Jump to content

User:MackenzieOliver/Everything I Know About Love/Skelley01 Peer Review

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

General info

[edit]
Whose work are you reviewing?

MackenzieOliver

Link to draft you're reviewing
User:MackenzieOliver/Everything I Know About Love - Wikipedia
Link to the current version of the article (if it exists)
Everything I Know About Love - Wikipedia

Evaluate the drafted changes

[edit]

Hi! I really like how you updated the lead in your article, and added reviews from Storygraph so there is more information on the page then just the Goodreads reviews.

One idea is maybe adding a plot summary of the book, I have seen those on other Wikipedia articles about books and it could be a good way to increase the quality of your article.You could also consider adding more reviews from other places, such as newspapers or magazines in order to add more to the article in the reception section. Also in order to further the quality class of the article you could maybe add another heading with information.

Overall, your sources seem good but maybe see if you can find the information from cup of tea with that book please from another source since Wikipedia encourages against using blogs as a source. Otherwise, your sources seem to cover a range of options and area all up to date. I think it's cool that you included a non-English source as well for the translations.

Finally, as you are putting the finishing touches on your article, I would make sure you are matching the formatting from the original article in your sandbox so it's easier to publish.