Wikipedia:Peer review/List of shopping centres in the United Kingdom by size/archive1

List of shopping centres in the United Kingdom by size

I've listed this article for peer review because it has had quite a substantial update with new references. The page (including the talk page) has had a tidy up, and it would be an ambition for it to be considered a "featured list".

I'm looking for comments on the list itself and anything else that needs adding, was wondering if a graph showing the history of expansions would be useful.

Thanks, Jayflux (talk) 12:35, 7 May 2019 (UTC)

• It looks very nice and complete. I assume there are reasons you elected not to have the columns sortable and the table with a heading. 174.0.180.176 (talk) 22:40, 27 May 2019 (UTC)

I would like to have the table sortable. I assumed it already is? or at least for me. As for the heading, could you give me an example? Jayflux (talk)

The article is quite far from featured status but here are some suggestions to get started:

• Featured lists no longer use the tautological ""this is a list of". You can start by saying something like "there are x shopping centres in the UK over x size".
• Your criteria needs a reason, why only 70k size? Also this sentence should be a note in the table, not part of the lead.
• The lead is *extremely* thin. There is no depth, completely unsourced, no history, no discussion of the largest etc...
• The article lacks any images. You can probably eve have an image in the table for each mall.
• Annual visitor list is incomplete.
• City/town column sometimes includes other administrative divisions, and sometimes not. Consistency is needed.
• Annual visitors as of when?

Mattximus (talk) 14:11, 4 July 2019 (UTC)