Jump to content

User:Xdamr/Great Power Rev X

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

{{Cleanup|date=August 2006}}

The Great Powers are usually taken to be those nations or states that, through their great economic, political and military strength, are able to exert power over world diplomacy. Their opinions are often strongly taken into account by other nations before taking diplomatic or military action. Characteristically, they have the ability to intervene militarily almost anywhere, and they also have soft, cultural power, often in the form of economic investment in less developed portions of the world.

Commentators give varying opinions on exactly which nations constitute a great power. Some include China, India, and possibly the European Union [1] however there is also an alternative view that the rising interdependency between the world's nations has made the concept of a superpower obsolete and that the world is now multipolar. There is considerable debate over the EU's power and influence. If the member states were combined it would presumably be a superpower. However, most commentators agree that the EU, lacking the political unification of a sovereign state, cannot therefore be a superpower or power of any kind. The United Nations Security Council permanent member nations (excluding the United States ), namely the United Kingdom, France, China, and Russia, are all normally considered great powers.

The United States of America is considered to be a superpower.

Characteristics[edit]

Though characteristics of great powers can vary, the following are usually considered:[2]

  • The capacity to contribute to the international order
  • Internal cohesion to allow for effective state action
  • Economic power, such as high levels of economic growth or a large market
  • Military power, with the ability to compete with other dominant powers in a conventional war

History[edit]

Different sets of Great Powers have existed in history, but after 1815, the Concert of Europe formalized France, the United Kingdom, Russia, Austria, and Prussia as the five powers. Of these, the first three had colonial empires outside Europe; Prussia had had a colonial possession briefly. Austria was called an empire in the earlier sense of the word, that of a monarch ruling over several kingdoms. Prussia was a newcomer, rising through Frederick the Great's militaristic grand strategy. Upon the unification of Italy and Germany, they were accepted as Great Powers - Germany as a continuation of Prussia. After the First World War, at the Paris Peace Conference, 1919 four Great Powers were readily recognised: the British Empire (including its Dominions), the United States, France and Italy. The status of Japan requires qualification. They were not part of the Big Four, but were accorded two votes like the Big Four. Their position was highlighted by their race equality proposal, which touched on a number of issues including their status as a Great Power. Although this proposal was defeated as first the British and then the Americans caved into the Australian defence of the White Australia Policy, their successful retention of Shandong and the German islands in the Pacific north of the equator indicated that they had attained the position of a non-white Great Power. Again, after the Second World War in 1945, the United States, the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom, France and the People's Republic of China were formalised as the five powers with permanent seats and veto power in the UN Security Council. Clearly, shifts in great power status tend to follow wars.

Great powers are also often associated with the projection of military power through a particular technology, such as Dreadnoughts or nuclear weapons. A mere large, defensive infantry army, such as the Chinese would have been able to raise during the age of European dominance is not able to project power overseas. Even the U.S. Army and its blockading navy during the Civil War was insufficient at a time when the United States did not have armored ocean-going battleships. Wealth could be a military factor. Britain could not raise a large army quickly, but was able to fund allies to raise them for it during the Napoleonic Wars.

The Congress of Berlin, a peace treaty to a comparatively minor war, included Ottoman Empire and Italy at the status of those mentioned in the Concert of Europe. International meetings, which developed during the second half of the nineteenth century, also serve to indicate Great Power status in the absence of peace treaties after wars, such as the different Berlin Conference.

By the end of the Cold War and the era of globalization other nations began to attain international recognition as great powers, India is an example of this after its economic boom in the 90s.

Since the end of the World Wars, the term Great Power has been split up into a number of definite categories. The term Superpower was used to define a nation with overwhelming power over the rest of the world, this term was initially used to describe the United States and Soviet Union. The term Major power (or sometimes Global Power) has also been used to describe nations with great power, yet not as overwhelming as that of a superpower. This system forms a type of hierarchy for powerful nations.

Great powers through modern history[edit]

The Gross Domestic Product (GDP), as shown on this map, is perhaps the most important characteristic of a great power.

Since around the year 1750 the world has become more globalized and most Great powers have had a certain amount of influence over the rest of the world. Prior to the 21st century this power was mostly exerted by colonial powers, or powers that had explored and established states in other continents. However, since the World Wars the geopolitical landscape has greatly changed. The emergence of new technologies also mean that soft power can be exerted over other regions easily.

After World War II, a number of changes in power were seen. The powers of Germany, Italy and Japan was greatly reduced and most of Europe was affected adversely by the war. In the aftermath of the war, Great powers has often been used to refer to nations who have strong power projection yet are not as strong as a superpower (a term used to describe the United States).

It is now generally accepted that the term Great power also applies to the United Kingdom, Germany, France, China, Japan, and Russia. The European powers of the United Kingdom, France, Germany and Italy lost much of their political influence after the World Wars. However, all four of these nations managed to rebuild their economy and increase their power projection. There is debate on whether Italy should be included as a Great power as it meets some of the common characteristics of the other powers. However, it is often categorized as a middle power instead of a Great power. [3]

Japan also comes into the same category as Italy and Germany, after being devastated because of the Second World War, Japan steadily rebuilt its economy and managed to reach the status of a Great power. Japan also has built a strong high-tech manufacturing industry. The other Asian powers, China and India, are emerging superpowers and have developed a quickly growing economy.

Russia is considered by some as a declining power and by others as a rising one. It was the most prominent of the 15 Soviet Republics, and is the legal successor state to the Soviet Union, inheriting many of its superpower capabilities. Although Russia initially reliquished some of its power as the nation fell into disarray following the USSR's dissolution, it has since undergone significant recovery and has considerable influence over the world today through its military, geographical position, demographics, resources and economy.


Great Powers throughout Modern History
Country Dates Rise Downfall Notes
Austria/ Austria-Hungary 1687-1918 Battle of Mohács (1687) World War One Under the Habsburg Monarchy.
China[4][5] 1368-1842, 1978-present The founding of the Ming Dynasty. Economic explosion and Military strength. The First Opium War (1842) Under the Ming and Qing Dynasties. Today under People's Republic of China
England/ Great Britain/ United Kingdom[6] 1154-1399, 1688-present Plantagenets dynasty 1154-1399, The Glorious Revolution (1688), economic power, G8 nation Extinction of Plantagenets in direct line and Wars of the Roses Under Plantagenets monarchy, William III of Orange, Hanover, Saxe-Coburg-Gotha, Windsor, and the British Parliament. Empire created by, The Royal Navy, British Army.
France[6] 1214-1337, 1453-1559, 1648-present The Battle of Bouvines (1214), The Battle of Castillon (1453), end of Thirty Years' War (1648), economic power, G8 nation Start of Hundred Years' War (1337), end of Italian Wars (1559) Under the Capetian Dynasty, Valois Dynasty, the House of Bourbon, Napoleon, Napoleon III, and multiple French republics.
Germany[7][8][9][6] 1871-1918, 1933-1945, 1970s-present Franco-Prussian War (1871), Rule of Nazism (1933-1945), Economic miracle (1970s) & economic power, G8 nation (starting in Western Germany, then continuing after the reunification) World War I, World War II; NA since 1991 Under Hohenzollern Dynasty, as Republic of Weimar, Hitler, and now a republic.
Republic of India [6] 1990-Present Economic explosion - Considered an emerging superpower
Italy 1095-1494, 1861-1945 Crusades, Italian Unification Italian Wars, World War II Between the Crusades (1095-1291) and the Italian Wars (1494-1559) the Italian city-states were great powers of the Middle Ages. After the Italian Unification under Savoy Monarchy and later Mussolini.
Japan[10][11][6] 1905-1945, 1970s-present Russo-Japanese War, economic power, G8 nation Military destruction by the USA during World War II Slumped post-World War II, but recovered by 1970s.
The Mughal Empire 1526-1739 Invasion of India Invasion of the British and the East India Company Pakistan, India, and Afghanistan
The Netherlands 1579-1795 Union of Utrecht Batavian revolution Under States-General of the Netherlands
The Ottoman Empire 1453-1918 Conquest of Constantinople World War I Under Ottoman Dynasty
Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth 1466-1700 Peace of Torun Beginning of Northern War Personal union 1385-1569. Single state after 1569 (Union of Lublin) Under Jagiellonian Dynasty and elected kings.
Portugal 1415-1581, 1640-1822 Portuguese Colonization, Restoration of Independence Spanish annexation, Napoleonic Wars and Brazilian independence
Prussia 1763-1871 Seven Years' War German Unification Under Hohenzollern Dynasty; can be said to be directly succeeded by German power
Russia[6] 1721-1917 (Russian Empire), 1991-present (Russian Federation)G8 The Great Northern War - Under Romanov Dynasty (Russian Empire), now a federation and the formal successor state to the USSR; current power from military strength, UN veto, extensive resources, possession of a vast nuclear stockpile, advanced military and space scientific/technological capabilities
The Soviet Union 1945-1991 World War II Dissolved in 1991 by the leadership of Russia, the Ukraine, and Belarus Under Communism, consisted of 15 Soviet Republics; military strength, diplomatic influence, large industrial output, extensive resources, possession of a vast nuclear stockpile, advanced military and space scientific/technological capabilities
Spain 1469-1898 Unification of Spain Spanish-American War Under Trastámara, Hapsburg and Bourbon Dynasties
Sweden 1611-1721 The Ingrian War The Great Northern War Partly made possible by the production of iron and steel.
United States[6] 1898-Present Spanish-American War - Economic power, G8 nation, scientific leadership, and military strength

Great powers in the pre-modern age (pre-1500 CE)[edit]

Africa[edit]

Great Powers throughout pre-Modern History
Country Dates Rise Downfall Notes
Ancient Egypt 3000 BCE-1070 BCE End of the Protodynastyic Period The death of Ramesses XI, resulting in centuries of foreign rule and domination
Kingdom of Aksum 100 BC-630 AD End of the Proto-Aksumite period Rise of Islam, moving of the capital from Axum, loss of trade. Called one of the 4 greatest empires in the world by Mani (mid 3rd century), conquered Meroe.

East Asia[edit]

Great Powers throughout pre=Modern History
Country Dates Rise Downfall Notes
Qin Dynasty 221-207 BCE The founding of the Qin Dynasty The death of Qin Shi Huang, China's first Emperor First unification of China
Han Dynasty 202 BCE-220 CE The coronation of Emperor Gaozu The abdication of Emperor Xian Ruled China; dynastic interruption from CE 9-24 by Wang Mang
Sui Dynasty 581-618 Emperor Wen seizes control of northern and southern China The overthrow of Emperor Gong Ruled China
Tang Dynasty 618-907 The overthrow of Emperor Gong The overthrow of Emperor Ai Ruled China; interrupted by Empress Wu from 690-705
Song Dynasty 960-1276 Emperor Taizu reunifies northern and southern China Kublai Khan seizes the Song capital, Hangzhou Ruled China; territory diminished to Southern China
Jin Dynasty 1127-1234 The sack of Kaifeng, the Song Dynasty's first capital Conquest by Ogedei Khan Ruled Northern China and Manchuria
Mongolian Empire 1214-1340 est. Genghis Khan defeats and receives tribute from the Jin Dynasty The Black Death, decline of the Silk Road and communication networks Directly ruled territory from Korea and Vietnam to the Vistula River and Mesopotamia; the empire's component states of Yuan China, the Ilkhanate, the Golden Horde, and the Chagatai Khanate continued as completely independent states.
Yuan Dynasty 1271-1369 Kublai Khan receives the title of the Emperor of China Ming conquest of Shangdu Self-governing part of the Mongol Empire; the Yuan continued to rule Mongolia after its grip on China slipped.
Ming Dynasty 1369-1644 Expulsion of the Yuan from China Qing conquest of Beijing Ruled China; the Ming did not completely collapse until 1662

Europe and Mediterranean sea[edit]

Great Powers throughout Modern History
Country Dates Rise Downfall Notes
The Urartian Empire (Asia) 1000 BCE (or earlier)-585 BCE When King Ispuini (ca. 820-800 BCE) annexed the neighbouring state of Musasir and made his son Sarduri II viceroy. His successor Menua (ca. 800-785 BCE) also enlarged the kingdom greatly and left inscriptions over a wide area. Argishtish I (ca. 785-760 BCE) added more territories along the Araxes river and Lake Erivan. Conquered by the Medes in 612 BCE. At its height, ruled all of present-day eastern Turkey, all of present-day Armenia, and parts of Syria, Iran, and Georgia.
The Carthaginian Empire 575 BCE-202 BCE The fall of Tyre to the Assyrians, which let Carthage assume leadership of the Phoenician colonies The Battle of Zama Ruled much of the coasts of modern Tunisia, Libya, Algeria, Morocco, and Spain; also ruled Corsica, Sardinia, and Western Sicily
Alexander's Empire 336 BCE-323 BCE Submission of most of the Greek City-States to Alexander Death of Alexander the Great Ruled an area from Greece and Cyrenaica to the Indus River; though the empire was theoretically still united after Alexander's death, generals seized control of its pieces, which later became Ptolemaic Egypt, Macedon, and the Seleucid Empire.
Macedon 272 BCE-197 BCE The death of Pyrrhus at Argos The Battle of Cynoscephalae Under the Antigonid Dynasty; ruled directly and indirectly much of Greece, the Balkans, and Asia Minor
Ptolemaic Egypt 301 BCE-170 BCE The Battle of Ipsus The invasion of Antiochus IV Epiphanes Ruled Egypt, Cyrenaica, Palestine, Cyprus, and various territories in Greece and Asia Minor
The Roman Republic 275 BCE-27 BCE The Battle of Beneventum The First Settlement between Octavian and the Roman Senate Continued as the Roman Empire
The Roman Empire 27 BCE-475 CE The First Settlement between Octavian and the Roman Senate The overthrow of Emperor Julius Nepos At its height, ruled all of Europe west of the Rhine and south of the Danube, lower Great Britain,Dacia, North Africa, Asia Minor, the Levant, part of Arabia, Mesopotamia, and Armenia.
The Hun Empire 432 CE-454 Unification of the Huns under Ruga The Battle of Nedao -
The Eastern Roman Empire/The Byzantine Empire 395 CE-1204 CE Permanent division of the Roman Empire The sack of Constantinople during the Fourth Crusade A diminished empire finally collapsed in 1453 with the fall of Constantinople.

South Asia[edit]

Great Powers throughout Pre-Modern History
Country Dates Rise Downfall Notes
The Kingdom of Kosala c. 600 BCE - c. 500 BCE Reign of the Raja Manu line Absorption by the Magadha Empire Cultural Hub of Ancient India, holy place for Hindus, Buddhists and Jains. Fought war with Ancient Sri Lanka.
The Magadhan Empire 540 BCE - 460 BCE Expansion through much of the northern half of the subcontinent through Emperors Asoka, Bimbisara, Ajathashatru and Bindusara. Conversion to buddhism and later successors who were too weak to control the realm. Cultural and economic power. Expanded throughout almost the whole of the Gangetic plains.
The Mauryan Empire 321 BCE-180 BCE Expansion through Chandragupta Maurya's conquests. Overthrown by the Sunga dynasty. Ruled most of South Asia, became a Buddhist pacifist empire c. 250 BC
The Gupta Empire 240-550 CE Expansion through Chandragupta and Samudragupta's campaigns. Internal dissension (Pushyamitra) and invasion (Huns) drained the imperial treasury and brought an end to empire Ruled most of north India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Burma.
The Chola Dynasty 850-c. 1300 CE Cultural strength and expansion into South East Asia. Rise of neighbouring kingdoms. Expanded throughout parts of modern day Indonesia and Malaysia.
The Delhi Sultanate 1145-1526 Under various dynasties First Battle of Panipat The first Muslim rulers in India
The Mughal Empire 1526-1739 First Battle of Panipat Rise of Marathas, formally ended after the Revolt of 1857 against the British The empire flourished under the 6 great mughals after which it regressed eventually being superceded by the British East India Company.
The Maratha Confederacy 1674-1818 Through the campaigns of Baji Rao II Third battle of Panipat Under Shivaji the Marathas harassed the Mughals and held their own in the Deccan region of India
Sikh Punjab 1764-1849 Sikh rebellion against Mughal Emperors British Rule Mughals attempted to retake Punjab 9 times. Last kingdom to fall to the British Rule

Southeast Asia[edit]

Great Powers throughout Pre-Modern History
Country Dates Rise Downfall Notes
Srivijaya 200 CE - 1300 Trade between the east and the west, spread of Buddhism and absorption of neighboring kingdoms. Rise of Majapahit, Chola's raid, spread of Islam and changing trade routes. Sovereignty covered the western part of the Malay Archipelago.
Majapahit 1300 - 1400 The fall of Srivijaya, and the Javenese conquest to the surrounding islands in the western and central part of Malay Archipelago. Rise of Islam, states in northern Sumatra rebelled against Majapahit rule and set up their own Islamic kingdoms, internal revolts. Ruled the western and central part of Malay Archipelago, controlled the largest area for the first time in history until the Indonesian independence, successfully drove the Mongol invaders out from Java.
Ayutthaya 1400-1800 Prosperity and growth of the Thai people under the the rule of the five dynasties of Ayutthaya. Conquered many neighbouring countries and was a port between the East and the west. Had dipolmatic relations with France and other European countries. Ended by a great host of armies from Burma, who besieged and destroyed the capital city of Ayutthaya.

References[edit]

  1. ^ An explanation of the concept of Great powers
  2. ^ Hegemony, liberalism and global order: what space for would-be great powers? Hurrell, Andrew; 2006; International Affairs 82 (1); pp1-19; Accessed May 22 2006 (Subscription or one off payment of 19p required)
  3. ^ Middle Power Approaches to Maritime Security Note the categorization of Italy within this group
  4. ^ "Yale, China as a great power" (PDF). Retrieved 2006-08-21.
  5. ^ "Council on foreign affairs, China as a great power". Retrieved 2006-08-21.
  6. ^ a b c d e f g "List of Great Powers and Hyerpowers". Retrieved 2006-08-25.
  7. ^ "World Security Network, Germany a great power in denial" (PDF). Retrieved 2006-08-21.
  8. ^ "Nato, Federal Republic of Germany, a European great power". Retrieved 2006-08-21.
  9. ^ "World Security Network, Germany fails to recognize its position as a Great Power". Retrieved 2006-08-21.
  10. ^ "Japan as a great power". Retrieved 2006-08-21.
  11. ^ "The New Republic, Japan's great power role relating to the Korea conflict zone". Retrieved 2006-08-21.

See also[edit]