User:SebastianHelm/ArbCom/2007

table • talks

Undecided

Adam Cuerden (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no reply, but has already a link which I put there
Raul654 (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): arbitrator, blocked 8 months ago; no reply to my question, has already link I put there
Will Beback (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): (2006: s - Sounds reasonable, link shows good clerical work. Not sure about people skills) no reply, but has already a link which I put there last year
Jeepday (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): still talking on eir page

Supported

Newyorkbrad (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Good ArbCom clerk
FT2 (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Amazing list of portfolion links!
Ryan Postlethwaite (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Nice, simple statement with several links
Wizardman (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Has not been active since Nov 26. Has already 2 links which I put there.
Shell Kinney (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): (2006: s - Added links, one of them is OK) Is thinking of ArbCom table. Liked some links. Weak support because of "cretin" answer to question about name change. Ey had over a year to calm down eir anger!
Thebainer (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Added links - really nice portfolio!
FayssalF (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote)

Opposed

Endlessdan (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): slack statement; preferred to reply to video game questions
Giano II (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): blocked 5 months ago by other candidates (without any link); refused to provide portfolio
John Reaves (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): blocked 11 months ago; did not reply to my question, did not add links
Phil Sandifer (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): (2006: u - no reaction needed) blocked 19 months ago; left Wikipedia
White Cat (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Some conversation on eir talk page about bragging; waiting for eir reply; blocked 7 months ago; did not reply to my second question
Alexia Death (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): apparently inactive after eir candidacy
Danny (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply, although ey refuses much of a statement on the groungs of being for concise information
David Fuchs (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply, apparently doesn't keep conversations together
Deskana (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply, apparently doesn't keep conversations together
Hemlock Martinis (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply
Misza13 (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply
Pilotguy (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply (has box "Messages left here may not be replied to promptly." - but that's just what I would expect!)
Physchim62 (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply
Swatjester (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Too confrontational and too much into requiring "deference" from others. However, his admirable enthusiasm for Wikipedia makes me hope he'll find a more suitable position here. Unfortunately, I can not quote the deference part directly since it was in a private mail, but the combination "Swatjester" and "deference" has a few hits on Google.
JoshuaZ (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no reply, but has already 2 links which I put there
Sam Blacketer (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Added many links - needle in haystack. Seems fishy to me
Moreschi (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no reply, but has already 2 links which I put there. I asked new question Dec 4 (still watching page)
MastCell (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply
Rebecca (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no portfolio, no reply, insists on semi-protecting her talk page

Withdrawn before I voted

Mercury (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): Replied with Wikipedia talk:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2007/Summary table‎#Consist (still watching page)
Stifle (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): no reply, but has already a link which I put there
Monsieurdl (talk • contribs • statement • questions • vote): added links (with bef-aft)