Valparaiso University deaccessioning controversy
In early 2023, Valparaiso University in Valparaiso, Indiana, U.S., under the leadership of president José Padilla, announced that it had decided to sell three paintings in its collection to fund dormitory renovations. The proposed sale of three paintings—Mountain Landscape (c. 1849) by Frederic Edwin Church, The Silver Veil and the Golden Gate (1914) by Childe Hassam, and Rust Red Hills (1930) by Georgia O'Keeffe—sparked fierce opposition, including protests from faculty and students, and from Richard H. W. Brauer, founder and director of the university's Brauer Museum of Art where the paintings were exhibited.
Background
[edit]In early 2023, university president Padilla argued that the university's declining enrollment and financial situation necessitated the sale of three paintings from the permanent collection of the Brauer Museum of Art. Padilla also threatened to cut additional programs and positions. The university board and administration declared that the paintings represent assets that "are not core or critical to the educational mission or strategic plan" to increase enrollment and grow the university.[1] To cut costs, the university shut down its law school in 2020 and no longer offers degrees in secondary education and French. By selling the paintings, Valparaiso will raise more than the projected $8–10 million needed to build new student housing,[2] with the O'Keeffe painting alone worth $10–15 million.[3]
Museum association opposition
[edit]The proposed sale was opposed by the Association of Art Museum Directors (AAMD), the American Alliance of Museums (AAM), the Association of Academic Museums and Galleries (AAMG), and the Association of Art Museum Curators (AAMC). The ethical guidelines and best practices of deaccessioning require that proceeds from any art sales must be used solely for art, not for infrastructure projects like the kind Valparaiso intended to complete. According to the AAMD, when a museum generally sells work to raise money, the proceeds are usually conserved for other artworks, either for the purpose of obtaining new works or to preserve the old ones.[4] The Brauer Museum was not a member of AAMD or the AAMC, but the director of the museum was a member of the AAMG and the museum itself was an unaccredited member of AAM.[5]
Lawsuit
[edit]Brauer and Philipp Brockington filed suit against the university, arguing that the proposed sale violated the original Sloan trust agreement, which requires revenue from paintings that are sold to be put back into the Sloan purchase fund. The university countered that Brauer's original purchase of an impressionist painting by Hassam and a modernist work by O'Keeffe, violated the Sloan agreement which specified that the funds were only to be used to buy "conservative", or representational, non-abstract works of art.[6] The university also argued that they needed to sell the painting to address their deficit and student decline, and that a dormitory renovation would increase enrollment. The university noted that the Brauer Museum is not professionally accredited, and therefore does not have to follow the ethical standards and guidelines of deaccessioning common to accredited museums.[7] Brauer and Brockington were denied standing by the court. Todd Rokita, the Indiana attorney general, reviewed the case and supported the position taken by Valparaiso.[8]
Firing of staff and museum closure
[edit]In June 2024, the university eliminated the position of museum director and 13 other staff members and closed the Brauer Museum indefinitely, citing a restructuring effort.[3]
References
[edit]- ^ Jones, Shelly (February 15, 2023). "Valparaiso University students protest plan to sell three paintings, including a Georgia O'Keeffe". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
- ^ Richardson, Kalia (March 10, 2023). "Its Georgia O'Keeffe Is Worth Millions. And Its Dorms Need Updating". The New York Times. Retrieved October 23, 2024.
- ^ a b Lavalley, Amy (June 21, 2024). "Valparaiso University cuts 14 staff, including museum director, in restructuring effort". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
- ^ Boucher, Brian Boucher (September 4, 2024). "A Court Approves Valparaiso's Plan to Sell Artworks". Artnet News. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
- ^ "Joint Statement on Brauer Museum of Art, Valparaiso University". Association of Art Museum Directors. Retrieved November 25, 2024.
- ^ Cui, Liya (September 4, 2024). "Indiana Court Allows Valparaiso University to Sell O'Keeffe Painting". Reuters. Retrieved October 30, 2024.
- ^ Boucher, Brian (July 1, 2024). "'It Defames Me': Brauer Museum Founding Director Blasts Valparaiso University's Ongoing Deaccessioning Plan". Artnet. Retrieved October 23, 2024.
- ^ LaValley, Amy (June 20, 2023). "Indiana AG files for dismissal of lawsuit against Valpo U over artwork sale". Post-Tribune. Retrieved October 29, 2024.
Further reading
[edit]- Aguiar, Annie (July 19, 2024). "To Sell Prized Paintings, a University Proclaims They're Not 'Conservative'". The New York Times. Retrieved October 30, 2024.
- Borem, Jarod (October 28, 2024). "Valpo alum's solution will keep paintings' legacy alive". The Torch. Retrieved October 30, 2024.
- Masciotra, David (March 15, 2023). "A Georgia O'Keeffe Painting and the Battle for the Soul of a Liberal Arts College". The New Republic. Retrieved October 31, 2024.
- Shuey, Mickey (September 11, 2024). "Valparaiso University selling Georgia O’Keeffe painting to spruce up dorms". Indianapolis Business Journal. Bloomberg News. Retrieved October 29, 2024.