Wikipedia:Move review/Log/2013 September
2013 September[edit]
|
---|
The following is an archived debate of the move review of the page above. Please do not modify it. |
The page was renamed from Carpi F.C. 1909 to Carpi FC 1909 with the motivation "Official team logo has no periods." The official homepage of the teams writes the name with dots everywere[1] and all the other articles about Italian football clubs have dots.CapPixel (talk) 14:22, 21 September 2013 (UTC)
|
The above is an archive of the move review of the page listed in the heading. Please do not modify it. |
|
---|
The following is an archived debate of the move review of the page above. Please do not modify it. |
(1) Non-admin close of difficult area related to current confusion as to whether WP:PDAB applies to mentions in other articles - particularly thorny given series of recent disagreement on whether a song covered in a collection of songs should be disambiguated against by bandname Foo in the (Foo song) or whether songs should only be disambiguated against if song is forked out of a collection of songs into a standalone song article. (2) Closes with confusion about what to do with redirect "Consensus did not seem clear at all about leaving the redirect" inviting further discussion in close, meaning that discussion isn't over and a relist would have been better. (3) pinging a user in the close "(In ictu oculi did not mention it)" rather than pinging before a close. (4) no consensus visible with RM proposer accepting alternative RM proposal so inappropriate for a non-admin close. In ictu oculi (talk) 00:45, 16 September 2013 (UTC)
|
The above is an archive of the move review of the page listed in the heading. Please do not modify it. |
|
---|
The following is an archived debate of the move review of the page above. Please do not modify it. |
There was a proposed move to move Southeast, Northeast, Northwest and Southwest to Southeast (disambiguation), Northeast (disambiguation), Northwest (disambiguation) and Southwest (disambiguation). There was no mention by the proposer of what the base names (e.g., Northeast) would redirect to in the event of the move passing (he mentioned something about "the articles on the directions should all be moved to the base name", despite the fact that there are no such articles); therefore, I at least was unable to make a !vote. It was a mess, rather atypical of User:Bkonrad, whom I respect immensely, and unfortunately User:BD2412, the closing admin, read that move request and determined that when a user types in Northwest (for instance), they should be taken to boxing the compass, which is problematic for three reasons. First, that's a poor choice of landing--boxing the compass doesn't say anything about the direction Northwest in particular (which makes sense, because we're not a dictionary and I doubt anyone could write and source an article about a direction--in any case, that article doesn't exist at boxing the compass). Second, there is no consensus anywhere at that move request for primary topic being boxing the compass, because primary topic wasn't even discussed, because nobody proposed a primary topic and the closer just picked a location for those links to redirect to. Third, our primary topic criteria would reject this decision if only the question had ever been raised. Just check the pageviews. boxing the compass has 26k views over past 90 days whereas Southwest Airlines, which is just one example for just one direction, has 158k!. In summary, this move close did not correctly identify a consensus to move the pages to disambiguation pages and to redirect the base names to boxing the compass. I respect and appreciate the nominator and the closing administrator; I do however believe this was an error. (The closing admin has been notified.) Red Slash 00:24, 9 September 2013 (UTC)
|
The above is an archive of the move review of the page listed in the heading. Please do not modify it. |