User talk:UnTrueOrUnSimplified
The two columns 'Detect rename' 'Detect move' in the Sync Comparison page are still very confusing. They discriminate (negatively) some products because every provider/developer interpret it in his/her own favor. Also many users have various interpretation of the terms. The definition which is added is very complex and practically mostly not the case for many products despite what the table suggests. As a developer I can confirm that using a hash is not the only way for detecting rename or move. As the definition suggest, using a hash or central database is a good thing which is in many cases not. Every solution has its pros and cons. Even though 'hashing' may be considered as one solution to detect renames/moves, it has its own draw backs likes sync speed reduction.
Using the colors 'green' and 'red' suggests that a product may be better of worse than the other, which is not. Because many attributes in this table are not completely objective (and not always neutrally verified) the table sets up an incorrect and not neutral comparison. I suggest to make the table subjective informative, by removing the colors. The table should only provide information and no judgment at all. Everybody may provide information and information only.
Start a discussion with UnTrueOrUnSimplified
Talk pages are where people discuss how to make content on Wikipedia the best that it can be. Start a new discussion to connect and collaborate with UnTrueOrUnSimplified. What you say here will be public for others to see.
