Wikipedia:Peer review/Eminem discography/archive1

Eminem discography

• A script has been used to generate a semi-automated review of the article for issues relating to grammar and house style; it can be found on the automated peer review page for December 2008.

This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I intend to bring the article to Featured List status after the unsuccessful FLC of a few months ago. I believe I have addressed all the issue that were brought up and fixed other problems, especially those regarding the reliability of the former sources and unnecessary large amount of charts. I would like comments on anything that can be improved, but especially comments regarding the lead and the "note system" at the bottom of the page are most welcome.

Thanks, — Do U(knome)? ^yes..._{or no} 09:56, 10 December 2008 (UTC)

Comments from Cannibaloki (talk · contribs)

This is a partial assessment of layout, not yet seen the text.

• All these types, on the entire table, per visual appeal should be in a consistent 'width' and same style.

• Done

• Overall, you should put the entire list as the others featured lists, look at my page, to see a modern days FL. Preference to see The Mars Volta and Iron Maiden discogs.

• Now it looks more similar

• Put all fonts in normal size (except bottom keys).

• Done, with the exception for guest performers in the singles chart.

• When you has more than 10 chart peaks, keep the 10 bests, as MOS:DISCOG suggests.

• Done (all but the singles table have 10 charts)

• For the external links like: australian-charts.com should be replaced by Discography Eminem; In the same system that can be found in the discography of Trivium; Will give you less work, and reduce the list weight.

• Good Idea. Done

• If you prefer, I can make the suggested changes without any problems.
  • Did I miss anything?
    • Nothing, all done. Cannibaloki 13:37, 20 December 2008 (UTC)

Regards, Cannibaloki 03:16, 20 December 2008 (UTC)

• Thanks for your comments! Is there anything I missed or that you would like to see further improved? — Do U(knome)? ^yes..._{or no} 12:31, 20 December 2008 (UTC)

All codes that I post here, should replace the ones used in the discography.

• ! rowspan="2" width="125"| [[Music recording sales certification|Certifications]]<br /><small>([[List of music recording sales certifications|sales thresholds]])</small>
  • Only on the first ocurrence, the following should be just Certifications (with no links).

• Done

• ! style="width:3em;font-size:75%;"| [[Billboard 200|US]]<br /><ref>The current references, of course.</ref> (for all similar entries)

• Done

• It would be nice if Worldwide, was shortened to WW, but this means World War, then forget it.
• "—" denotes releases that did not chart or were not released in that country.

• "—" means that the album or song did not chart.

• The Singles is a compilation album or a box set?
  • Should be moved for a Box sets section, and put a notes explain something as its content or other stuff.

• To be fair, a box set is a compilation album which is released in various discs. For that matter, then even Curtain Call: The Hits should be moved to a greatest hits section.— Do U(knome)? ^yes..._{or no} 11:13, 21 December 2008 (UTC)

• You will find information about the Australian Top DVD charts at ARIA report (see MOS:DISCOG).

• Done

***I will work on all of this once I come back home. Thanks 19:00, 20 December 2008 (UTC) Well, I guess I'm back. Anything I missed?— Do U(knome)? ^yes..._{or no} 11:13, 21 December 2008 (UTC)