User talk:Matxo granota

Álvaro Traver - Reply[edit]

Resolved

Hi Matxo,

First and foremost: thanks for your polite message. Even though you are 100% right that Traver is a member of the B-team, his loan should be listed in the first team when there's no official source to back up who should be listed there (a clear example is Real Sociedad's website, which lists who is on loan from the first team and who is "on loan from the reserve team"). Of course we need to reiterate that reserve teams do not loan players, but I think it's safe to add according to the official web.

On second thought, we need to consider that Traver already played with the main squad before, and was a part of the first team's pre-season last summer. It is, indeed, preferrable to list here in the first team article instead of adding a section in the reserve team article just to include his loan. As for De Tomás, the same logic can be applied. In Aspas' case, he was still a youth player when returning, obviously didn't have an article back at this time and his loan is (and was) quite unnoticed. Cheers, MYS 77 ^✉ 16:13, 21 March 2017 (UTC)[reply]

   Hi MYS77, Thank you for your explanation. I agree with your ideas, and accept your revisions. Cheers Matxo granota (talk) 05:11, 22 March 2017 (UTC)[reply]