Jump to content

User talk:JC7V7DC5768/CSD log

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Here is why I made some noms that I did

Most blue links exist because after the articles/drafts were deleted they were recreated without the copyright violations or excessive spam that got the article/draft deleted in the first place
  • Christopher Scott as customized CSD tagging (already in draft space)

Because I saw that Christopher Scott currently existed as a draft so I tagged the Christopher Scott article for deletion since it existed at the time in draft form. Didn't realize that the article was previously AFD'd or deleted (but even if I did know that, there was no way to know if the article was different enough now to not CSD it under that criteria under 'recreated article from a previous deletion discussion' criteria

  • CSD Tony Severino

written like a booster ad and unsourced, changed to prod after discussion with Meters and then SoFixIt'd myself after consulting with Meters further.

  • CSD to non deletion tag on Relentless Church

The article was soon AFD'd so I was right to think it should be deleted but after I CSD tagged I got a nagging to further research deletion policy essays dso after doing more searches I realized it shouldn't be CSD'd so I removed the CSD tag and SoFixIt'd to make it more suitable and then let it be deleted at AFD if need be.

  • Dedf1st

tagged it A7 because there wasn't enough context to show that the character is significant enough to pass A7 (couldn't find category for fictional character), reCSDtagged it after CSD tag removed by author, this time with a A1 no context CSD tag which is the rationale used in its AFC decline earlier (more accurate to say NO CONTEXT to show that the character is significant enough to pass A7 than to say no context AND THUS THE CHARACTER IS NOT SIGNIFICANT ENOUGH TO PASS A7'

  • Ajmal Karunagappally (2nd deletion): I removed my CSD tag in favor of Alternative to Deletion due partly to the fact that the author added more to article. I was going to go 'Article rescue squandron' on the article and get it to meet GNG as best as possible (even though I probably couldn't i was up to the challenge to at least try) but before I even had a chance it was CSD tagged by another user and deleted.