial and use of discriminatory techniques to determine perpetrators of violence.[7]

Within the regular Nigerian Police Force, there are high amounts of corruption and violations that include extortion and embezzlement. The police force takes advantage of the people by putting up roadblocks that require a fee to pass and taking money for no legal reason. Within the police force, there is no equal protection under the law.[8] The wealthy are able to buy the police for security as well as expecting the police to turn a blind eye to illegal activities they participate in.

Corruption[edit]

Nigeria has the label of having one of the world's highest levels of corruption. This is especially seen within the public sector including stealing public funds and accepting bribes[9] It is estimated that between 1999 and 2007, Nigeria has lost around $4–8 billion yearly due to corruption [10]

Politicians often siphon public funds to further their political careers and they also pay gangs to aid them in rigging elections. The elections since the end of military rule occurring in 1999, 2003, and 2007 were bloody affairs and were openly rigged.[10] In 2007, ballot boxes were visibly stuffed by paid gangs and in some cases, electoral results were simply made up.[11] Human Rights Watch estimates that at least 300 were killed due to the 2007 elections and that is considered to be a conservative estimate as cited from a Human Rights Watch telephone interview with Derrick Marco, Nigeria country director in March, 2007. These measures of violence and intimidation discouraged the general public from voting. Those who did come out were subject to attacks by gangs [10]

The current Fourth Republic of Nigeria has strengthened its laws against corruption and established the Independent Corrupt Practices Commission (ICPC) and Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) in the early 2000s. However, due to the previous institutionalization of corruption, the battle against corruption is ongoing. These anti-corruption institutions have been attempting to combat the issue but they have not been very heavy handed in terms of punishment.[8] Former Edo State governor Lucky Igbinedion pleaded guilty to embezzling 2.9 billion Naira (about $24.2 million). However, he had a plea bargain with EFCC and was fined 3.5 million Naira ($29,167) and did not serve any jail time.[12] Often, many high-level politicians remain uninvestigated and only lower-level officials are arrested.[13]

Boko Haram[edit]

Boko Haram is an Islamist terrorist group that has seized territory in much of northeastern Nigeria and focuses its attacks on government officials, Christians, and fellow Muslims who speak out against their actions or are thought to aid the government, known as "traitor Muslims".[7] They cite corruption committed by the national government as well as increased Western influence as the primary reason for their often violent actions. This group engaging in Jihad was banded in 2000 by the spiritual leader Mohammed Yusuf.

In July 2009, there were five days of extreme violence from Boko Haram as well as with the governmental response. From July 26–31, the group killed 37 Christian men and burned 29 churches. After a brief hiatus in claimed incidents, the group resurfaced in the summer of 2011 with church attacks.

In October 2013, Amnesty International recommended that the Nigerian government investigate the deaths of more than 950 suspected Boko Haram members that died under military custody in the first six months of the year.[14]

In 2014, Boko Haram drew international attention from its April 14 kidnapping of approximately 300 female students from a secondary school in the northern town of Chibok, Nigeria. Boko Haram leader Abubakar Shekau claims the girls have converted to Islam and has threatened to sell them as wives or slaves to Boko Haram members at a price of $12.50 each.[15] Boko Haram has also attacked schools in Yobe State and forced hundreds of young men to join their forces, killing those who refused. Persistent violence in northeast Nigeria in 2014 has caused the deaths of over 2,500 civilians and the displacement of more than 700,000.[16]

From January 3 to 7, 2015, Boko Haram militants seized and razed the towns of Baga and Doron-Baga and killed over 2,000 people in the Baga Massacre.[17]

Social rights and equality[edit]

LGBT rights[edit]

In May 2013, Nigeria's House of Representatives voted to pass the Same-Sex Marriage Bill, which prohibits gay marriage and public displays of affection between same-sex couples and allots fourteen years in prison to those engaged in same-sex relationships. This bill also allows punishment for those knowingly associating with those identifying as members of the LGBT community or aiding these individuals in becoming married or pursuing that lifestyle. The punishment for abetting gay marriage is 5 years imprisonment. The Same-Sex Marriage Bill was ratified by President Goodluck Jonathan in January 2014 and has received much condemnation for its restriction of the freedoms of expression and assembly for the LGBT community in Nigeria.[18]

Women[edit]

Women in Nigeria face various versions of human rights violations despite the provisions granted unto them in the 1999 Constitution.[19] Regardless of the opportunity provided to take up unconstitutionality to higher courts in Nigeria, women do no often utilize this option and as such, there continues to be many violations occurring.

Nigerian women face particular problems and injustices once they become widows. The women are subject to cultural pressures that are inconsistent with human rights. In the widowhood practice, culture demands that when a man of significance within the community dies, his widow must act in a certain way as documented by Akpo Offiong Bassey in her studies of the Cross River State.[20] First off, the woman must go into seclusion. They are also forced to neglect their bodies; they are not allowed to shave, shower, or change their clothing. They have to rub cow dung and palm oil on their bodies and must also sleep on the floor. Widows are also expected to wear black, the color of mourning, for two years to properly show their loss and respect for their late husband. [21]

Apart from mourning, the widow has immediate concerns involving living situations and property to deal with. In most cases, the eldest son and not the widow inherits the entire property.[21] Women are culturally viewed as property and can be inherited like the rest of a husband’s estate. Whether or not the widow can continue to reside on the property is dependent on her relationship with her eldest son or, if there are no sons, the eldest male relative of her husband. There have also been instances where the woman must return to her premarital home after refunding the bride price.[22] The lack of sufficient property right makes these women dependent on men while single, married, or widowed.

Though the Nigerian Supreme Court has yet to formally deal with this issue, in the 2007 Nnanyelugo v. Nnanyelugo case, two brothers attempted to get the land of their deceased brother under the case that a widow has no business with the property. The ruling stated that they would no longer allow the males to take advantage of the vulnerable position of the widows and young children.[21] There are other cases in which courts have ruled to implement the equality guaranteed underneath the constitution.

Child labor and child marriage[edit]

According to the U.S. Department of Labor, 31% (which corresponds to around 14,000,000 children) of Nigerian children aged 5 to 14 years old are working children who engage in forced labor in various sectors.[23] According to the Department's List of Goods Produced by Child Labor or Forced Labor, instances of child labor have been observed in the agricultural sector where children participate in the production of cocoa, cassava and sand, and in the mining industry where they mine, quarry and crush gravel and granite.

In Nigeria, around 43% of women are married under 18 years old.[24][dubiousdiscuss] One popular source of legislation that was first brought forward in 1991 and became national law in 2003 is the Child Rights Act. Among other factors to protect children from abuses and discrimination, Section 21 and 23 of the act made it illegal to marry off a child below the age of 18. If a husband consummates a marriage with a child, it is considered rape.[25]

The Child Rights Act competes with sharia law in some states as well as with customs and cultural expectations in different regions. The Child Rights Act has not been enacted in 13 of Nigeria’s 36 states where other cultural factors are largely influencing the laws that are enacted.[26] Some also believe that it is the high levels of child marriage and the restrictions preventing women from leaving the home without the husband's permission under sharia law that lead to Nigeria having the highest global rate of vesicovaginal fistula occurring during young girls' delivery.[27]

Ethnic minorities[edit]

Religious minorities[edit]

According to its constitution, Nigeria is a secular country.[28] The Constitution forbids the establishment of a state religion and guarantees the right to freedom of religion. Nigeria is a religiously divided country[29], as approximately 50 percent of its population is Muslim, 40 percent is Christian, and 10 percent practices indigenous religions.[30] However, since January 2000, several states in Nigeria have institutionalized a version of Sharia law, and interreligious conflict has caused thousands of deaths since then. This enactment of Sharia law has caused controversy over its violation of fundamental rights, such as the right for minorities to practice their religion, the right to life, and freedom from cruel and unusual punishment. [31]

Historically, the Nigerian Constitution has allowed Sharia courts jurisdiction over certain cases, but their jurisdiction is limited to matters of Islamic personal or family law. Many state governors have extended Sharia law to criminal offenses, thereby violating the Constitution's prohibition of an official religion. These states have relied on a constitutional provision that allows the Sharia Court to exercise other jurisdiction given to it by the state in introducing Sharia penal codes. The imposition of Sharia law in certain states in Nigeria infringes on the rights of Muslims and non-Muslims alike. Muslims who would prefer to be judged under the Constitution are not able to do so, and non-Muslims are denied the right to practice their religions freely.[32]

The severe penalties given to lesser offenses under Sharia penal laws have raised concern about their violation of rights that are protected by international human rights treaties. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), of which Nigeria is a party, allows the death penalty if it is carried out in a way that causes the least suffering and only in the cases of serious crimes that intentionally cause lethal consequences. Under Sharia law, adultery is punished by death by stoning, which violates both conditions set forth by the ICCPR.[33]

  1. ^ Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor. Human Rights Practices for 2012. 2012.
  2. ^ McCarthy-Arnolds,Eileen. "Africa, Human Rights, and the Global System: The Political Economy of Human Rights in a Changing World". December 30, 1993
  3. ^ Egede, Edwin (2007). "Bringing Human Rights Home: An Examination of the Domestication of Human Rights Treaties in Nigeria". Journal of African Law. 51 (2): 249-284.
  4. ^ a b c MCathy-Arnolds, Penna, and Sobrepena (1994). "Africa, Human Rights, and the Global System".
  5. ^ Africa Watch. “Academic Freedom”.
  6. ^ "2011 Human Rights Reports: Nigeria". Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, U.S. Department of State. 24 May 2012.
  7. ^ a b c Human Rights Watch. "Spiraling Violence: Boko Haram Attacks and Security Force Abuses in Nigeria". 2012."
  8. ^ a b Human Rights Watch. "Everyone's in on the Game- Corruption and Human Rights Abuses by the Nigerian Police Force". August 2010
  9. ^ "Everyone's in on the Game- Corruption and Human Rights Abuses by the Nigerian Police Force".
  10. ^ a b c Human Rights Watch. “Criminal Politics”. October 2007
  11. ^ Human Rights Watch. “Nigeria: Polls Marred by Violence, Fraud”. April 17, 2007.
  12. ^ Ahemba, Tume. "Convicted Nigerian ex-governor to pay $25,750 fine". Reuters. December 19, 2008.
  13. ^ "World Report 2015: Nigeria". Human Rights Watch. Human Rights Watch.
  14. ^ "Nigeria: Deaths of hundreds of Boko Haram suspects in custody requires investigation". Amnesty International. Oct 15, 2013. Retrieved 2014-05-05.
  15. ^ "Boko Haram kidnapped the 230 school girls as wives for its insurgents". The Rainbow. 29 April 2014. Retrieved 6 May 2014.
  16. ^ "World Report 2015: Nigeria". Human Rights Watch. Human Rights Watch.
  17. ^ "Some of Boko Haram's worst attacks in Nigeria". USA Today. Gannett Company.
  18. ^ "World Report 2015: Nigeria". Human Rights Watch. Human Rights Watch.
  19. ^ Kuteyi, O.S. “The Rights of Nigerian Under the Laws: Real or Myth”. Gender Issues and National Development.
  20. ^ Ako-Nai, Ronke. “Gender and Power Relations in Nigeria”. Lexington Books. 2012
  21. ^ a b c “Gender and Power Relations in Nigeria”
  22. ^ Ako-Nai, Ronke. “Gender and Power Relations in Nigeria”. Lexington Books. 2012
  23. ^ Nigeria, 2013 Findings on the Worst Forms of Child Labor
  24. ^ Jain, Saranga and Kurz, Kathleen. "New Insights on Preventing Child Marriage- A Global Analysis of Factors and Programs". International Center for Research on Women. April 2007
  25. ^ Toyo, Nyoko. "Revisiting Equality as a Right: The Minimum Age of Marriage Clause in the Nigerian Child Rights Act, 2003". Third World Quarterly, Vol. 27, No. 7, The Politics of Rights: Dilemmas for Feminist Praxis (2006), pp. 1299-1312
  26. ^ Mark, Monica. "Nigeria's child brides". The Guardian. September 2, 2013
  27. ^ "World Report 2015: Nigeria". Human Rights Watch. Human Rights Watch.
  28. ^ Zarifis, Ismene (2002). "Rights of Religious Minorities in Nigeria". Human Rights Brief. 10 (1): 22-25.
  29. ^ Ilesanmi, Simeon (2001). "Constitutional Treatment of Religion and the Politics of Human Rights in Nigeria". African Affairs. 100: 529-54.
  30. ^ Zarifis, Ismene (2002). "Rights of Religious Minorities in Nigeria". Human Rights Brief. 10 (1): 22-25.
  31. ^ Zarifis, Ismene (2002). "Rights of Religious Minorities in Nigeria". Human Rights Brief. 10 (1): 22-25.
  32. ^ Zarifis, Ismene (2002). "Rights of Religious Minorities in Nigeria". Human Rights Brief. 10 (1): 22-25.
  33. ^ Zarifis, Ismene (2002). "Rights of Religious Minorities in Nigeria". Human Rights Brief. 10 (1): 22-25.