Wikipedia:Peer review/List of Intercontinental Cup winning managers/archive1
List of Intercontinental Cup winning managers[edit]
| Toolbox |
|---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I would like outsiders' opinion on how to improve this list so that it could receive the featured list rating. Also, any help with referencing would be appreciated.
Thanks, Timbouctou (talk) 14:56, 6 January 2010 (UTC)
- The structure of the table is good, although I'm not sure about the way nationality is done. The columns should be clearly labelled, and I'm not sure if the three letter codes on their own adequately explain the flag. One solution would be to use a key explaining the shorter codes, another would be to use the full country names in these columns too.
- The images and captions are fine, although they need alternative text. And perhaps File:Copa Intercontinental (MAG).JPG could go in the lead?
.JPG&action=edit&redlink=1){kind=link}
- A main concern at FLC would be the lack of inline citation in the lead. My suggestions for citations would be:
- Citations for the various rule changes over the years. You might do this by using one source several times, by using <ref name=rules>{{citeweb|url=...}}</ref> the first time, and simply adding <ref name=rules/> to subsequent statements.
- A citation where it is stated that specific venues hosted the competition in specific year ranges.
- Citation for "The competition was then discontinued and merged into the FIFA Club World Championship which was held for the first time in 2005."
- It should also be explained that winners of the Champions League/European Cup did not always enter.
- The dashes in the table should all be centrally aligned.
- Personally I feel that this is a worthwhile list, but I think some others might have a different view at FLC. Be prepared to justify why this needs to be a stand-alone list if asked.
Hope these comments help. Feel free to contact me on my talk page if you have any further questions. Regards, WFCforLife (talk) 15:03, 13 January 2010 (UTC)